Views and Representation ― A Symptomatic Reading of 'Hahoe Byeolsingut Tallori'

Young-bae Lee

doi:10.22901/trans.2010.3.1.109

This study aims to depart from religious aspects of 'Hahoe Byeolsingut Tallori' as much as possible and identify colonialism and otherness implicated in the narrative of 'Hahoe Byeolsingut Tallori'. At the same time, it also tries to analyze the meaning, relationship and conflict structures of 'Hahoe Byeolsingut Tallori'. 'Hahoe Byeolsingut Tallori' shows modernity symptoms, ethnic symptoms, colonial symptoms, capitalistic symptoms and civilizational symptoms. The symptoms are based on the territories of various political entities, states, ideologies, imperialism, market and culture respectively. However, the study focuses on civilizational, ethnic and colonial symptoms to determine their cultural meanings, that is, meanings of representation and views, colonialism in ideology and mind, and the violence of imperialism. In fact, regarding the restoration of 'Hahoe Byeolsingut Tallori,' several critical examinations have been made about the restoration times and their political intentions in the light of the thematic framework of ‘made traditions’ or ‘origins and birth,’ which is already common in academia. However, those studies have mainly focused on the performance environment as well as ritual and shamanistic traditions and performance forms in the context of local history. In a sense, it can be said that while the understanding of the text is still transcendent, essential or original, that of the outside of the text is modern, constructive and thus double-layered. Therefore, it is necessary to explore the gap, and a variety of interpretations of the text can be considered as a solution. Given that folklore is accompanied by shifts in paradigms due to the influence of continuity, variation and selection, especially of epistemological breakage, studies on Tallori’s performance text should be given due consideration of the performance forms in alignment with the times and the points of time in content changes. Even though 'Hahoe Byeolsingut Tallori' was one of the cultural practices under the Japanese colonial regime, it is thought that its performance forms still have in it or around it newly organized and assigned ideologies and desires of the partaker, performer and audience amidst the collapsed Chosun society’s ideological and cultural foundations. Hence, it is possible to identify the states and natures of the potentiality, though partial, when an examination is made on the aspects of the breakage that retroacts to the Japanese colonial period when the performance of 'Hahoe Byeolsingut Tallori' was banned.

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (2)
열림/닫힘 버튼
REFERENCES (32)
열림/닫힘 버튼
* 2021년 이후 발행 논문의 참고문헌은 현재 구축 중입니다.

[book] 김덕진 / 2008 / 대기근, 조선을 뒤덮다 / 푸른역사

[journal] 김완배 / 1989 / 양반탈과 선비탈의 재검토 / 안동문화연구 3

[book] 김택규 / 1982 / 한국민속연구논문선"Ⅲ / 일조각

[journal] 남근우 / 2002 / ‘조선 민속학’과 식민주의: 송석하의 문화민족주의를 중심으로 / 한국문화인류학 / 한국문화인류학회 35(2)

[journal] 류한상 / 1959 / ｢하회별신가면무극대사 / 국어국문학 20

[journal] 박진태 / 1990 / 하회별신굿탈놀이 / 비교민속학 6

[book] 박진태 / 1990 / 탈놀이의 기원과 구조 / 새문사

[book] 박진태 / 2006 / 하회별신굿탈놀이 / 피아

[book] 박천홍 / 2008 / 악령이 출몰하던 조선의 바다 / 현실문화연구

[book] 백승종 / 2006 / 정감록 역모사건의 진실게임 / 푸른역사

[book] 서연호 / 1991 / 서낭굿탈놀이 / 열화당

[journal] 성병희 / 1980 / 하회별신탈놀이 / 한국민속학 12

[book] 성병희 / 1978 / 우리고장의 민속 / 경상북도 대구

[book] 안동문화연구소 / 1999 / 하회탈과 하회탈춤의 미학 / 사계절

[book] 앙드레 슈미트 / 2007 / 제국 그 사이의 한국 / 휴머니스트

[journal] 이두현 / 1982 / 하회별신굿탈놀이 / 한국문화인류학 14

[book] 이두현 / 1994 / 한국가면극 / 서울대학교 출판부

[book] 이영배 / 2008 / 교정과 봉합, 혹은 탈주와 저항의 사회극 / 아카넷

[journal] 이재호 / 1975 / 하회별신가면무극대사 / 한국문학 20

[book] 임재해 / 2005 / 하회탈, 그 한국인의 얼굴 / 민속원

[journal] 임재해 / 1986 / 탈과 조각품으로 본 하회탈의 예술성과 사회성 / 예술과 비평 9

[journal] 임재해 / 2008 / New Understanding of Tradition and Beauty of Korean Masked-dance / 비교민속학 / 비교민속학회 (37) : 377~460

[book] 정교 / 2004 / 대한계년사 3 / 소명

[book] 조동일 / 1979 / 탈춤의 역사와 원리 / 홍성사

[journal] 조정현 / 2005 / The Reproduction of Hahoe-Talchoom and a Changing Image of Andong Culture / 비교민속학 / 비교민속학회 (29) : 339~376

[journal] 조정현 / 2008 / A Character of Ritual and Festival on Viewing ByulShin-Gut of Andong Province / 비교민속학 / 비교민속학회 (35) : 361~408

[book] 질 들뢰즈 / 2004 / 차이와 반복 / 민음사

[book] 최남선 / 1972 / 조선상식문답속편 / 삼성문화문고

[book] 최상수 / 1985 / 산대·성황신제 가면극의 연구 / 성문각

[book] 최상수 / 1959 / 하회가면극의 연구 / 고려서적주식회사

[journal] 한양명 / 2008 / Tradition of Local Community Festival and Transformation of Folklore / 비교민속학 / 비교민속학회 (35) : 445~475

[journal] 한양명 / 2007 / Rethinking the Meaning of Buddhist Priests and their Madang in Mask Play / 비교민속학 / 비교민속학회 (34) : 455~490

이 논문은 한국연구재단의 지원을 받아 작성되었습니다.

KJC Korea
Journal Central

Statistics

Tools

Sharing

Issue List

Citation status