Research on the Modification of Folktales’ Motifs
DOI : 10.21049/ccs.2015.39..241
Publisher : Center for Cross Culture Studies
Research Area : Literature
-
This study explores how folktales’ motifs are used in diverse cultural contents such as literature, movies, or comics. More precisely, it is concerned with mysterious characters like Babayaga and Koshchei who appear in Russian fairytales. When the motifs of the reviewed literature are analyzed, the following three criteria are used for classification: New Writing, Rewriting, and New Version. Or course, it is New Writing that is far from the original work. Most of the collected works, including Joan Aiken’s The Kingdom Under the Sea, Patricia Polacco’s Babushka’s Doll, Babushka Baba Yaga, and Taï-Marc Le Thanh’s BABAYAGA, belong to New Writing. The New Writing type mainly focuses on Babayaga’s secluded life. In fairytales, Babayaga is depicted as the goddess of Mother Earth, the heroine of the Nature, or the ruler of the Animal Kingdom. That is why she lives in the deep and uninhabited wood. She is related to the Coming of Age ceremony. Her ‘Hut on hen’s legs’ is an obstacle for immature protagonists to face before they come of age. Protagonists are supposed to solve the problems posed by Babayaga. If they succeed, they can get her magical help so as to complete their final mission. Babayaga is likely to appear as their antagonist. Protagonist may be subjected to a terrible ordeal created by Babayaga, and then come of age by recovering from that ordeal. Sometimes, Babayaga helps protagonists to get a grip on reality. That is why she lives in a hut in the deep and dark forest which is on the borderline between life and death. On the other hand, Marianna Mayer’s Baba Yaga and Vasilisa the Brave has been classified as a controversial work between New Writing and Rewriting. It is apparently closer to New Version. However, it cannot be classified as a work of New Version because the author incorporates ‘probability’ into her work. Among the reviewed works, it is Korean Writer Rye, Kami’s The Spider Woman’s House that best reflects the essence of Babayaga. Babayaga and other characters are amusing in movies because most of the movies are animations for children. In one sense, it is positive that the scary characters in folktales are approachable to children. In other sense, however, it is regrettable that symbolic motifs are completely eliminated. In Mike Mignola’s Hellboy, Japanese animations such as Index or Narutaru, on-line games such as Cabal or Vampire: The masquerade, the essence of the supernatural characters in folktales is completely eliminated, and only their ‘belligerent power’ stands out. It is desirable to put stories into perspective whether they are written or told. The literature property of folktales provides a special opportunity to readers. In this light, a variety of motifs have a good reason to be reborn as modern cultural contents. The bottom line is to maintain its true nature.
-
[book] 류가미 / 2003 / 거미 여인의 집 / 이룸
[book] 마리안나 마이어 / 2003 / 바바 야가와 용감한 바실리사 / 한국프뢰벨
[book] 이미현 / 2010 / 바바야가(The Tale of Babayaga) / 상명대 애니메이션학과
[book] 조안 에이킨 / 2007 / 바다 속 왕국 / 논장
[book] 키토 모히로 / 1999 / 드래곤 드림1 / 세주문화
[book] 타이마르크 르 탕 / 2008 / 바바야가 / 비룡소
[book] 패트리샤 폴라코 / 2003 / 바바야가 할머니 / 시공주니어
[book] 프로프 / 1990 / 민담의 역사적 기원 / 문학과 지성사
[book] 하이어윈 오럼 / 2003 / 슬기로운 인형 / 국민서관
[other] / 2008 / Baba Yaga, Школа на курьих ножках / Медиахауз
[book] HANS-JÖRG, Uther / 2004 / A Classification and Bibliography / Academia Scientiarum Fennica
[book] HIAWY, N Oram / 1998 / Baba Yaga and the Wise Doll / Dutton Juvenile
[book] JOAN, Aiken / 1971 / The Kingdom Under the Sea / Puffin Books
[book] MAYER, Marianna / 1994 / Baba Yaga and Vasilisa the Brave / Morrow Junior Books
[book] MIGNOLA, Mike / 1998 / Hellboy - The Baba Yaga / Dark Horse Comics
[book] MIGNOLA, Mike / 2009 / Hellboy - Wild hunt #4, Baba yaga's feast / Dark Horse Comics
[book] MIGNOLA, Mike / 1998 / Hellboy: The Chained Coffin and The Baba Yaga / Dark Horse Comics
[book] MIGNOLA, Mike / 1994 / Hellboy / Dark Horse Comics
[book] MIGNOLA, Mike / 2009 / Hellboy, The Wild hunt #2, #3, How Koshchei Became Deathless / Dark Horse Comics
[book] POLACCO, Patricia / 1993 / Babushka Baba Yaga / Penguin Putnam Inc
[book] Taï-Marc Le Thanh / 2003 / BABAYAGA / Hachette Livre
[book] А. Давыдов / 1989 / Два богатыря / союзмультфильм
[book] Александр Афанасьев / 2010 / Народные русские сказки. Полное издание в одномтоме / Альфа-книга
[book] Андрей Усачёв / 2004 / Большая книга Бабы Яги / Оникс : 5~
[book] Афанасьев, А. Н. / 1936 / Народные русские сказки, том I / академиа
[book] Афанасьев, А. Н. / 1986 / Народные русские сказки, том II / наука
[book] Афанасьев, А. Н. / 1985 / Народные русские сказки, том III / наука
[book] В. Пекарь / 1979 / Баба-Яга против! / Киностудия союзмультфильм
[book] И. Иванов / 1949 / Гуси лебеди / союзмультфильм
[book] М. Цехановский / 1954 / Царевна-лягушка / Киностудия союзмультфильм
[other] Максим Свешников / 2014 / Baba Yaga
[book] Пропп, В. Я. / 2000 / Исторические корни волшебной сказки / Лабиринт
[other] Сергей Карпов / 2006 / Бабка Ежка и другие / United Multimedia Projects
[book] 鎌池和馬 / 2004 / とある魔術の禁書目録 / 電撃文庫
[book] 鎌池和馬 / 2007 / 少年ガンガン
[book] 鬼頭莫宏 / 2002 / なるたる-骸なる星 珠たる子 9 / 講談社
-
KCI Citation (0)
223 Viewed
Print this page
Download PDF