The Active Way of Trauma: Receiving the Return of the Past

Gilwan, Seoh

doi:10.21049/ccs.2015.41..33

Trauma studies have provided useful models for dealing with the catastrophic and disastrous events that an individual and collective group experience. Most important of all, the perspective of post-structuralist trauma study, including Cathy Caruth, became a paradigmatic model and it has been applied to almost all contexts of life. The perspective of this study model, which is called an “event-based model of trauma,” focuses on the literal registration of the traumatic event and the accurate and immediate recall of the past. The person directly involved in the event becomes the passive bearer transmitting the truth of a traumatic event. From this perspective, the traumatic subject only undergoes and endures the event and cannot play an active role in constructing trauma and dealing with it. Eventually, the truth of trauma has to be obtained at the cost of the traumatic subject’s autonomy and the possibility of his/her agency. The problem here is that the truth, which is reencountered through the literal return of the past, obtained at the cost of the subject’s autonomy, strikes a rather fatal blow to the person, than gives help for resolving many of matters surrounding traumatic experience and curing trauma. This suggests that the active way of dealing with trauma on the part of the traumatic subject, rather than the traumatic event itself, is demanded. Furthermore, because more recently, images of disastrous events were viewed “live” by audiences and an immediacy to the event is replicated in public discourse about them, the event becomes more immediately traumatic and there is a more strong presumption that people regard themselves as traumatic victims than before. This is the reason that we must explore an active way dealing with trauma on more human position at this time. This essay aims to examine the limits of the paradigmatic model of trauma study, an “event-based model of trauma,” critically through a literary, theoretical text in which it reveals how the literal return of the traumatic past have a fatal effect on the victim; and hopes to suggest “the narrative memory” as a way to deal with trauma from a more humanistic perspective.

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (5)
열림/닫힘 버튼
REFERENCES (25)
열림/닫힘 버튼
* 2021년 이후 발행 논문의 참고문헌은 현재 구축 중입니다.

[book] 오카, 마리 / 2004 / 기억⋅서사 / 소명출판사

[book] 수잔, 브라이슨 / 2003 / 이야기 해 그리고 다시 살아나 / 인향

[book] 오노레, 발자크 / 2000 / 사랑과 행복의 비밀 / 큰나무

[book] 이명호 / 2014 / 누가 안티고네를 두려워하는가: 성차의 문화정치 / 문학동네

[book] 주디스, 허먼 / 2007 / 트라우마 : 가정폭력에서 정치적 테러까지 / 플래닛

[book] CARUTH, Cathy / 1996 / Trauma: Exploration in Memory / Johns Hopkins UP

[book] DELBO, Charotte / 1995 / Auschwiz and After / Yale UP

[book] GIBBS, Alan / 2014 / Contemporary American Trauma Narratives / Edinburgh UP

[book] FELMAN, Shoshana / 2002 / The Juridical Unconscious: Trials and Traumas in the Twentieth Century / Harvard UP

[book] HENKE, Suzette / 2008 / A Shattered Subjects : Trauma and Testimony in Women's Life-writing / St. Martin's P

[book] HUYSSEN, Andreas / 2003 / Present Pasts : Urban Palimpsests and the Politics of Memory / Stanford UP

[book] JUDITH Greenberg / 2003 / Trauma at home: after 9/11 / U of Nebraska P

[book] LACAPRA, Dominick / 2004 / History in Transit: Experience, Identity, Critical Theory / Cornell UP

[book] LEGIN K, Ursula / 1989 / Dancing at the Edge of the World: Thoughts on the Words, Women, Place / Grove

[book] LEYS, Ruth / 2000 / Trauma: A Genealogy / U of Chicago P

[book] MEEK, Allen / 2010 / Trauma and Media: Theories, Histories, and Images / Routledge

[journal] MICCICHE, Laura R / 2001 / Writing Through Traum / Composition Studies 29(1) : 131~141

[journal] RADSTONE, Susannah / 2007 / Trauma Theory: Context, Politics, Ethics / Paragraph 30(1) : 9~29

[book] ROSS, Gina / 2003 / Beyond the Trauma Vortex: The Media's Role in Healing Fear, Terror, & Violence / North Atlantic Books

[book] SHACTER, Daniel / 1996 / Searching for Memory: the Brain, the Mind, and the Past / Basic Books

[book] SHAY, Jonathan / 1994 / Achilles in Vietnam: Combat Trauma and the Undoing of Character / Atheneum

[book] SHERER, Miggel / 1992 / Still Loved by the Sun: A Rape Survivor’s Journal / Simon& Schurster

[book] TAL, Kali / 1996 / Worlds of Hurt: Reading the Literatures of Trauma / Cambridge UP

[journal] VAN del Kolk, Bessel / 1995 / Dissociation and the Fragmentary Nature of Traumatic Memories: Overview and Exploratory Study / Journal of Traumatic Stress 8(4) : 505~525

[book] YOUNG, Allan / 1995 / The Harmony of Illusions : Inventing Post-Traumatic Stress Disorder / Princeton UP

KJC Korea
Journal Central

Statistics

Tools

Sharing

Issue List

Citation status