Conflict Analysis of Regional Tourism Development using Game Theories: The Case of Developing Process of Muju Tourist City

Yoo, Kwang-Min; Kim, Jin-Dong; Kim， Nam Jo

Journal of Tourism Sciences

Abbr : JTS
2008, 32(6), pp.233-251
Publisher : The Tourism Sciences Society Of Korea
Research Area : Tourism

Yoo, Kwang-Min ¹, Kim, Jin-Dong ², Kim， Nam Jo ³

¹한양대학교
²강원도립대학
³한양대학교

ABSTRACT

This study adopted the power and game theories to find the primary causes and structure of the conflict among the community involved in Muju tourism & leisure city. In-depth interviews for stakeholders were conducted to collect the data. Authors find that gamer rationally decides conflict strategy in the structure of unbalanced powers between gamers. The gamer also takes conflict strategy when there is no confidential network between gamers. However, if there is confidential network(e.g. governance) between gamers, the gamer rationally takes collaboration strategy to obtain maximum benefits. This study implies that it is very difficult to virtually make a collaborated relations among stakeholders in lack of confidential situation.
KEYWORDS

Game theory, Conflict of regional tourism development, Tourism & Leisure Enterprise City
REFERENCES (35)

[journal] 강인호 / 2005 / A Study of Interlocalgovernmental Conflict Management through Possessing Jurisdiction -focusing on making uylcon industrial-complex- / 한국지역개발학회지 / 한국지역개발학회 17(3) : 61~82

[thesis] 구본일 / 2004 / 골프에 의한 환경갈등과 대안적 환경정책 방안 연구 / 박사 / 대구대학교

[journal] 김남조 / 2008 / Analysis of Conflict Structure Occurring Development Processof Tourism-Leisure Type Enterprise Cities Using Emic and Etic Approaches / 관광학연구 / 한국관광학회 32(3) : 61~81

[journal] 김일철 / 1984 / 사회발전과 갈등 / 한국사회학 18 : 135~149

[journal] 김창수 / 1996 / 지역관광개발계획과정의 집단간 갈등요인 / 관광학연구 20(1) : 242~259

[book] 나태준 / 2004 / 갈등해결의 제도적 접근: 현행갈등관련 제도분석 및 대안 / 한국행정연구원

[book] 듀크 / 1976 / 갈등과 권력-갈등론적 사회학의 전개 / Brigham Young University Press

[book] 문화관광부 / 2007 / 관광레저형기업도시 갈등관리 및 공공갈등 사례 / 관광레저도시추진기획단 : 27~63

[book] 박주현 / 2001 / 게임이론의 이해 / 해남

[book] 신성휘 / 2006 / 게임이론 길라잡이 / 박영사

[journal] 신용석 / 2005 / An Exploratory Research into the Framework of Stakeholders in a Local Festival: Power Struggles among Stakeholders / 관광학연구 / 한국관광학회 28(4) : 295~312

[journal] 안석교 / 2006 / Social Conflict - Economic Policy - Code of Conduct / 국제경제연구 / 한국국제경제학회 12(1) : 1~13

[journal] 안형기 / 1999 / 친환경 정치행동화: 사회ㆍ심리적 접근과 합리적 선택의 관점 / 한국행정학보 33(4) : 398~409

[journal] 유양섭 / 2002 / 게임이론을 통한 골프장건설정책 연구-가야산 국립공원을 중심으로 / 한국학교체육학회지 12(2) : 133~145

[journal] 윤상헌 / 2006 / Tourism Development and Conflicts : A Case of the Abandoned Mine Area in Southern Gangwon Province / 관광학연구 / 한국관광학회 30(3) : 71~89

[book] 이연택 / 2003 / 관광정책론 / 일신사

[book] 자그 / 1984 / 게임이론 : 개념과 응용 / Sage Publications

[journal] 정준표 / 1994 / 집단행동과 게임이론 / 한국정치학회보 27(2) : 109~139

[journal] 정준표 / 2003 / The Concept of Rationality in the Rational Choice Theory / 대한정치학회보 / 대한정치학회 11(2) : 415~439

[thesis] 최재근 / 2005 / 관광단지 개발과 토지보상 갈등에 관한 연구:해남 화원관광단지를 사례로 / 석사 / 한양대학교 국제관광대학원

[journal] Ap, J. / 1992 / Residents' perception on tourism impacts / Annals of Tourism Research 19(4) : 665~690

[journal] Fallon, F. / 2001 / Conflict, Power and Tourism on Lombok / Current Issues in Tourism 4(6) : 481~502

[journal] Hall, C. M. / 1994 / Tourism and Politics, Policy, Power and Place / John Wiley & Sons 2 : 20~58

[book] Harsanyi, J. / 1988 / A General Theory of Equilibrium Selection in Games / MIT Press

[journal] Hermandez, S. / 1996 / Residents' attitudes towards: an instant resort enclave / Annals of Tourism Research 23(4) : 755~779

[journal] Heywood, John L. / 1993 / Game theory: A basis for analyzing emerging norms and conventions in outdoor recreation / Leisure Science 15 : 37~48

[journal] Madrigal, R, / 1993 / A tale of tourism in two cities / Annal of Tourism Research 20 : 336~353

[journal] Markwick, Marion C. / 2000 / Golf tourism development, stakeholders, differing discourses and alternatives agenda: the case of Malta / Tourism Management 21 : 515~524

[journal] McKercher, B. / 2005 / Relationship between tourism and cultural heritage management: evidence from Hong Kong / Tourism Management 26 : 539~548

[journal] Reed, Maureen G. / 1997 / Power Relations and community based tourism planning / Annals of Tourism Research 24(3) : 566~591

[journal] Sharpley, R. / 2000 / Tourism and Sustainable development: Exploring the theoretical divide / Journal of Sustainable Tourism 18(1) : 1~19

[journal] Timothy, D. / 1999 / Participatory planing: A view of tourism in Indonesia / Annals of Tourism Research 26(2) : 371~391

[journal] Tosun, C. / 2000 / Limits to community participation in the tourism development process in developing countries / Tourism Management 121 : 613~633

[web] / / www.jd.re.kr

[web] / 전북일보,2007.1.30 / www.jjan.kr
KCI Citation (9)

KJC Korea
Journal Central

Statistics

Tools