On the Dunhuang Manuscript Dasheng qixin lun shu 大乘起信論疏 (provisional title; hane 羽 333 verso) Belonging to the Kyō’u 杏雨 Library

池田 將則

doi:10.29213/crbs..12.201212.45

As is well known, there exist four early commentaries on the Awakening of Faith in the Great Vehicle (AF), written in China (also in Korea): Tanyan’s 曇延 (516-588) Dasheng qixin lun yishu 大乘起信論義疏; Jingying Huiyuan’s 淨影慧遠 (523-592) Dasheng qixin lun yishu 大乘起信論義疏; Wŏnhyo’s 元曉 (617-686) Qixin lun shu 起信論疏; and Fazang’s 法藏 (643-712) Dasheng qixin lun yiji 大乘起信論義記. Among the four texts, Tanyan’s commentary has been considered the oldest one. However, I found another commentary on the AF, which precedes Tanyan’s one in the recently published Dunhuang manuscripts belonging to the Kyō’u 杏雨 Library in Japan. In this article, I intend to examine the entire nature of this newly identified Dasheng qixin lun shu 大乘起信論疏 (provisional title; hane 羽 333 verso) (羽333V) in comparison with Tanyan’s commentary, and make clear the following points: 1. By comparing and contrasting the 羽333V with Tanyan’s commentary, we can find some cases that the latter summarizes comments of the former, and the latter added some explanations which are not in the former. We therefore, conclude that the 羽333V precedes Tanyan’s commentary. 2. The 羽333V cites some paragraphs from Paramārtha’s translation of the Mahāyānasaṃgrahabhāṣya (MSBh), and precedes Tanyan’s commentary as mentioned above. Therefore, the 羽333V was composed after 564 C.E. when Paramārtha completed translating the MSBh into Chinese, and before 588 C.E. when Tanyan was dead. 3. In the 羽333V, we can find a number of comments based on the doctrines of the Jiu shi zhang 九識章 composed by Paramārtha, and of the MSBh and the Foxing lun 佛性論 translated by him. Compared with Tanyan’s commentary, the 羽333V closes to the works of Paramārtha much more. Therefore, there is a strong possibility that the author of the 羽333V was familiar with the translations and various compositions of Paramārtha, and had a close relationship with him. 4. In the extant manuscript of the 羽333V, there are some traces of modifications probably by the author himself, but on the other hand, there are also the omission of the transcription which suggests that the manuscript was organized by some other editor as well. Also, among these traces of modifications, a part of it was possibly known by Tanyan, but others may not. We therefore, assume that the 羽333V is probably a text whose type is a record of lecture co-produced by an author (i.e. a master) and an editor (i.e. a disciples), and it is possible that more than one text had existed in those days, and there were variant versions of compilations which have different types of editing while reflected the author’s modifications. 5. It is unknown whether Huiyuan and Wŏnhyo knew the 羽333V, but in Fazang’s commentary, we can find some evidence that Fazang referred to it. We therefore, can assume that the 羽333V had existed in central China, at least until the 7th century.

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (10)
열림/닫힘 버튼
REFERENCES (40)
열림/닫힘 버튼
* 2021년 이후 발행 논문의 참고문헌은 현재 구축 중입니다.

[book] 荒牧典俊 / 2000 / 北朝隋唐中國佛敎思想史 / 法藏館

[journal] 池田將則 / 2009 / 敦煌本『攝大乘論抄』の原本 (守屋コレクション本) と後續部分 (スタイン2554) とについて――翻刻と研究――(前篇･後篇) / 佛敎史研究 / 龍谷大學佛敎史研究會 45

[book] 池田將則 / 2010 / 地論思想の形成と変容 / 國書刊行會

[book] 池田將則 / 2012 / 藏外地論宗文獻集成 / 圖書出版CIR

[book] 今津洪嶽 / 1918 / 佛敎大系　大乘起信論華嚴金師子章華嚴法界義鏡 / 佛敎大系刊行會

[book] 上山大峻 / 1990 / 敦煌佛敎の研究八―十世紀敦煌の佛敎學 / 法藏館

[book] 宇井伯壽 / 1965 / 印度哲學研究, 第六 / 岩波書店

[book] 宇井伯壽 / 1994 / 大乘起信論 / 岩波文庫

[journal] 大竹晉 / 2003 / 『大乘起信論』の唯識説と『入楞伽經』 / 哲學･思想論叢 / 筑波大學哲學･思想學會 (21)

[book] 大竹晉 / 2012 / 眞諦三藏研究論集 / 京都大學人文科學研究所

[book] 柏木弘雄 / 1981 / 大乘起信論の研究――大乘起信論の成立に關する資料論的研究―― / 春秋社

[book] 杏雨書屋 / 2009 / 敦煌秘笈 / 公益財團法人武田科學振興財團

[journal] 神秘主義研究班 / 2001 / 『大乘起信論義記』研究 (三) / 關西大學東西學術研究所紀要 34

[book] 高崎直道 / 1981 / 大乘佛敎から密敎へ / 春秋社

[book] 高崎直道 / 2009 / 大乘起信論･楞伽經 / 春秋社

[journal] 高崎直道 / 1986 / 『大乘起信論』における <念> について / 東方學 73

[book] 高崎直道 / 1987 / 寶性論 (インド古典叢書) / 講談社

[journal] 高崎直道 / 1997 / 『大乘起信』の意味と論體―― 『起信論･曇延疏』解讀 (一) / 東洋の思想と宗教 / 早稻田大學東洋哲學會 (14)

[book] 竹村牧男 / 1993 / 大乘起信論讀釋 / 山喜房佛書林

[book] 竹村牧男 / 1990 / 如來藏と大乘起信論 / 春秋社

[report] 丹治昭義 / 2004 / 曇延撰『大乘起信論義疏』の基本的思想體系, ｢大乘起信論｣と法藏敎學の實證的研究(科學研究費補助金研究成果報告書)

[book] 長尾雅人 / 1982 / 攝大乘論和譯と注解, 上･下 (インド古典叢書) / 講談社

[journal] 藤枝晃 / 1985 / 『德化李氏凡將閣珍藏』印について / 學叢 / 京都國立博物館 (７)

[book] 船山徹 / 2012 / 眞諦三藏研究論集 / 京都大學人文科學研究所

[book] 竹村牧男 / 1993 / 大乘起信論讀釋 / 山喜房佛書林

[book] 竹村牧男 / 1990 / 如來藏大乘起信論 / 春秋社

[report] 丹治昭義 / 2004 / 曇延撰『大乘起信論義疏』の基本的思想體系, ｢大乘起信論｣と法藏敎學の實證的研究(科學研究費補助金研究成果報告書)

[book] 長尾雅人 / 1982 / 攝大乘論和譯と注解, 上･下 (インド古典叢書) / 講談社

[journal] 藤枝晃 / 1985 / 『德化李氏凡將閣珍藏』印について / 學叢 / 京都國立博物館 (７)

[book] 船山徹 / 2012 / 眞諦三藏研究論集 / 京都大學人文科學研究所

[book] 望月信亨 / 1922 / 大乘起信論之研究 / 金尾文淵堂

[journal] 吉津宜英 / 1972 / 慧遠の『起信論疏』をめぐる諸問題 (上) / 駒澤大學佛敎學部論集 (３)

[journal] 吉津宜英 / 1973 / 淨影寺慧遠の『起信論疏』について――曇延疏との比較の視點から―― / 印度學佛敎學研究 21(1)

[journal] 吉津宜英 / 1976 / 慧遠『大乘起信論義疏』の研究 / 駒澤大學佛敎學部紀要 (34)

[book] 吉津宜英 / 1991 / 華嚴一乘思想の研究 / 大東出版社

[journal] 吉津宜英 / 2001 / 吉藏の大乘起信論引用について / 印度學佛敎學研究 50(1)

[journal] 吉津宜英 / 2003 / 眞諦三藏譯出經律論研究誌 / 駒澤大學佛敎學部研究紀要 (61)

[book] 榮新江 / 2005 / 日本學･敦煌學･漢文訓讀の新展開 / 汲古書院

[book] 王重民 / 1962 / 敦煌遺書總目索引 / 商務印書館

[journal] 張娜麗 / 2006 / 羽田亨博士收集『西域出土文獻寫眞』について / お茶の水史學 (50)

이 논문은 한국연구재단의 지원을 받아 작성되었습니다.

KJC Korea
Journal Central

Statistics

Tools

Sharing

Issue List

Citation status