Buddha-nature, Critical Buddhism, and Early Chan

Robert H. Sharf

doi:10.29213/crbs..22.201712.105

This article begins with a reflection on why medieval Chinese Buddhist thought has not been more conspicuous in recent comparative work on Buddhism and Western philosophy. The Japanese proponents of “Critical Buddhism” (hihan bukkyō 批判仏教), Matsumoto Shirō 松本史朗 and Hakamaya Noriaki 袴谷憲昭, would see this neglect as merited since, in their view, East Asian Buddhism in general, and Chinese Chan in particular, is philosophically crippled owing to its embrace of tathāgatagarbha and buddha-nature thought. Indeed, Matsumoto singles out Shenhui 荷澤神會 (670-762), one of the architects of the Southern School of Chan, as an example of the early Chan advocacy of buddha-nature doctrine. This article is not concerned with whether buddha-nature and tathāgatagarbha thought is actually deleterious to critical philosophical work. Rather, the concern is to demonstrate that, far from embracing buddha-nature doctrine, the eighth-century founders of Southern Chan had serious concerns with it. Evidence for this is found in: (1) the writings of Shenhui, notably in his opposition to the doctrine of the “buddha-nature of insentient objects” (wuqing foxing 無情佛性); and (2) the Platform Scripture of the Sixth Patriarch (Liuzu tanjing 六祖壇經), particularly in the variant versions of Huineng’s famous “enlightenment verse.” Thus the Southern School may be viewed as a forerunner of the Critical Buddhist anti-dhātuvāda polemics. The article closes with comments on the ongoing problems Chinese Buddhist exegetes had in marrying the metaphysical monism of Yogācāra and tathāgatagarbha teachings with the anti-foundationalist thrust of Madhyamaka and Prajñāpāramitā literature.

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (0)
REFERENCES (56)
열림/닫힘 버튼
* 2021년 이후 발행 논문의 참고문헌은 현재 구축 중입니다.

[book] ARNOLD, Daniel Anderson / 2005 / Buddhists, Brahmins, and Belief: Epistemology in Indian and Buddhist Philosophy / Columbia University Press

[journal] ARNOLD, Daniel Anderson / 2010 / Self-Awareness (svasaṃvitti) and Related Doctrines of Buddhists Following Dignāga: Philosophical Characterizations of Some of the Main Issues / Journal of Indian Philosophy 38(3) : 323~378

[book] ARNOLD, Daniel Anderson / 2012 / Brains, Buddhas, and Believing: The Problem of Intentionality in Classical Buddhist and Cognitive-scientific Philosophy of Mind / Columbia University Press

[journal] BARRETT, Timothy H / 1991 / The Date of the Leng-chia shih-tzu chi / Journal of the Royal Asiatic Society 1(2) : 255~259

[book] BLUM, Mark Laurence / 2013 / The Nirvana Sutra (Mahāparinirvāṇa-Sūtra). Vol. 1 / BDK America

[book] COSERU, Christian / 2012 / Perceiving Reality: Consciousness, Intentionality, and Cognition in Buddhist Philosophy / Oxford University Press

[journal] DEGUCHI, Yasuo / 2008 / The Way of the Dialetheist : Contradictions in Buddhism / Philosophy East and West 58(3) : 395~402

[journal] DEGUCHI, Yasuo / 2013 / How We Think Mādhyamikas Think : A Response To Tom Tillemans / Philosophy East and West 63(3) : 426~435

[book] DEGUCHI Yasuo / What Can’t be Said: Contradiction and Paradox in East Asian Thought

[book] DEMIÉVILLE, Paul / 1952 / Le Concile de Lhasa. Une controverse sur le quiétisme entre bouddhistes de l’Inde et de la Chine au VIIIe siècle de l’ère chrétienne / Imprimerie Nationale de France

[book] FAURE, Bernard / 1997 / The Will to Orthodoxy: A Critical Genealogy of Northern Chan Buddhism / Stanford University Press

[book] GANERI, Jonardon / 2012 / The Self: Naturalism, Consciousness, and the First-person Stance / Oxford University Press

[journal] GARFIELD, Jay L. / 2003 / Nāgārjuna and the Limits of Thought / Philosophy East and West 53(1) : 1~21

[book] GARFIELD, Jay L. / 2015 / Engaging Buddhism: Why It Matters to Philosophy / Oxford University Press

[book] GERNET, Jacques / 1977 / Entretiens du maître dhyâna Chen-Houei du Ho-Tsö (668-760) / Ecole Française d’Extrême-Orient

[book] GÓMEZ, Luis O. / 1983 / Studies in Ch’an and Hua-Yen (Kuroda Studies in East Asian Buddhism no. 1) / University of Hawai’i Press : 69~167

[book] GREGORY, Peter N. / 2012 / Readings of the Platform Sutra (Columbia Readings of Buddhist Literature) / Columbia University Press : 77~108

[book] HAKAMAYA Noriaki 袴谷憲昭. / 1989 / Hongaku shisō hihan 本覚思想批判 / Daizō shuppan

[book] HAKAMAYA Noriaki 袴谷憲昭 / 1990 / Hihan bukkyō 批判仏教 / Daizō shuppan

[book] HANSEN, Chad / 1983 / Language and Logic in Ancient China / University of Michigan Press

[book] HARBSMEIER, Christoph / 1998 / Science and Civilisation in China, Vol. 7, Part 1, Language and Logic / Cambridge University Press

[book] HALBERTAL, Moshe / 1992 / Idolatry / Harvard University Press

[book] HEINE, Steven / 1997 / Pruning the Bodhi Tree: The Storm over Critical Buddhism / University of Hawai’i Press : 251~285

[book] HU Shi 胡適 / 1968 / Shenhui heshang yiji—fu Hu xiansheng zuihou de yanjiu 神會和尚遺集—附胡先生最後的研究 / Hu Shi jinian guan

[book] HUBBARD, Jamie / 1997 / Pruning the Bodhi Tree: The Storm Over Critical Buddhism / University of Hawai’i Press

[journal] KING, Richard / 1995 / ‘Buddha-Nature’ Buddhist? / Numen 42(1) : 1~20

[book] LUSTHAUS, Dan / 2002 / Buddhist Phenomenology: A Philosophical Investigation of Yogācāra Buddhism and the Ch’eng Wei-shih Lun / RoutledgeCurzon

[book] MCRAE, John R. / 1987 / Sudden and Gradual: Approaches to Enlightenment in Chinese Thought / University of Hawai’i Press : 227~278

[book] MATSUMOTO Shirō 松本史朗 / 1989 / Engi to kū: Nyoraizō shisō hihan 縁起と空：如来蔵思想批判 / Daizō shuppan

[book] MATSUMOTO Shirō 松本史朗 / 1993 / Zen shisō no hihanteki kenkyū 禪思想の批判的研究 / Daizō shuppan

[book] MATSUMOTO Shirō 松本史朗 / 1997 / Pruning the Bodhi Tree: The Storm Over Critical Buddhism / University of Hawai’i Press : 242~250

[book] MATSUMOTO Shirō 松本史朗 / 2000 / Dōgen shisōron 道元思想論 / Daizō shuppan

[book] RADICH, Michael / 2015 / The Mahāparinirvāṇa-mahāsūtra and the Emergence of Tathāgatagarbha Doctrine / Hamburg University Press

[book] RUEGG, David Seyfort / 1969 / La théorie du Tathāgatagarbha et du Gotra: Études sur la Sotériologie et la Gnoséologie du Bouddhisme. Publications de l’École Française d’Extrême-Orient 70 / École Française d’Extrême-Orient

[book] RUEGG, David Seyfort / 1989 / Buddha-Nature, Mind and the Problem of Gradualism in a Comparative Perspective: On the Transmission and Reception of Buddhism in India and Tibet / School of Oriental and African Studies, University of London

[book] SHARF, Robert H. / 2007 / Thinking with Cases: Specialized Knowledge in Chinese Cultural History / University of Hawai’i Press : 205~243

[book] SHARF, Robert H. / 2014 / India in the Chinese Imagination: Myth, Religion, and Thought / University of Pennsylvania Press : 141~170

[journal] SHARF, Robert H / 2014 / Mindfulness and Mindlessness in Early Chan / Philosophy East and West 64(4) : 933~964

[journal] SHARF, Robert H / 2016 / Is Yogācāra Phenomenology? Some Evidence From the Cheng weishi lun / Journal of Indian Philosophy 44(4) : 777~807

[journal] SHARF, Robert H. / 2018 / Knowing Blue: Early Buddhist Accounts of Non-conceptual Sense Perception / Philosophy East and West 68(3)

[book] SHIELDS, James Mark / 2011 / Critical Buddhism Engaging with Modern Japanese Buddhist Thought / Ashgate

[book] SHIMODA Masahiro 下田正弘 / 1997 / Nehangyō no kenkyū: Daijō kyōten no kenkyū hōhō shiron 涅槃経の研究:大乘経典の研究方法試論 / Shunjūsha

[report] TAKASAKI Jikidō 高崎直道 / 1966 / A Study of the Ratnagotravibhāga (Uttaratantra) Being a Treatise on the Tathāgatagarbha Theory of Mahāyāna Buddhism, Including a Critical Introduction, a Synopsis of the Text, a Translation from the Original Sanskrit Text, in Comparison with Its Tibetan and Chinese Versions, Critical Notes, Appendixes And Indexes / Instituto Italiano per il Medio ed Estremo Oriente

[book] TAKASAKI Jikidō 高崎直道 / 1974 / Nyoraizō shisō no keisei 如來蔵思想の形成 / Shunjūsha

[book] TILLEMANS, Tom J. F. / 2009 / Pointing at the Moon: Buddhism, Logic, Analytic Philosophy / Oxford University Press : 83~100

[journal] TILLEMANS, Tom J. F / 2013 / ‘How Do Mādhyamikas Think?’ Revisited / Philosophy East and West 63(3) : 417~425

[book] TILLEMANS, Tom J. F. / 2013 / A Companion to Buddhist Philosophy / John Wiley & Sons : 290~306

[book] Tōdai goroku kenkyūhan 唐代語録研究班 / 2006 / Jinne no goroku: dango 神会の語錄 : 檀語 / Zen bunka kenkyūjo (Hanazono University)

[book] TUCK, Andrew / 1990 / Comparative Philosophy and the Philosophy of Scholarship: On the Western Interpretation of Nāgārjuna / Oxford University Press

[book] YAMPOLSKY, Philip B. / 1967 / The Platform Sutra of the Sixth Patriarch: The Text of the Tun-huang Manuscript with Translation, Introduction, and Notes / Columbia University Press

[book] YANAGIDA Seizan 柳田聖山 / 1971 / Shoki no zenshi I 初期の禪史 I. Zen no goroku 禪の語録 2 / Chikuma shobō

[book] YANAGIDA Seizan 柳田聖山 / 1984 / Sodōshū sakuin 祖堂集索引. 3 vols / Kyōto daigaku jinbun kagaku kenkyūjo

[book] YANG Zengwen 楊曾文 / 1996 / Shenhui heshang chanhua lu 神會和尚禪話錄 / Zhonghua shuju

[book] ZIMMERMANN, Michael / 2002 / A Buddha Within: The Tathāgatagarbhasūtra: The Earliest Exposition of the Buddha-Nature Teaching in India / The International Research Institute for Advanced Buddhology, Soka University

[book] ZIPORYN, Brook / 2000 / Evil And/or/as the Good: Omnicentrism, Intersubjectivity, and Value Paradox in Tiantai Buddhist Thought / Harvard University Press

[journal] ZIPORYN, Brook / 2013 / A Comment on ‘The Way of the Dialetheist : Contradictions in Buddhism, ’ by Yasuo Deguchi, Jay L. Garfield, and Graham Priest / Philosophy East and West 63(3) : 344~352

KJC Korea
Journal Central

Statistics

Tools

Sharing

Issue List

Citation status