Shylock as the Abject

Lee,Mi-Sun

doi:10.21049/ccs.2018.50..483

Shylock in Shakespeare’s play, The Merchant of Venice has been considered as either a devilish villain, or as a victim who was persecuted unfairly by the Christian society in Venice. By focusing on the matter of the Other, which has been summarily overlooked in literary texts and the literary criticism, it is noted that the New Historical and Cultural criticism interpreted Shylock as the racial, religious, and economic Other in the Venetian society which at the time was dominated by Christian ideals. The purpose of this paper is to show how Shylock becomes an abjected Other, that is, the abject, based on Julia Kristeva's theory of abjection. According to Kristeva, an abjection is the process of expulsion of otherness from society, through which the subject or the nation tries to set up clear boundaries and establish a stable identity. Shylock is marginalized and abjected by the borders drawn by the Venetian Christian society, which in a strong sense tries to protect its identity and homogeneity by rejecting and excluding any unclean or improper otherness. The borders include the two visible borders like the Ghetto and the red hats worn by the Jews, and one invisible border in the religious and economic fields. By asking for one pound of Antonio’s flesh when he can’t pay back 3,000 ducats owed, Shylock tries to cross the border between Christians and Jews. Portia frustrates Shylock's desire to violate the border by presenting a different interpretation of the expression, ‘one pound of flesh,’ from Shylock’s interpretation. And in doing so she expels him back to his original position of abject.

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (1)
열림/닫힘 버튼
REFERENCES (31)
열림/닫힘 버튼
* 2021년 이후 발행 논문의 참고문헌은 현재 구축 중입니다.

[journal] 김종학 / 1997 / ‘타자’로서의 유태인: 『베니스의 상인』(The Merchant of Venice) 연구 / Shakespeare Review

[journal] 백민아 / 2012 / Shylock’s Otherness / 영어영문학연구 / 한국중앙영어영문학회 54(2) : 123~138 / 10.18853/jjell.2012.54.2.007

[book] 윌리엄 셰익스피어 / 1996 / 셰익스피어 전집 / 서문당

[journal] 이미선 / 1998 / 단일 의미의 불가능성-『베니스의 상인』에서 ‘1파운드의 살’을 중심으로 / Shakespeare Review

[journal] 정은숙 / 2011 / The Abjection of The Mother/Colonial Country in Jamaica Kincaid’s Annie John / 영어영문학 / 한국영어영문학회 57(2) : 285~314 / 10.15794/jell.2011.57.2.005

[book] Barber, C. L. / 1959 / Shakespeare's Festive Comedy: A Study of Dramatic Form and Its Relation to Social Custom / Princeton UP

[journal] Brady, Mary Pat / 2000 / The Fungibility of Borders / Nepantla: Views from South 1(1)

[book] Butler, Judith / 1990 / Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity / Routledge

[book] Butler, Judith / 1993 / Bodies That Matter: on the Discursive Limits of “Sex” / Routeledge

[book] Coats, Karen / 2004 / Looking Glasses and Neverlands: Lacan, Desire, and Subjectivity in Children's Literature / University of Iowa Press

[journal] Cohen, D. M. / 1980 / The Jew and Shylock / Shakespeare Quarterly 31

[book] Creed, Barbara / 2000 / The Horror Reader / Routledge

[book] Danson, Lawrence / 1978 / The Harmonies of the Merchant of Venice / Yale UP

[book] Davis, Richard C. / 2001 / The Jews of Early Modern Venice / The Johns Hopkins UP

[book] Derrida, Jacques / 2000 / Of Hospitality / Stanford UP

[book] Eagleton, Terry / 1986 / William Shakespeare / Blackwell

[book] Garber, Marjorie / 2004 / Shakespeare After All / Pantheon Books

[book] Kermode, Frank / 1961 / Early Shakespeare / St Martin's

[journal] Kitch, Aaron / 2008 / Shylock's Sacred Nation / Shakespeare Quarterly 59(2)

[book] Kristeva, J. / 1982 / The Powers of Horror / Columbia UP

[book] Kristeva, J. / 1991 / Strangers to Ourselves / Columbia UP

[journal] Kwon, Young-Keun / 2002 / The ‘Other’ in The Tempest and The Merchant of Venice / 영어영문학 9

[book] Lacan, Jacques / 1977 / Écrits: A Selection / Tavistock

[journal] Meyer, Adam / 2013 / Victim and Villain: Shylock in the African American Imagination / Borrowers and Lenders 7(2)

[book] Moody, A. D. / 1964 / Shakespeare: The Merchant of Venice / Barron's Educational Series

[book] Schneiderman, Stuart / 1983 / Jacques Lacan: the death of an intellectual hero / Harvard UP

[book] Shakespeare, William / 1974 / The Riverside Shakespeare / Houghton Mifflin Company

[journal] Smith, Warren D. / 1964 / Shakespeare's Shylock / Shakespeare Quarterly 15(3)

[journal] Stoll, Elmer Edgar / 1911 / Shylock / The Journal of English and Germanic Philosophy 10

[web] Derrida, Jacques / Politics and Friendship: A Discussion with Jacques Derrida at the Center for Modern French Thought / University of Sussex / http://www.hydra.umn.edu/derrida/pol+fr.html

[web] Sentürk, Neslihan / Border as an Abjection Tool and the Creation of Abject-ivities in The Merchant of Venice / https://whatamiwriting.wordpress.com/2010/06/06/border-as-an-abjection-tool-and-the-creation-of-abject-ivities-in-the-merchant-of-venice/

KJC Korea
Journal Central

Statistics

Tools

Sharing

Issue List

Citation status