Unchosen Cohabitation of Hannah Arendt and Precarity Politics of Judith Butler: Based on Body Politic and Ethical Obligation

Cho Scarlet Hyun June

doi:10.21049/ccs.2017.48..361

This essay examines ‘precarity politics’ by Judith Butler, a well-known gender theorist and queer philosopher, in Notes Towards a Performative Theory of Assembly (2015) focused on concepts as unchosen cohabitation of Hannah Arendt and unwilled proximity of Emmanuel Levinas. Butler’s precarity politics is the condition of our dispossessed political beings with fundamental vulnerability and interdependency that cannot choose with whom we will live on this Earth. Butler’s political ethics is twofold: on one hand, she examines significance of ‘action’' the most significant vita activa in the public area, and ‘plurality’' the condition—not only the necessary condition but the possible condition—for a political life suggested by Hannah Arendt in Human Condition; on the other hand, Butler reflects upon global precarity based on a diasporic precarious life in the social world towards freedom and equality. Unchosen cohabitation of plural humans on Earth, and global pervasion of precarity, that indicates “politically induced condition in which certain populations suffer from failing social and economic networks of support and become differentially exposed to injury, violence, and death,” so called “differential distribution of precariousness,” are practical possibilities of ethical and equal cohabitation of different ethnic groups in the social world. Ethical obligations or ethical demand to respond to others’ suffering in distance and proximity originated from precarity politics, mentioned in Precarious Life, Parting Ways, and Frames of War, could be non-foundational joint of plural people living together globally. We should presume the ‘reversibility’ of distance and proximity in others’ suffering, based on responsiveness and responsibility of others, if we want to stay attuned to the pain of others we never chose to live together. That is the significance of Butler’s ‘precarity politics’ with ‘ethical obligation’ to accept ‘unchosen plurality’ of living population on Earth, and ‘reversibility between of distance and proximity,’ in her ‘new plural and embodied body politics’ or ‘new corporeal ontology’, through human primary vulnerability, fundamental interdependency, being exposed and responsive to suffering of others.

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (1)
열림/닫힘 버튼
REFERENCES (28)
열림/닫힘 버튼
* 2021년 이후 발행 논문의 참고문헌은 현재 구축 중입니다.

[book] 김비환 / 2003 / 축복과 저주의 정치사상 : 20세기와 한나 아렌트 / 한길사

[book] 김선욱 / 2015 / 한나 아렌트의 공화주의 : 아모르 문디에서 레스 푸블라카로 / 아포리아

[book] 서유경 / 2009 / 한나 아렌트와 세계 사랑 / 인간사랑

[book] 애스트라 테일러 / 2012 / 불온한 산책자 / 이후

[book] 이진우 / 1996 / 인간의 조건 / 한길사

[journal] 조현준 / 2013 / Judith Butler’s Political Ethics: Interdependence of Human Subjects and the Critique of Ethical Violence / 인문학연구 / 인문학연구원 (24) : 29~56

[journal] 조현준 / 2017 / A Comparative Study between Gender Trouble and Undoing Gender by Judith Butler: My Identity to Beside Myself, Gender to Humanness / 여성문학연구 / 한국여성문학학회 (40) : 239~266

[book] 홍원표 / 2011 / 아렌트 : 정치적 존재이유는 자유다 / 한길사

[book] Arendt, Hannah / 1998 / Human Condition / University of Chicago Press

[book] Arendt, Hannah / 1963 / Eichmann in Jerusalem / Schocken

[book] Arendt, Hannah / 1973 / On Totalitarianism / Harcourt

[book] Arendt, Hannah / 1972 / Crises of the Republic / Harcourt Brace Jovanoovich

[book] Brandy Anita / 2011 / Understanding Judith Butler / SAGE

[book] Butler, Judith / 2007 / Who Sings the Nation State?: Language, Politics, and Belonging / Seagull Books

[book] Butler, Judith / 1983 / The Power of Religion in the Public Sphere / Columbia University Press

[book] Butler, Judith / 2016 / Vulnerability in Resistance / Duke University Press

[book] Butler, Judith / 2005 / Giving an Account of Oneself / Fordham University Press

[book] Butler, Judith / 2015 / Notes Toward a Performative Theory of Assembly / Harvard University Press

[book] Butler, Judith / 2012 / Parting Ways : Jewishness and the Critique of Zionism / Columbia UP

[book] Butler, Judith / 2004 / Precarious Life : The Powers of Mourning and Violence / Verso

[book] Butler, Judith / 2004 / Undoing Gender / Routledge

[book] Chambers, Samuel A. / 2008 / Judith Butler and Political Theory: Troubling Politics / Routlege

[book] Kirby, Vicki / 2006 / Judith Butler : Live Theory / Continuum International Publishing Group

[book] Lloyd, Moya / 2007 / Judith Butler / Polity

[book] Lloyd, Moya / 2008 / Judith Butler's Precarious Politics / Routledge

[book] Lloyd, Moya / 2015 / Butler and Ethics / Edinburgh UP

[book] Lloyd, Moya / 2007 / Judith Butler / Polity Press

[book] Loizidou, Elena / 2007 / Judith Butler: Ethics, Law, Politics / Routledge

KJC Korea
Journal Central

Statistics

Tools

Sharing

Issue List

Citation status