Some Issues of Empirical Studies on Leisure Tastes:Focusing on the Studies of Cultural Capital Theory

Kwang-Eik Cho

This study tried to explore the problems and limitations of empirical studies of Bourdieu's cultural capital theory on leisure tastes in Korea. After reviewing Bourdieu's cultural capital theory and previous studies, several limitations of empirical studies on leisure tastes are discussed. First, theoretical frame of previous empirical study on leisure tastes simplified the Bourdieu's original cultural capital theory. Second, definition of cultural capital, operationalization of the concept and measurement of the concept are critical to verifying the theory. Most empirical studies used respondent's educational level as embodied cultural capital. However, it isn't agreed to determine which is the most appropriate way to measure embodied type of cultural capital. Also, rank of university in Korea respondents graduated should be seriously regarded as independent variable. Finally, many empirical studies analyzed leisure preference than mode of leisure consumption. I proposed that lifestyle of leisure should be analysed.

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (9)
열림/닫힘 버튼
REFERENCES (64)
열림/닫힘 버튼
* 2021년 이후 발행 논문의 참고문헌은 현재 구축 중입니다.

[journal] 강준만 / 1995 / 피에르 부르디외, 왜 중요한가? / 한국사회와 언론 5 : 277~306

[journal] 김은미 / 2011 / Profiling Cultural Omnivores in Korea: Quantity and Breadth of Cultural Consumption / 한국언론학보 / 한국언론학회 55(5) : 205~233

[journal] 김은미 / 2012 / Television Viewing as an Act of Cultural Consumption: Omnivore Hypothesis and the Diversity of Broadcasting Content Consumption / 한국방송학보 / 한국방송학회 26(3) : 135~175

[book] 닷슨 / 1998 / 포퓰러 컬처와 매스 컬처의 차이, In 현대사회와 대중문화 / 나남출판

[journal] 박상곤 / 2006 / Effects of Cultural Capital on Leisure Consumption / 관광학연구 / 한국관광학회 30(6) : 241~258

[book] 부르디외, P. / 1996 / 구별짓기 上, 下 / 새물결

[book] 부르디외, P. / 2000 / 재생산 / 동문선

[book] 부르디외, P. / 1995 / 상징폭력과 문화재생산 / 새물결

[journal] 서우석 / 2007 / Impacts of the Socioeconomic Environments on the Leisure Activities of the Youth / 한국청소년연구 / 한국청소년정책연구원 18(1) : 273~302

[book] 쉴즈, E. / 1998 / 대중사회와 문화, In 현대사회와 대중문화 / 나남출판

[book] 아도르노, T. W. / 1995 / 계몽의 변증법 / 문예출판사

[book] 양종회 / 2005 / 문화예술사회학 / 도서출판 그린

[journal] 양종회 / 2009 / 문화적 취향의 분화와 계급 - 음악장르를 중심으로 / 한국사회학 / 한국사회학회 43(5) : 170~209

[journal] 이일열 / 2012 / The Dialectics of Modernity and Orientalism Reflected on the Formation of the Leisure and Tourism Pattern: A Case Study of the Japan Ruling-era / 관광학연구 / 한국관광학회 36(6) : 11~35

[journal] 이호영 / 2008 / Cultural Capital and Its Impact onthe Omnivorousness of Movie Preferences / 한국사회학 / 한국사회학회 42(1) : 62~95

[journal] 장미혜 / 2001 / 문화자본과 소비양식의 차이 / 한국사회학 35(3) : 51~81

[journal] 장미혜 / 2002 / Cultural Reproduction of Social Class: Effects of Cultural Capital on Student Ability Test / 한국사회학 / 한국사회학회 36(4) : 8~27

[journal] 전범수 / 2004 / Cultural Patterns of Movie Genre Choice / 한국방송학보 / 한국방송학회 18(3) : 554~597

[book] 정일준 / 1995 / 편역자 서문: 왜 부르디외인가?: 문제는 ‘상징권력’이다, In 상징폭력과 문화재생산 / 새물결

[book] 조광익 / 2006 / 현대관광과 문화이론 / 일신사

[journal] 조광익 / 2006 / Mode of Leisure Consumption and Cultural Capital: Bourdieu's Cultural Theory / 관광학연구 / 한국관광학회 30(1) : 379~401

[journal] 조광익 / 2006 / Cultural Tourism and New Middle Class: rpretation from Cultural Capital Theory / 관광학연구 / 한국관광학회 30(6) : 135~154

[book] 조광익 / 2010 / 여가의 사회이론 / 대왕사

[journal] 조광익 / 2012 / Reviewing the Empirical Studies on Leisure Consumption and Identity / 관광연구논총 / 관광연구소 24(4) : 3~24

[journal] 조돈문 / 2005 / Social Classes and Culture in Korea / 한국사회학 / 한국사회학회 39(2) : 1~33

[journal] 조은 / 2001 / 문화 자본과 계급 재생산 : 계급별 일상 생활 경험을 중심으로 / 사회와 역사 60 : 166~205

[journal] 최샛별 / 2002 / High-Class Women and Cultural Capital in Consolidating High-Class BoundaryKorean Case: Females Majoring in Western Classical Music / 한국사회학 / 한국사회학회 36(1) : 5~28

[journal] 최샛별 / 2006 / Does Cultural Capital Exist in Korean Society? / 문화와 사회 / 한국문화사회학회 1(1) : 123~158

[journal] 최샛별 / 2012 / Basic Research for Constituting the South Korean Society’s Cultural Capital Topographic Map:Based on Culture and Art Activities and Music Genre / 조사연구 / 한국조사연구학회 13(1) : 61~87

[journal] 최샛별 / 2012 / 음악장르, 여가활동, TV프로그램 선호분석을 통해 본 한국 사회의 문화 지형도 / 한국사회학 / 한국사회학회 46(2) : 34~60

[journal] 최영섭 / 2000 / 한국인의 문화 소비 결정요인에 대한 일 고찰 / 문화정책논총 12 : 229~260

[journal] 한교남 / 2011 / Differentiation between Social Class Leisure Consumption in Korea: By Focusing on Art and Culture / 관광학연구 / 한국관광학회 35(10) : 181~199

[book] 한국교육개발원 / 2011 / 교육통계연보 / 한국교육개발원

[report] 한국문화관광연구원 / 2008 / 문화향수 실태조사 / 한국문화관광연구원

[journal] 한신갑 / 2007 / Grammar of Distinction in Korea:Mapping the Cultural Landscape of Koea through Leisure Activities in 2005 / 한국사회학 / 한국사회학회 41(2) : 211~239

[journal] 한준 / 2007 / Cultural Boundary and Cultral Hierarchy among Korean People / 문화와 사회 / 한국문화사회학회 2(1) : 29~53

[book] 홀, S. / 1998 / 문화연구의 두 패러다임, In 현대사회와 대중문화 / 나남출판

[book] 홍성민 / 2000 / 문화와 아비투스 / 나남출판

[book] 홍성민 / 2002 / 아비투스와 계급, In 문화와 계급 / 동문선

[book] 홍성민 / 2004 / 피에르 부르디외와 한국사회 / 살림

[book] 홍성민 / 2012 / 취향의 정치학 / 현암사

[book] Kelly, J. R. / 2004 / 여가사회학 / 도서출판 그린

[journal] Aschaffenburg, K. / 1997 / Cultural and educational careers : The dynamics of social reproduction / American Sociological Review 62(4) : 573~587

[journal] Atkinson, W. / 2011 / The context and genesis of musical tastes: Omnivorousness debunked, Bourdieu buttressed / Poetics 39 : 169~186

[book] Bourdieu, P. / 1984 / Distinction: A social critique of the judgement of taste / Harvard University Press

[journal] Bryson, B. / 1996 / "Anything but heavy metal" : Symbolic exclusion and musical dislikes / American Sociological Review 61 : 884~899

[journal] Chan, T. W. / 2007 / Social stratification and cultural consumption : The visual arts in England / Poetics 35 : 168~190

[journal] De Graaf, N. D. / 2000 / Parental cultural capital and educational attainment in the Netherlands : A refinement of the cultural capital perspective / Sociology of Education 73 : 92~111

[journal] De Graaf, P. M. / 1986 / The impact of financial and cultural resources on educational attainment in the Netherlands / Sociology of Education 59 : 237~246

[journal] DiMaggio, P. / 1979 / Review essay : On Pierre Bourdieu / American Journal of Sociology 84(6) : 1460~1474

[journal] DiMaggio, P. / 1982 / Cultural capital and school success : The impact of status cultural participation of the grades of U. S. high school student / American Sociological Review 47 : 182~201

[journal] DiMaggio, P. / 1985 / Cultural capital, educational attainment, and martial selection / American Journal of Sociology 90 : 1231~1261

[journal] DiMaggio, P. / 1978 / Cultural democracy in a period of cultural expansion / Social Problems 28 : 180~197

[journal] Dumais, S. A. / 2002 / Cultural capital, gender, and school success : The role of habitus / Sociology of Education 75(1) : 44~68

[journal] Dumais, S. A. / 2010 / Cultural capital and first-generation college success / Poetics 38 : 245~265

[journal] Holt, D. B. / 1997 / Distinction in America? Recovering Bourdieu’s theory of tastes from its critics / Poetics 25 : 93~120

[journal] Holt, D. B. / 1998 / Does cultural capital structure American consumption? / Journal of Consumer Research 25 : 1~25

[journal] Kane, D. / 2003 / Distinction worldwide? : Bourdieu's theory of taste in international context / Poetics 31 : 403~421

[journal] Katz-Gerro, T. / 2002 / Highbrow cultural consumption and class distinction in Italy, Israel, West Germany, Sweden, and the United States / Social Forces 81(1) : 207~229

[journal] Kraaykamp, G. / 1999 / Preferences in leisure time book reading : A study on the social differentiation in book reading for the Netherlands / Poetics 26 : 203~234

[journal] Lamont, M. / 1988 / Cultural capital : Allusions, gaps and glissandos in recent theoretical development / Sociological Theory 6(2) : 153~168

[book] OECD / 2011 / OECD Factbook 2011-2012 / OECD Publishing

[journal] Peterson, R. A. / 1997 / The rise and fall of highbrow snobbery as a status marker / Poetics 25 : 75~92

[journal] Peterson, R. A. / 2005 / Problems in comparative research : The example of omnivorousness / Poetics 33 : 257~282

KJC Korea
Journal Central

Statistics

Tools

Sharing

Issue List

Citation status