The Paradox of Grant Allen’s Physiological Reductionism

Lee, Sungbum

doi:10.21049/ccs.2016.44..411

One of central issues in the Literature and Science discourses during the Victorian era is the relation of physiology to psychology. Many thinkers tackle the question of whether or not psychic phenomena can be reducible to their physiological bases. For instance, Victorian physiologist William Benjamin Carpenter claims that there should be a boundary between physiological and psychological qualities. Yet, his contemporary writer Grant Allen contends for the reduction of psychology into physiology. In the essay, I discuss Grant Allen’s work Physiological Aesthetics (1877) so as to eventually problematize his physiological reductionism. I especially highlight the paradox of his physiological aesthetics. In order to clarify my argument, I introduce two concepts: evolutionary aesthetics and physiological reductionism. On the one hand, Allen argues for the development of aesthetic appreciation. The gradual evolution from gaudy to serene colors, for instance, reflects the fine differentiation of sensory organs. He believes that the existence of varied aesthetic pleasures corresponds to the evolution of sensory nerve structures. Nonetheless, Allen ironically gives more weight to the commonality of aesthetic experiences than to this teleological ordering of aesthetic experiences. He argues that there is no fundamental difference among humans in terms of their aesthetic assessments. Furthermore, there is even no essential distinction among plants, animals, and humans in light of their aesthetic appraisals, he states firmly. Although he asserts the gradual advance of aesthetic feelings caused by the intricacy of nervous systems, he simultaneously trivializes the evolution of aesthetic appraisal. In the essay, I highlight this paradox in Allen’s physiological aesthetics. It should be underscored, lamentably enough, that Allen seeks biological purity by erasing fine lines among physiology, psychology, and sociality. He estranges aesthetic experiences from subjective variations and their socio-cultural contexts. He makes great efforts to eliminate individual differences and socio-cultural specificities in order to extremely biologize aesthetic experiences. Hence, Allen’s physiological aesthetics is marked as the politics of physiological purification.

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (0)
REFERENCES (15)
열림/닫힘 버튼
* 2021년 이후 발행 논문의 참고문헌은 현재 구축 중입니다.

[book] Albright, Thomas D. / 2005 / Neural Science: A Century of Progress and the Mysteries that Remains / American Psychiatric Press Inc

[book] Allen, Grant / 2005 / Physiological Aesthetics (1877) / Adamant Media Corporation

[book] Allen, Grant / 1882 / The Colours of Flowers as Illustrated in the British Flora / Macmillan

[book] Brain, Robert Michael / 2015 / The Pulse of Modernism: Physiological Aesthetics in Fin-de-Siècle Europe / U of Washington P

[book] Broadbent, Donald Eric / 1958 / Perception and Communication / Pergamon Press

[book] Carpenter, William Benjamin / 1875 / Principles of Mental Physiology: with Their Applications to the Training and Discipline of the Mind, and the Study of its Morbid Conditions / Appleton

[book] Lewes, George Henry / 1874 / Problems of Life and Mind, First Series : the Foundations of a Creed. Vol. 1 / James R. Osgood and Company

[book] Rose, Steven / 1984 / Not in Our Genes: Biology, Ideology and Human Nature / Pantheon

[book] Rylance, Rick / 2000 / Victorian Psychology and British Culture, 1850-1880 / Oxford UP

[book] Scott, John / 1994 / A Dictionary of Sociology / Oxford UP

[book] Smith, Jonathan / 2004 / Grant Allen, Physiological Aesthetics, and the Dissemination of Darwin’s Botany, Science Serialized: Representations of the Sciences in Nineteenth-Century Periodicals / MIT P

[book] Smith, Roger / 2004 / The Physiology of the Will: Mind, Body, and Psychology in the Periodical Literature, 1855-1875, Science Serialized: Representations of the Sciences in Nineteenth-Century Periodicals / MIT P

[journal] Stiles, Anne / 2008 / Victorian Psychology and the Novel / Literary Compass 5(3)

[book] Taylor, Jenny Bourne / 1890 / Embodied Selves: An Anthology of Psychological Texts, 1830-1890 / Clarendon P

[book] Thornton, Tim / 2004 / Reductionism and Antireductionism, The Philosophy of Psychiatry / Oxford UP

KJC Korea
Journal Central

Statistics

Tools

Sharing

Issue List

Citation status