Korean | English

pISSN : 2234-7534

2020 KCI Impact Factor : 0.95
Home > Author > Review Process

Review Process


1. The submitted paper will be decided in terms of appropriateness after a meeting of the editing committee.

2. The papers judged suitable for the screening shall be referred for review behind closed doors by selecting 3 examiners per paper.

3. The reviewer shall judge the results of the examination among publication accepted, publication accepted after correction, re-examination after correction and publication rejected in the paper review request, and describe the contents of examination and submit it to the editing committee.

4. The results of the paper review by the three examiners shall be returned to the contributor for correction.

5. If there is any objection to the judgment, a temporary editing committee consisting of three or more persons shall be convened immediately and the results of the judgment shall be notified to the person who raised the objection within one week.


[accept without any changes]

A: accept without any changes / B: accept without any changes / C: accept without any changes

A: accept without any changes / B: accept without any changes / C: accept with minor revisions


[accept with minor revisions]

A: accept without any changes / B: accept with minor revisions / C: accept with minor revisions

A: accept without any changes / B: accept with minor revisions / C: review after major revisions

A: accept with minor revisions / B: accept with minor revisions / C: review after major revisions


[review after major revisions]

A: review after major revisions / B: review after major revisions / C: review after major revisions

A: accept with minor revisions / B: review after major revisions / C: review after major revisions

A: accept without any changes / B: review after major revisions / C: review after major revisions

A: accept without any changes / B: review after major revisions / C: reject

A: accept with minor revisions / B: review after major revisions / C: reject

 

[editorial decision]

A: accept without any changes / B: accept without any changes / C: reject

A: accept with minor revisions / B: accept with minor revisions / C: reject

 

[reject]

A: accept without any changes / B: reject / C: reject

A: accept with minor revisions / B: reject / C: reject

A: review after major revisions / B: reject / C: reject

A: reject / B: reject / C: reject