Understanding Conflicts in the Tourism Development: An Application of Weber's Theory of Action

구경여; Taehong Ahn

Journal of Tourism Sciences

Abbr : JTS
2010, 34(4), pp.331-352
Publisher : The Tourism Sciences Society Of Korea
Research Area : Tourism

구경여 ¹, Taehong Ahn ²

¹숙명여자대학교
²서울과학종합대학원

ABSTRACT

This study is to demonstrate a possibile way for conflict management in regional tourism development by examining proper action orientation in a specific conflict between the local residents and other stakeholder. Previous conflict management studies mainly focus on conflicts between the groups, and they eventually lead to the negative effects on a development project. From the perspective, the possible solution for the conflict is merely to gather opinions from the involved groups via official channels. However, this study approaches the conflicts between the regional tourism developers and the local residents differently based upon Weber's four types of social actions, i.e., instrumentally rational, value-rational, affectual and traditional action. Especially Weber's theory of action will help us to understand the types of action that would be matched with a specific type of conflict in a regional tourism development.
KEYWORDS

Weber's theory of action, Tourism development conflicts, Actor constraints
REFERENCES (64)

[journal] 강인원 / 2006 / 지역관광개발에 대한 주민의식 성향 비교 연구 : 울산광역시 울주군을 중심으로 / 문화관광연구 8(1) : 45~63

[web] 경향신문 / 2004년9월24일, 해공에 뜬 지역개발/해남관광단지 / http://www.kinds.or.kr/

[journal] 고동완 / 2003 / Community Attachment and Attitudes Toward Tourism Development / 관광학연구 / 한국관광학회 27(3) : 97~114

[journal] 구경여 / 2010 / The Effects of Regional Tourism Development Policy and Actor Constraints on Private Investment / 관광연구 / 대한관광경영학회 24(6) : 85~105

[web] 국민일보 / 1990년8월21일, 영종ㆍ용유지역 종합개발계획의 사전유출 의혹 / http://www.kinds.or.kr/

[web] 국민일보 / 2003년4월8일, 도시민의 무질서한 행락 농어촌 주민 불만 부추겨 / http://www.kinds.or.kr/

[book] 김덕영 / 2004 / 짐멜이냐 베버냐?: 사회학 발달과정 비교연구 / 한울

[journal] 김두환 / 2007 / Resolution of Interest Conflict on Urban Development through Resident-Participation / 시민사회와 NGO / 제3섹터연구소 5(1) : 241~268

[book] 김성진 / 1984 / 베버 종교 사회학의 이론적 함축성. in: 사회학연구 / 대영사

[journal] 김재권 / 2006 / Understanding Actions: Normativity and the Agent's Point of View / 철학사상 / 철학사상연구소 20(23) : 3~29

[journal] 김태보 / 2009 / 환경가치로 본 제주개발의 과제 / 지역사회발전학회논문집 34(1) : 1~19

[journal] 김형미 / 2007 / An Analysis on the Influential Factors of Inter-regional Conflicts in Tourism Development: A Case of the Abandoned Mine Area in Southern Gangwon Province / 관광·레저연구 / 한국관광.레저학회 19(2) : 35~55

[journal] 김창수 / 1996 / 지역관광개발계획과정의 집단간 갈등요인 / 관광학연구 20(1) : 242~259

[book] 박경식 / 1984 / 사회학 이론과 현실세계: 사회 행위이론의 재인식. in: 사회학연구 / 대영사

[book] 박성환 / 1992 / 막스 베버의 문화사회학과 인류학 / 문학과 지성

[book] Weber Ma / 1997 / 경제와 사회 I(Wirtschaft und Gesellschaft) / 문학과 지성사

[book] 박연호 / 1988 / 조직관리론 / 법문사

[book] 박종화 / 1995 / 지역개발론 / 박영사

[journal] 변우희 / 1996 / AHP를 이용한 경주권 관광개발 제약요인 평가에 관한 연구 / 관광⋅레저연구 18(2) : 65~83

[book] Habermas / 1995 / 소통행위이론 1: 행위합리성과 사회적 합리화(JurgenTheorie des kommunikatiuen handelns) / 의암출판사

[journal] 안승국 / 2001 / 대만의 민주화과정 분석: 정치행위자의 전략과 선택을 중심으로 / 한국행정학회보 36(2) : 283~299

[journal] 안종철 / 2003 / 관광단지개발에 있어서 주민참여방안에 관한 연구 / 도시연구보 14 : 89~98

[journal] 이연택 / 2003 / 제주국제자유도시계획과 국가관광정책의 과제 / 행정문제논문집 19 : 37~54

[journal] 이연택 / 2004 / Community Participation in the National Tourism Policy:Addressing Tourism Policy Issues / 관광학연구 / 한국관광학회 28(3) : 143~160

[journal] 이영아 / 2009 / Exploring Key Facts of Residents' Participation for Local Capacity Building / 한국지역지리학회지 / 한국지역지리학회 15(2) : 261~272

[journal] 이정식 / 2002 / Socio-Ethical Problems dued to Environment Destruction of Sport and Counterplans / 움직임의 철학 : 한국체육철학회지 / 한국체육철학회 10(1) : 151~174

[book] 이종수 / 1983 / 막스베버의 학문과 사상 / 한길사

[journal] 이환기 / 1995 / 대구근교권의 관광지 및 관광자원의 실태와 문제점 / 관광연구 5 : 145~165

[journal] 염미경 / 2007 / Local Development and the Politics of Residents' Interests:A Case of the Neighboring Village of Jungmoon Tourism Resort in Jeju Island / 한국사회학 / 한국사회학회 41(3) : 1~31

[journal] 유재원 / 2002 / Analyzing Influence of Major External Actors Upon Local Bureaucracy / 한국정책학회보 / 한국정책학회 11(4) : 23~26

[journal] 윤상헌 / 2006 / Tourism Development and Conflicts : A Case of the Abandoned Mine Area in Southern Gangwon Province / 관광학연구 / 한국관광학회 30(3) : 71~89

[journal] 윤지현 / 2008 / The impact of Community Attachment on the Residents' attitudes toward tourism development / 관광경영연구 / 관광경영학회 12(2) : 76~102

[book] 진영재 / 2004 / 지역관광개발론 / 대왕사

[journal] 정삼철 / 2002 / 충주지역 관광산업의 개발 전략 2 : 47~68

[book] 정익준 / 2003 / 관광체계론 / 형설출판사

[journal] 최승묵 / 2005 / Attitudes of Tourism-involved Civil Servants towards Tourism Development / 관광학연구 / 한국관광학회 29(1) : 209~227

[journal] 최희선 / 2005 / A Study for Natural Conservation Value Assessment of Developing Area- Case Study of Alpensia Resort - / 한국조경학회지 / 한국조경학회 33(4) : 108~118

[journal] 한세억 / 2002 / A Study on the change and characteristic of Informatization Policy in Korea / 한국정책학회보 / 한국정책학회 11(3) : 21~46

[journal] 한범수 / 1998 / 충청북도 관광개발계획의 실현성 평가: 충주호 관광개발계획을 중심으로 / 관광학연구 22(특별)

[web] 한겨레 / 2010년2월12일, 동부산관광단지 원영보존 훼손되나 / http://www.kinds.or.kr/

[web] 한국일보 / 2000년8월2일, 지금 이곳에선/ 설악⋅금강권 개발계획 밀실에서 나와라 / http://www.kinds.or.kr/

[journal] 황기형 / 2001 / 지속가능한 어촌관광개발과 주민참여 / 월간해양수산 198 : 1~15

[book] Anthony, G. / 2003 / 현대 사회학(Sociology. 4th ed.) / 을유문화사

[journal] Brohman, J. / 1996 / New ddirections in tourism for third world development / Annals of Tourism Research 23(1) : 48~70

[book] Davidson, D. / 1970 / Action, Reason, and Causes. in Essays on Actions and Events / Oxford University Press

[journal] Farrel, B. H. / 1979 / Tourism's human conflicts: Cases from the Pacific / Annals of Tourism Research 6(2) : 122~136

[book] Greenstein, F. I. / 1987 / Personality and Politics: Problems of evidence, inference and conceptualization / Current edition Princetion Univeristh Press

[book] Howard, J. / 1974 / The Cutting Edge: Social Movements and Social Change in America / Lippincott

[book] Hodge, B. / 1988 / Organization theory. 3rd ed. / Allyn & Bacon

[book] Hirschman, A. O. / 1965 / Models of Reform-Mongering. Albert O. Hirschman. Journeys toward Progress: Studies of Economic Policy-Making in Latin American / Doubleday

[book] Jessop, B. / 1997 / The Governance of Complexity and the Complexity of Governance: Preliminary Remarks on Some Problems and Limits of Economic Guidance. In Ash Amin and Jerzy Hausner. in: Beyond market and Hierarchy: Interactive Governance and Social Complexity / Edward Elgar : 95~128

[book] Jurgen, H. / 1995 / 소통행위이론 1: 행위합리성과 사회적 합리화(Theorie des kommunikatiuen handelns) / 의암출판

[book] Knoke, D. / 1982 / Network Analysis / Beverly Hills

[journal] Mitchell, R. E. / 2001 / Community Integration: Island Tourism in Peru / Annals of Tourism Research 8(1) : 113~139

[book] Parsons, T. / 1977 / Social systems and the evolution of action theory / Free Press

[journal] Pearce, J. A. / 1980 / Host community acceptance of foreign tourists / Annals of Tourism Research 7(2) : 224~233

[book] Przeworski, A. / 1986 / Some Problems in the Study of the Transition to Democracy. in: Transition from Authoritarian Rule: Comparative Perspective / Johns hopkins University Press

[book] Schluchte, W. / 1981 / The Rise of Western Rationalism / Universith of California Press : 128~138

[journal] Sheldon, P. J. / 1984 / Resident attitudes to tourism in North Wales / Tourism Management 5(1) : 40~47

[book] Stewart, C. / 1979 / The Theory of Power and Organization / Routledge & Kegan Paul

[other] Stephan, K. / 1980 / Max Weber Typen der Rationalitat. in: Grundsteine fur die Analyss von Rationalisierungs-Prozessen in der Geschichte /

[journal] Um, S. H. / 1987 / Measuring Resident's Attachment Levelo in a host community / Journal of Travel Research 26(1) : 27~28

[book] Weber, Max / 1964 / Max Weber: The Theory of Social and Economic Organiaztion. Translated by A.M. Henderson and Talcott Parsons / The Free Press

[book] Weber, Max / 1968 / Economy and Society: An Outline of Interpretive Sociology / Bedminster Press
KCI Citation (11)

KJC Korea
Journal Central

Statistics

Tools