Reframing Bhāviveka
2016, (20), pp.13-48
DOI : 10.29213/crbs..20.201612.13
Publisher : Geumgang Center for Buddhist Studies
Research Area : Buddhist Studies
-
According to Tibetan accounts, Madhyamaka bifurcated into the Svātantrika of Bhāviveka and the Prāsaṅgika of Buddhapālita and Candrakīrti. However, we can hardly find any trace concerning the Svātantrika-Prāsaṅgika distinction in later Indian sources. This paper attempts to explain why this discrepancy occurred by analysing the works of Candrakīrti, Bhavya and Atiśa. Firstly, I examine what is svatantra anumāna in the Prasannapadā to elucidate the cause of the problem and the point of controversy between Bhāviveka and Candrakīrti. It is a widespread view that the dispute over the use of probative inference in the Prasannapadā resulted in this division of the Svātantrika and the Prāsaṅgika. It is, however, possible to read it in a different way. Then, I focus on Atiśa’s works to show the widespread view was not shared by him, who endorses both Bhāviveka and Candrakīrti. In order to bolster my argument, I look into how Candrakīrti’s position regarding inference was transmitted to him, and point out that Bhavya’s Madhyamakaratnapradīpa played a crucial role in the formation of the later Indian Prāsaṅgika lineage. A close examination of these texts makes it clear that Candrakīrti succeeded in handing down his view by misleading the later Mādhyamikas.
-
[book] Haribhadra / 1932 / Abhisamayālaṅkārālokā Prajñāpāramitāvyākhyā,The Work of Haribhadra / Tōyō Bunko
[other] Bodhibhadra / 1976 / Jñānasārasamuccayanibandhana / by Mimaki 1976. Derge 3852, dbu ma, Tsha 28a3-45b4; Peking 5252, dbu ma, Tsha 31a3-53b3
[other] Bhāviveka / 1980 / Tarkajvālā / Iida 1980 (chap. 3, vv. 1-136). Derge 3856, dbu ma, Dza 40b7-329b4; Peking 5256, dbu ma, Dza 43b7-380a7
[other] Bhāviveka / 1914 / Derge 3853, dbu ma, Tsha 45b4-259b3; Peking 5253, dbu ma, Tsha 53b3-326a6 / by Walleser 1914. Derge 3853, dbu ma, Tsha 45b4-259b3; Peking 5253, dbu ma, Tsha 53b3-326a6
[other] Avalokitavrata / Prajñāpradīpaṭīkā / Derge 3859, dbu ma, Wa 1-287a7, Zha 1-338a7, Za 1-341a7; Peking 5259, dbu ma, Wa 1-333a6, Zha 1-394a5, Za 1-406a8
[book] Candrakīrti / 1916 / Mūlamadhyamakakārikās (Mādhyamikasūtras) de Nāgārjuna avec la Prasannapadā Commentaire de Candrakīrti
[other] Atiśa / Bodhimārgapradīpapañjikā / Derge 3948, dbu ma, Khi 241a4-293a4;Peking 5344, dbu ma, Ki 277b6-339b2
[other] Bhāviveka / Madhyamakaratnapradīpa / Derge 3854, dbu ma, Tsha 259b3-289a7; Peking 5254, dbu ma, Tsha 326a6-365a8
[other] Bhāviveka / 2001 / Madhyamakahṛdayakārikā / by Lindtner
[other] Śāntarakṣita / 1985 / Madhyamakālaṃkāra / by Ichigo 1985. Derge 3884, dbu ma, Sa 53a1-56b3; Peking 5284, dbu ma, Sa 48b7-52b1
[other] Kamalaśīla / 1985 / Madhyamakālaṃkārapañjikā / by Ichigo 1985. Derge 3886, dbu ma, Sa 84a1-133b4; Peking 5286, dbu ma, Sa 84b7-143b2
[other] Candrakīrti / 1907 / Madhyamakāvatārabhāṣya / by La Vallée Poussin 1907-12. Derge 3862, dbu ma, ’a 220b1-348a7; Peking 5263, dbu ma, ’a 264b8-411b1
[book] Nāgārjuna / 1916 / Mūlamadhyamakakārikās (Mādhyamikasūtras) de Nāgārjuna avec la Prasannapadā Commentaire de Candrakīrti
[other] Atiśa / 1993 / Ratnakaraṇḍodghāta / by Miyazaki 1993 (partial). Derge 3930, dbu ma, Ki 96b1-116b3; Peking 5325, dbu ma, A 106b6-132b3
[other] Jñānagarbha / 1987 / Satyadvayavibhaṅgakārikā / by Eckel 1987. Derge 3881, dbu ma, Sa 1-3b3
[other] Jñānagarbha / 1987 / Satyadvayavibhaṅgavṛtti / by Eckel 1987. Derge. 3882, dbu ma, Sa 3b3-15b1
[other] Atiśa / 1983 / Satyadvayāvatāra / by Ejima 1983. Derge 3902, dbu ma, A 72a3-73a7, 4467, jo bo’i chos chung, 5b3-6b5; Peking 5298, dbu ma, Ha 70a5-71b2, 5380, dbu ma, Gi 6b7-8a8. Also edited by Lindtner 1981
[other] Ye shes sde / 1977 / lTa ba'i khyad par / by Ueyama 1977 (the Madhyamaka section based on Pelliot no. 814). Derge 4360, sna tshogs, Jo 213b1-228a7;Peking 5847, ngo tshar bstan bcos, Cho 252a5-269b6
[confproc] INABA Shoju / 1966 / チベット中世初期における般若中観論書の訳出(上) ‘Chibetto Chūsei-shoki ni okeru Hannya-chūgan-ronjo no Yakushutsu (jō)’ / 大谷大学仏教学セミナー 4 : 15~33
[journal] UEYAMA Taishun / 1977 / エセイデの仏教綱要書 ‘Eseide no Bukkyō Kōyō-sho’ / 仏教学研究 32/33 : 19~45
[journal] EJIMA Yasunori / 1983 / アティーシャの二真理説 ‘Atīsha no Ni-shinri-setsu’ / 龍樹教学の研究
[book] KISHINE Toshiyuki / 2001 / チャンドラキールティの中観思想 Chandorakīruthi no Chūgan-shisō / 大東出版
[book] NAGASHIMA Jundo / 2007 / 梵文学研究論集：松濤誠達先生古稀記念 Bonbungaku Kenkyū-ronshū: Matsunami Yoshihiro Sensei Koki-kinen / 大祥書籍
[book] MATSUMOTO Shiro / 1997 / チベット仏教哲学 Chibetto BukkyōTetsugaku / 大蔵出版
[journal] MIYAZAKI Izumi / 1993 / 中観優婆提舎開宝篋 について ‘Chūganubadaisha-kaihōkyō ni tsuite / 仏教史学研究 36(1) : 1~31
[journal] YAMAGUCHI Susumu / 1943 / 中観派に於ける中観説の綱要書 ‘Chūgan-ha ni okeru Chūgan-setsu no Kōyōsho’ / 大谷大学研究年報 2 : 69~152
[book] COULSON, Michael / 1992 / Teach Yourself Sanskrit / Hodder and Stoughton
[other] BENDALL, Cecil / 1905 / Subhāṣitasaṃgraha / Extracted from Le Muséon, IV, 1903, 375-402; V, 1904, 5-46 and 245-274
[journal] DEL TOSO, Krishna / 2015 / Some Problems Concerning Textual Reuses in the Madhyamakaratnapradīpa, with a Discussion of the Quotation from Saraha’s Dohākośagīti / Journal of Indian Philosophy 43(4/5) : 511~557
[book] DREYFUS, Georges B. J. / 2003 / The Svātantrika-Prāsaṅgika Distinction / Wisdom Publications
[book] ECKEL, Malcolm David / 1987 / Jñānagarbha’s Commentary on the Distinction between the Two Truths / State University of New York Press
[journal] HE Huanhuan / 2014 / Further Notes on Bhāviveka’s Principal Oeuvre / Indo-Iranian Journal 57(4) : 299~352
[book] ICHIGO, Masamichi / 1985 / Madhyamakālaṃkāra, of Śāntarakṣita with his Own Commentary or Vṛtti and with the Sub-commentary or Pañjikā of Kamalaśīla / Buneidō
[book] IIDA, Shotaro / 1980 / Reason and Emptiness, A Study in Logic and Mysticism / Hokuseidō Press
[book] LA VALLÉE POUSSIN, Louis de / 1913 / Mūlamadhyamakakārikās (Mādhyamikasūtras) de Nāgārjuna avec la Prasannapadā Commentaire de Candrakīrti
[book] LA VALLÉE POUSSIN / 1912 / Madhyamakāvatāra par Candrakīrti
[journal] LINDTNER, Christian / 1981 / Atīśa’s Introduction to the Two Truths, and its Sources / Journal of Indian Philosophy 9 : 161~214
[book] LINDTNER, Christian / 1982 / Nāgārjuniana / Akademisk Forlag
[book] LINDTNER, Christian / 2001 / Madhyamakahṛdayam / The Adyar Library and Research Centre
[book] LOPEZ, Donald Sewell / 1987 / A Study of Svātantrika / Snow Lion
[book] MACDONALD, Anne / 2015 / In Clear Words, The Prasannapadā, Chapter One / Austrian Academy of Sciences
[book] MIMAKI Katsumi / 1976 / La Réfutation Bouddhique de la Permanence des Choses (Sthirasiddhidūṣaṇa) et la Preuve de la Momentanéité des Choses (Kṣaṇabhaṅgasiddhi)
[journal] NAGASHIMA Jundo / 2004 / Distinction Between Svātantrika and Prāsaṅgika in Late Madhyamaka: Atiśa and Bhavya as Prāsaṅgikas / Nagoya Studies in Indian Culture and Buddhism: Saṃbhāṣā 24 : 65~98
[book] RUEGG, David Seyfort / 1981 / The Literature of the Madhyamaka School of Philosophy in India / Otto Harrassowitz
[book] VOSE, Kevin A. / 2009 / Resurrecting Candrakirti, Disputes in the Tibetan Creation of Prāsaṅgika / Wisdom Publications
[book] WALLESER, Max / 1914 / Prajñāpradīpa, A Commentary on the Madhyamakasūtra by Bhāvaviveka / Asiatic Society of Bengal
[book] WOGIHARA Unrai / 1932 / Abhisamayālaṅkārālokā Prajñāpāramitāvyākhyā, The Work of Haribhadra / Tōyō Bunko
[journal] YONEZAWA Yoshiyasu / 2004 / Lakṣaṇaṭīkā Sanskrit Notes on the Prasannapadā (1) / Journal of Naritasan Institute for Buddhist Studies 27 : 115~154
[book] YOTSUYA Kodo / 1999 / The Critique of Svatantra Reasoning by Candrakīrti and Tsong-kha-pa: a study of philosophical proof according to two Prāsaṅgika Madhyamaka traditions in India and Tibet / Steiner
-
188 Viewed
Print this page
Download PDF