The Normalization of Universal Male Conscription in South Korean Society and the State Regulation of Draft Evasion and Conscientious Objection: 1950–1993

Peter W. MILNE

doi:10.22901/trans.2014.7.3.125

This paper traces the history of conscientious objection and draft evasion in Republic of Korea, from the outbreak of the Korean War in 1950 to the end of the militarized regimes in 1993. Much focus will be given to the process in which universal male conscription was established and solidified as a social norm in South Korean society. It was during the Korean War period when universal male conscription began to be negatively perceived as a “poor man’s draft” and led to rampant draft evasion that the Syngman Rhee regime (1948- 1960) failed to control. The normalization process began during the militarized regime of Chung-hee Park (1961–1979), when social impetuses were established alongside hegemonic masculinity and gender hierarchy to necessitate the completion of compulsory military service for men to function in society. It also coincided with the increased criminalization of draft evasion, as well as the persecution and stigmatization of religious conscientious objectors in South Korea, such as the Jehovah’s Witnesses and the Seventh-day Adventists, who were viewed indifferently from draft evaders. The negative labeling of draft evader and conscientious objectors as social deviants was also a state-led initiative to solidify universal male conscription as a social norm. This process was supported by the implementation of a national surveillance system which made possible the intensification of a nation-wide crackdown on draft evasion and conscientious objection. Much of the historical narrative will be analyzed using Foucauldian approaches to disciplinary mechanisms; in this case, normalization, surveillance and delinquency. The successful implementation of these disciplinary mechanisms perpetuated the normalized existence of universal male conscription and the persecution of its objectors, and its firm standing in South Korean society exemplifies the power of normalization.

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (0)
REFERENCES (64)
열림/닫힘 버튼
* 2021년 이후 발행 논문의 참고문헌은 현재 구축 중입니다.

[other] / 1973 / Crackdown on Six Biggest Social Evils / Chosun Daily

[other] / 1954 / Catching a Draft Evader / Chosun Daily

[other] / 1954 / cription Law Violator Amnesty Instructions Written Under the Jurisdiction of the Secretary of Interior / Chosun Daily

[other] / 1971 / The Problems Draft Evasion Crackdown / Chosun Daily

[other] / 1972 / List of Draft Evaders to be Made Public / Joongang Daily

[other] / 1974 / Jehovah’s Witness Arrested for Hiding a Draft Evader / Kyunghyang Newspaper

[other] / 1960 / Draft Evaders’ Situation / Chosun Daily

[other] / 1956 / Conscription Evasion, Persuasion through Enlightenment / Chosun Daily

[other] / 1956 / Young Man Cross-Dresses and Works as Housemaid to Avoid Draft / Chosun Daily

[journal] Cho, Kuk / 2007 / Conscientious Objection to Military Service in Korea: The Rocky Path from Being an Unpatriotic Crime to a Human Right / Or. Rev. Int’l L 9 : 187~224

[journal] Choi, Christine / 2006 / Military Conscription and Human Rights in the Republic of Korea: The Right of Conscientious Objection / Temp. Int’l & Comp. L.J 20 : 133~163

[book] Connel, R. W. / 1995 / Masculinities / Polity Press

[other] / 1959 / Judge Becomes Furious / Chosun Daily

[book] Enloe, Cynthia / 1988 / Does Khaki Become You? The Militarization of Women’s Lives / Pandora Press

[report] Fautre, Willy / For South Korea Without Prisoners of Conscience A report by Human Rights Without Frontiers International / Human Rights Without Frontiers International

[book] Foucault, Michel / 1995 / Discipline and Punish: Birth of the Prison / Vintage Books

[book] Fujitani, Takashi / 2011 / Race for Empire: Koreans as Japanese and Japanese as Americans during World War II / University of California Press

[other] / 1968 / Permanent Personal Numbers / Donga Daily

[other] / 1963 / Shaded Rights of Those Who Have Not Completed Their Conscription Duties / Chosun Daily

[other] / 1956 / Methods of Draft Evasion Crackdown / Chosun Daily

[other] / 1957 / National Consciousness and Religious Consciousness / Chosun Daily

[other] / 1957 / Is Church Doctrine More Important than Constitutional Law? / Korea Daily

[other] / 1958 / Talking Nonsense / Donga Daily

[other] Hong, Dae-Il / 2013 / interview. 5 Aug. 2013

[journal] 홍성태 / 2006 / 주민등록 제도와 총체적 감시사회 – 박정희 독재의 구조적 유산 / 민주사회와 정책연구 9 : 262~283

[journal] Hong, Seong-Tae / 2006 / Yusin Dictatorship and the Resident Registration System in Korea / Democratic Society and Policy Research 9 : 91~112

[other] / 1973 / Military Service as Human Duty / Chosun Daily

[other] / 1969 / Government Implements Multi-Functional Social Security System / Donga Daily

[book] Hong-Gu Han / 2008 / Those Who Do Not Hold Guns / Cheolsu and Yeonghui

[journal] Jin, Sang-Beam / 2006 / National and Religious Responses to Conscientious Objection in South Korean Society / Religion and Culture Research / University of Toronto Library 8 : 191~217

[other] / 1952 / Discussion in National Assembly About Conscription, Conscription Corruption / Donga Daily

[other] / 1952 / Persuading Conscription Evaders / Chosun Daily

[journal] Kahng, Byung Sun / 1992 / The Yushin Constitution and the Establishment of Bureaucratic Authoritarianism in the Republic of Korea / Korea Observer 23(3) : 177~195

[journal] Kang, In-Cheol / 2005 / South Korean Society and Conscientious Objection: History and Characteristics / Religion Culture Research 7 : 103~141

[thesis] 강인화 / 2007 / 한국사회의 병역거부 운동을 통해 본 남성성 연구 / 석사 / 이화여자대학교 대학원

[journal] 김동춘 / 2006 / How did the Formation of Divided State create the Character of Citizenship in Korea / 경제와 사회 / 비판사회학회 (70) : 168~189

[journal] 김동춘 / 2012 / War-politics in Spy-Making- October Yushin as Ruling Order / 민주사회와 정책연구 / 민주사회정책연구원 (21) : 146~174

[other] Kim, Dong In / 2013 / List of Imprisoned Jehovah’s Witnesses from 1974 to 2000 / Public Relations Office of the South Korea Jehovah’s Witness Headquarters. 21Nov. 2013. Web

[other] / 1961 / Finished with Guilty Lifestyle, Bright Expressions during Surrender Period / Chosun Daily

[journal] Kwon, Insook / 2001 / A Feminist Exploration of Military Conscription: The Gendering of the Connections between Nationalism, Militarism, and Citizenship in South Korea / International Feminist Journal of Politics 3(1) : 26~54

[report] Kwon, Insook / 2012 / The Hegemonic Influence of the Masculinity of the U.S. Army:Focusing on the Case of KATUSA in South Korea / All Academic Research

[other] Kwon, Oh-Sung / 2009 / Individuals Who Refused Arms Accused of Being Communists, Water Tortured, ‘Intentional Murder,’ / Hankyoreh Newspaper

[journal] 임재성 / 2010 / The History of Conscience Objection in South Korea : Approached through the Making Process of Conscription System / 사회와역사(구 한국사회사학회논문집) / 한국사회사학회 (88) : 387~422

[other] / 1974 / Shameful ‘Draft Evader’s House Sign / Chosun Daily

[book] Moon, Seungsook / 1998 / The Women and War Reader / New York University Press : 90~100

[book] Moon, Seungsook / 2005 / Militarized Modernity and Gendered Citizenship in South Korea / Duke University Press

[journal] Moon, Seungsook / 2005 / Trouble with Conscription, Entertaining Soldiers: Popular Culture and the Politics of Militarized Masculinity in South Korea / Men and Masculinities 8(1) : 64~92

[journal] 문수현 / 2012 / An Analysis of the Debate over Conscientious Objection in Korea / Seoul Journal of Korean Studies / 규장각한국학연구원 25(2) : 243~274

[journal] 문수현 / 2009 / The Debate about Conscientious Objection in West Germany / 역사와 문화 / 문화사학회 (17) : 106~133

[other] OHCHR / International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights / OHCHR. org. United Nationals Human Rights Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights, n.d. Web

[confproc] Oh, Hyunji / 2009 / Conscientious Objection Movement in South Korea, In Conscientious Objection In South Korea / War Resisters’ International and Korea Solidarity for Conscientious Objection : 4~5

[other] Pak, Noja / 2009 / Militarism and Anti-militarism in South Korea: ‘Militarized Masculinity’ and Conscientious Objector Movement / The Asia-Pacific Journal: Japan Focus

[book] Park, Chung-hee / 1970 / Major Speeches by Korea’s Park Chung Hee / Hollym Corporation : 229~236

[book] Park, Chung-hee / 1962 / Our Nation’s Path / Hollym Corporation

[book] Peukert, Detlev / 1987 / Inside Nazi Germany: Conformity, Opposition and Racism in Everyday Life / B.T. Batsford Ltd

[other] / 1962 / Treated Unfairly, Those Who Have Not Completed Their Conscription Duty / Chosun Daily

[report] Military Manpower Administration / 1975 / Report on the Meetings with Jehovah’s Witness Leadership Conscription Evasion Prevention Measures / Gukgagirog-won [National Archive and Research Services

[report] The Presidential Secretariat / 1975 / Report on the Preventive Measure of ‘Jehovah’s Witnesses’ Conscription Evasion / National Archive and Research Services

[report] Presidential Commission on Suspicious Deaths in the Military / 2008 / Report of the Presidential Commission for the Investigation of Suspicious Deaths in the Military / National Archive and Research Services

[journal] 신병식 / 2006 / The Military Conscription System and the Myth of 'Sacred Obligation of National Defence' during the Park Regime / 경제와 사회 / 비판사회학회 (72) : 148~172

[other] / South Korea Separates Hundreds of Conscientious Objectors From Criminals / Chosun Daily

[other] / Jehovah’s Witness Father Arrested / Chosun Daily

[other] / 1986 / Accusations of Former Jehovah's Witnesses / Chosun Daily

[other] / 1975 / 63 Jehovah’s Witnesses Charged / Chosun Daily

KJC Korea
Journal Central

Statistics

Tools

Sharing

Issue List

Citation status