The Estimation on the Contents of Wonhyo’s “Reconciliation of Dispute in the Aspect of Seeds” in Reconciliation of Disputes in Ten Aspects

Yeongil Kim

doi:10.29213/crbs..26.201910.159

This paper estimated the contents of Wonhyo’s “Reconciliation of Dispute in the Aspect of Seeds” in Reconciliation of Disputes in Ten Aspects which is not handed down in a complete form today. What has helped the paper do so much is the Seokwhaumkyobunki-wontongcho (釋華嚴敎分記圓通抄), Daeseongkisinron-dongeeyakgip (大乘起信論同異略集) and the Discourse on the Theory of Consciousness-only (成唯識論). In the first section of ‘standpoint’, the three theories proclaim their basic position. The first theory states that there are only ‘the originally existed seeds’, and that they are only augmented by perfumation. According to the second theory, there are only ‘the newly perfumed seeds’, which are only achieved by perfumation. In addition, the third theory states that there are both ‘the originally existed seeds’ and ‘the newly perfumed seeds’. In the second section of ‘debate’, we can see the three theories attacks each others. The second theory refutes the relation between the 7 consciousnesses and the 8th consciousness. The first theory criticizes that the seeds of no agony will not be able to occur. The third theory debates the second theory saying, “There are not only the newly perfumed seeds but also the originally existed seeds.” In the third section of ‘conclusion’, Wonhyo decides that all the three theories are right. The reason is that the first theory is correct under the condition of taking the results according to the nature, that the second theory is right under the condition of taking the outcomes according to the function, and that the third theory is true under the condition of taking the consequences according to harmonizing the two factors.

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (1)
열림/닫힘 버튼
REFERENCES (24)
열림/닫힘 버튼
* 2021년 이후 발행 논문의 참고문헌은 현재 구축 중입니다.

[other] 菩提留支 / 入楞伽經, T.16, No.0671

[other] 玄奘 / 瑜伽師地論, T.30, No.1579

[other] 曇無讖 / 菩薩地持經, T.30, No.1581

[other] 求那跋摩 / 菩薩善戒經, T.30, No.1582

[other] 玄奘 / 成唯識論, T.31, No.1585

[other] 玄奘 / 攝大乘論本, T.31, No.1594

[other] 玄奘 / 攝大乘論釋, T.31, No.1597

[other] 遁倫 / 瑜伽論記, T.42, No.1827

[other] 基 / 成唯識論述記, T.43, No.1830

[other] 見登 / 大乘起信論同異略集, H.03, No.0050

[other] 均如 / 釋華嚴敎分記圓通抄, H.04, No.0059

[journal] 고영섭 / 2007 / 원효 『십문화쟁론』 연구의 지형도: 조명기ㆍ최범술ㆍ이종익ㆍ이만용 복원문의 검토 / 문학사학철학 / 한국불교사연구소 발해동양학한국학연구원 10 : 131~165

[thesis] 김영일 / 2008 / 원효의 화쟁논법 연구 : 화쟁의 실례를 중심으로 / 박사 / 동국대학교 대학원

[journal] 김영일 / 2012 / Wonhyo's Theory of Harmonization on the Dispute of the Existence and the Emptiness / 한국불교학 / 한국불교학회 (64) : 219~241

[journal] 김영일 / 2013 / The Study on The Chapter on the Reconciliation of Dispute on the Buddha-nature in The Treatise on the Reconciliation of Disputes in Ten Aspects of Wonhyo / 한국불교학 / 한국불교학회 (66) : 195~221

[journal] 김영일 / 2015 / Wonhyo' Theory of Harmonization on the Buddha-body - the Permanence or the Impermanence of Reward Body - / 대각사상 / 대각사상연구원 (23) : 289~315

[book] 김영일 / 2019 / 화쟁사상 / 혜안출판사

[journal] 김운학 / 1978 / 원효의 화쟁사상 / 불교학보 / 동국대학교 불교문화연구원 15 : 173~182

[book] 박태원 / 2013 / 원효의 십문화쟁론 / 세창출판사

[journal] 박태원 / 2017 / The formation and development of Won-Hyo(元曉)’s reconciliatory philosophy(和諍哲學) - Centering on the Mun(門)-division thinking - / 철학논총 / 새한철학회 90(4) : 239~262

[book] 오법안 / 1989 / 원효의 화쟁사상연구 / 홍법원

[journal] 이동우 / 2003 / Discussion of “the origin of Seeds(B？ja)” mentioned in CH’ENG WEI-SHIH LUN (『成唯識論』, Vij？aptim？trat？siddhi) / 한국불교학 / 한국불교학회 (33) : 165~183

[book] 이만용 / 1983 / 원효의 사상 / 전망사

[book] 이종익 / 2002 / 한국의 사상가 10인: 원효 / 예문서원 : 229~272

KJC Korea
Journal Central

Statistics

Tools

Sharing

Issue List

Citation status