Why So Serious? Toward Online Game Ethics: Wittgenstein’s “Norm” and Levinas’s “Il y a” as Illumination
Publisher : Ewha Institute for the Humanities: EIH
Research Area : Other Humanities
1National Taiwan University
-
This paper first tries to spell out the literary review of the game discourses by seminal figures like Johan Huizinga, Roger Caillois, and Hans‐Georg Gadamer. Then, by introducing Ludwig Wittgenstein’s notion of ‘norm’ and ‘family resemblance,’ it is argued that the ethics of games today holds the key to the metaphysical prison of the traditional game. Next, the Massively‐Multiplayer Online Role‐Playing Game (MMORPG) WOW (World of Warcraft) is chosen in particular, as the text set in motion to exemplify the operation of game ethics in a postmodern age. Furthermore, Emmanuel Levinas’ concept of “Il y a” will be appropriated to beacon the way out of the intrinsic contradiction in this kind of postmodern MMORPG. “Il y a” is a state of ineluctable ‘presence of absence,’ an impersonal and anonymous ‘there is,’ which echoes the feature of anonymity in a MMORPG, where the game is still on, and the chosen character is still there even when a player takes a break, logging out and shutting down the computer. The player seems absent but in fact present, entering a state of ‘presence of absence,’ owing debt to the other players as inter‐subjects. It is in this sense that the ethical responsibility is involved. For Levinas, real time exists only in synchronic intersubjectivity, which can emancipate the subject from self‐identity through diachronic time in traditional games (readily reminiscent of Agamben’s implication of game as a time‐accelerator). The immediacy of online games welcomes and allows any player to join in at any time, whereas the traditional games refuse the impromptu joining due to the limit of artificial time such as a round, a set, or an inning. Also, it is also this immediacy of online games that makes the instant negotiation and modification of rules possible, paralleling Wittgenstein’s ‘norm’ again.
-
[book] Agamben, Giorgio / 1993 / Infancy and History: The Destruction of Experience / Verso
[book] Boswell, Marshall / 2003 / Understanding David Foster Wallace / University of South Carolina Press
[book] Caillois, Roger / 1961 / Man, Play, and Games / Free Press of Glencose
[book] Caygill, Howard / 2002 / Levinas and The Political / Routledge
[book] Corneliussen, Hilde G / 2008 / Digital Culture, Play, and Identity: A World of WarcraftⓇ Reader / The MIT Press : 1~15
[book] Gadamer, Hans‐Georg / 1989 / Truth and Method / The Crossroad Publishing Company
[book] Huizinga, Johan / 1955 / Homo Ludens: A Study of the Play‐element in Culture / Beacon
[book] Kolak, Daniel / 1997 / Lovers of Wisdom: A Historical Introduction to Philosophy with Integrated Readings / Wadsworth
[book] Levinas, Emmanuel / 1999 / Alterity and Transcendence / Athlone Press
[book] Levinas, Emmanuel / 1978 / Existence and Existents / Kluwer Academic Publishers
[report] Lyotard, Jean‐François / 1991 / Postmodern Condition: A Report on Knowledge / University of Minnesota Press
[other] / 2005 / More on the Web / Review. PC Magazine.com
[book] Newman, James / 2004 / Videogames / Routledge
[other] Pinckard, Jane / 2006 / World of Warcraft Is the New Golf: Tech Entrepreneurs Meet, Quest, and Talk Shop / PC Magazine : 108~109
[book] Wittgenstein, Ludwig / 1953 / Philosophical Investigations / Blackwell Publishers
[book] Wittgenstein, Ludwig / 1965 / Preliminary Studies for the 'Philosophical Investigations': Generally Known as The Blue and Brown Books / Harper and Row
[book] Wittgenstein, Ludwig / 1984 / Culture and Value / University of Chicago Press
-
KCI Citation (0)
92 Viewed
Print this page
Download PDF