The trend of research on the March 1st Movement and the direction of nationalism

Lee Yongki

doi:10.31218/TRKH.2020.09.139.133

KJC Korea
Journal Central

The Review of Korean History 2021 KCI Impact Factor : 1.28

Korean | English

pISSN : 1225-133X

http://journal.kci.go.kr/hksh

BACK
TOP

Home > Explore Content > All Issues > Article View

4 of 5

The trend of research on the March 1st Movement and the direction of nationalism

The Review of Korean History
2020, (139), pp.133-174
DOI : 10.31218/TRKH.2020.09.139.133

Publisher : The Historical Society Of Korea
Research Area : History

Received : July 28, 2020
Accepted : August 18, 2020
Published : September 30, 2020

Lee Yongki ¹

¹한국교원대학교

ABSTRACT
열림/닫힘 버튼

This article examines the changes in the perceptional terrain of the study of Korean modern history by reviewing the flow of the March 1st Movement study, but approaches the process of settlement, refraction, and implosion of the nationalist view. The research on the March 1st Movement began in earnest from 1969, the 50th anniversary of the movement, and while based on the nationalism that prevailed in Korean history academic circles at that time, it was constrained by the anti-communism of the Park Chung-hee regime, and thus tended to be a “conservative nationalism.” In 1989, which celebrated the 70th anniversary of the March 1st Movement, a divergence of research perspectives emerged clearly reflecting the political and ideological spectrum of the 1980s. The mainstream academia was divided into a tendency to adhere to the existing conservative position and a tendency toward a moderate national unity. The junior researchers holding a progressive position showed a tendency to “popular nationalism”, which aimed for a unified perception of national and class contradictions, and emphasized the people with class implications. In the 21st century, research on the trend of “post-nationalism” was prominent. These studies focused on the multi-layered behavior of multiple subjects, moving away from the dichotomy of domination and resistance, and raised values such as democracy, peace, and human rights apart from nationalism. As such, the change in the perspective of the March 1 Movement study from conservative nationalism to popular nationalism and recently post-nationalism shows a shift in the epistemological topography of the study of Korean modern history.
KEYWORDS
열림/닫힘 버튼

March 1st Movement, nationalism, post-nationalism, the people, multiple subjects

Statistics

126 Viewed

0 Downloaded

Tools

Print this page

Search PDF

Export Citation

Sharing

Facebook

Twitter

Issue List

Vol. No.148

Vol. No.147

Vol. No.146

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (1)
열림/닫힘 버튼
REFERENCES (26)
열림/닫힘 버튼
* 2021년 이후 발행 논문의 참고문헌은 현재 구축 중입니다.

[other] / 동아일보

[other] / 조선일보

[other] / 한겨레신문

[book] 동아일보사 / 1969 / 3·1운동 50주년 기념논집 / 동아일보사

[book] 동아일보사 / 1989 / (3·1운동 70주년 기념 심포지엄) 3·1운동과 민족통일 / 동아일보사

[book] 박헌호 / 2009 / 1919년 3월 1일에 묻다 / 성균관대학교출판부

[book] 한국역사연구회 / 1989 / 3·1 민족해방운동 연구 / 청년사

[book] 한국역사연구회 3·1운동100주년기획위원회 / 2019 / 3·1운동 100년 1~5 / 휴머니스트

[journal] 3·1운동100주년기획위원회 / 2019 / (좌담집) 3·1운동 100년의 기억과 기념 / 역사와 현실 114

[book] 강만길 / 1988 / 한국근현대 연구입문 / 역사비평사

[book] 김인걸 / 1997 / 한국사 인식과 역사이론 / 지식산업사

[journal] 김정인 / 2010 / 특집 : 내재적 발전론과 민족주의 / 역사와 현실 / 한국역사연구회 (77) : 179~214

[book] 배성준 / 2013 / 민중사를 다시 말한다 / 역사비평사

[journal] 백승덕 / 2019 / Beyond ‘Spectacular Nonviolence’: The Characteristics of the March 1st Movement Violence / 역사비평 / 역사문제연구소 (129) : 36~62 / 10.38080/crh.2019.11.129.36

[journal] 신주백 / 2014 / Formation of Internal Development in terms of Perspectives and Attitudes and Northeast Asian Intellectual Networks / 한국사연구 / 한국사연구회 (164) : 323~384

[journal] 신주백 / 2014 / The Formation of 'Internal Development' and the Emergence of Populous Nationalistic Historical Studies : New Awareness of the People and Discovery of Division / 동방학지 / 국학연구원 (165) : 193~233 / 10.17788/dbhc.2014..165.007

[journal] 오제연 / 2020 / Studies of the 100th Anniversary of the March 1 Movement and ‘the March 1 Revolution Theory’ / 역사비평 / 역사문제연구소 (130) : 162~193 / 10.38080/crh.2020.02.130.162

[journal] 윤해동 / 2006 / Dare We Criticize the Deus Obscurus?―The Internal Development Theory of Kim Yongs？p / 韓國史學史學報 / 한국사학사학회 (14) : 105~134

[book] 이용기 / 2013 / 민중사를 다시 말한다 / 역사비평사

[journal] 이용기 / 2019 / Criticism of the Sanctification of Legitimacy Theory of the Provisional Government of Korea and the Rise of ‘ROK Nationalism’ / 역사비평 / 역사문제연구소 (128) : 326~352 / 10.38080/crh.2019.08.128.326

[journal] 이정은 / 2015 / 3·1운동 연구 100년 / 유관순 연구 20

[journal] 이종호 / 2020 / Research Flows and Knots on the March 1 Movement: In Commemoration of its Centennial Anniversary / 역사비평 / 역사문제연구소 (130) : 194~226 / 10.38080/crh.2020.02.130.194

[journal] 장원아 / 2019 / The 100th Anniversary Studies of the March 1 Movement and Current Perspectives: Democracy and Various Subjects / 역사비평 / 역사문제연구소 (129) : 8~35 / 10.38080/crh.2019.11.129.8

[journal] 정용욱 / 2018 / Current trends in historical studies of the March 1st movement, and where it is apparently headed / 역사와 현실 / 한국역사연구회 (110) : 269~304 / 10.35865/YWH.2018.12.110.269

[journal] 조은정 / 2019 / 100-year Spring Winds Blowing from March 1st Movement: The Narrative of Park Chan-seung and Gwon Bodeurae Regarding March 1st Movement / 역사비평 / 역사문제연구소 (129) : 63~83 / 10.38080/crh.2019.11.129.63

[journal] 천정환 / 2020 / The Popular Politics of 100th Anniversary of the March 1 Movement and the Present Situation of Korean Nationalism / 역사비평 / 역사문제연구소 (130) : 8~51 / 10.38080/crh.2020.02.130.8