A Dream of Communal Society for Parts Without Parts: On Thomas More's Utopia

Myungho Lee

doi:10.21049/ccs.2016.45..295

This essay attempts a contrapuntal reading of Thomas More's Utopia. Contrapunctual reading, proposed by Edward Said. attempts to make a text speak across temporal, cultural, and ideological boundaries to a topic of present. I examine two opposite readings of Utopia around 2011 by both pro- and anti- Occupy Wall Street positions. On the one hand, the opponents of Occupy find its limits as a utopian social movement echoing in the fictional character of Hythrodaeus and the alternative society verbally sketched by him in Book Two of Utopia. On the other, Occupy's advocates read More's text as embodying its radial possibility. However, each shares the tendency to denounce Book Two, praising Book One in which Hythrodaeus vehemently criticizes England; they read Hythrodaeus not as an utopian idealist but as a social critic. The Occupy, as a result, is seen here as having an ambivalent relationship to utopianism. I reinterpret the radical possibilities of Book Two criticized by both pro- and anti-Occupy invocations of Utopia. Book Two provides a utopian space in which the existing social contradictions are cancelled, revealing the limits of the three partial utopias proposed at the end of Book One. Following Louis Marin's argument, I argue, the "utopic" space does not lie in the so-called ideal society described in the text but in the inconsistencies between the text's description(discourse) and topography(map). In Book Two the existence of a king is described, yet his space is not found in the topography of utopia; likewise market is described as existing at the center of a city, yet its space is not found either. These inconsistencies create a neutral space in which the ideological contradictions of the text are cancelled, and the space opens up the possibility of communal society beyond modern sovereign power and capitalism I argue this utopian dream needs to be summoned once again in our time as a compelling alternative to the corporate, capitalist order.

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (0)
REFERENCES (24)
열림/닫힘 버튼
* 2021년 이후 발행 논문의 참고문헌은 현재 구축 중입니다.

[book] 에드워드 W. 싸이드 / 2005 / 프로이트와 유태인 문제 / 창비

[book] 토머스 모어 / 2007 / 유토피아 / 을유문화사

[book] Claeys, Gregory / 2010 / The Cambridge Companion to Utopian Literature

[web] Goodwin, Michael / 2012 / Lord of Flies in Zuccotti Park / The New York Post

[book] Greenblatt, Stephen / 1980 / Renaissance Self-Fashioning / University of Chicago Press

[other] Hogan, Sarah / 2013 / What More Means Now: Utopia, Occupy, and the Commons / Upstart

[book] Jacoby, Russell / 2005 / Picture Imperfect: Utopian Thought for an Anti-Utopian Age / Columbia UP

[journal] Jameson, Fredric / 1977 / Of Islands and Trenches: Neutralization and the Production of Utopian Discourse / Diacritics 7(2)

[book] Jameson, Fredric / 1981 / The Political Unconscious / Cornell UP

[journal] Jameson, Fredric / 2004 / The Politics of Utopia / New Left Review 25

[book] Jameson, Fredric / 2005 / Archaeologies of the Future: The Desire Called Utopia and Other Science Fictions / Verso

[other] Kendrick, Christopher / 1985 / More's Utopia and Uneven Development / boundary 2 13.2

[book] Knapp, Jeffrey / 1992 / An Empire Nowhere: England, America, and Literature from Utopia to The Tempest / University of California Press

[journal] Marin, Louis / 1993 / Frontiers of Utopia: Past and Present / Critical Inquiry 19(3)

[book] Marin, Louis / 1984 / Utopics: Spacial Play / Humanities

[book] Marcuse, Herbert / 1970 / The End of Utopia / Beacon Press

[book] More, Thomas / 1992 / Utopia / W. W. Norton Company

[book] Moylan, Tom / 1986 / Demand the Impossible: Science Fiction and the Utopian Imagination / Methuen

[book] Moylan, Tom / 2000 / Scraps of Untainted Sky: Science Fiction, Utopia, and Dystopia / Westview

[web] Sage, Carolyn / 2012 / Organizing Thought 11: Join Us, the Bottom-lining Idealists!!

[journal] Survin, Darko / 1973 / Defining the Literary Genre of Utopia: Some Historical Semantics, Some Genealogy, a Proposal and a Plea / Studies in the Literary Imagination 6(2)

[web] Wallace Henley / 2012 / Occupy Wall Street, Idealism, and Original Sin

[book] Wegner, E. Philip / 2002 / Imaginary Communities: Utopia, the Nation, and the Spacial Histories of Modernity / University of California Press

[web] / 2012 / Occupy Wall Street Shows Why Utopias Always Fail

KJC Korea
Journal Central

Statistics

Tools

Sharing

Issue List

Citation status