A Critical Review on Sanction Theory and Its Effectiveness on North Korea: Focused on Reaction of Targeted State

NaHoseon; Cha， Chang Hoon

doi:10.18013/jnar.2020.35.1.002

The shift of North Korea’s foreign policy in 2018 was understood as the effectiveness of UN sanctions. This research criticizes the explanation that the change is the result of UN sanctions. Sanction theory generally focused upon its effectiveness but lacks in regarding reaction of the targeted state. The mechanism of interaction between sanction state and targeted state is required to refine theoretical ontology considering responses of targeted state. UN sanction against North Korea has two stages, symbolic and effective one, before and after 2016. UN sanction against North Korea overcome the unilateral, multilateral and third party defects and increased its effectiveness. North Korea, however, reacted against the sanction and utilized the sanction for stabilizing its political regime by completing its nuclear arsenal. North Korea sat on the table with its increased negotiation leverage for the purpose of improving US-North Korea relationship, not just nuclear issues. After all, the sanction itself did not resolve North Korean nuclear problem and North Korea’s nuclear build-up means the failure of sanction. The whole cost of US’s deal has been highly increased After North Korea aggressively reacted against UN sanction.

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (3)
열림/닫힘 버튼
REFERENCES (55)
열림/닫힘 버튼
* 2021년 이후 발행 논문의 참고문헌은 현재 구축 중입니다.

[journal] 강근형 / 2017 / Limits of Sanctions on North Korea after North Korea’s Nuclear Test and South Korea’s Responses / 신아세아 / 신아시아연구소 24(2) : 10~43 / 10.22869/nari.2017.24.2.001

[journal] 김근식 / 2011 / North Korea’s Nuclear Negotiations: Arguments, Actions, and Patterns / 한국과 국제정치 / 극동문제연구소 27(1) : 143~181 / 10.17331/kwp.2011.27.1.005

[journal] 나영주 / 2016 / Deploying THAAD in South Korea and China's corresponding strategy / 민족연구 / 사단법인 한국민족연구원 (67) : 48~77

[journal] 나호선 / 2018 / North Korea's Security Strategy based on Alliance Theory, from China-North Korea Alliance to Bandwagoning to US? / 21세기정치학회보 / 21세기정치학회 28(4) : 165~190 / 10.17937/topsr.28.4.201812.165

[journal] 남성욱 / 2019 / 식량난에 대한 북한의 이중적 태도 / 北韓

[book] 라몬 파체코 파르도 / 2016 / 북한 핵위기와 북·미 관계 / 연경문화사

[book] 마이크 치노이 / 2010 / 북핵 롤러코스터 / 시사 IN 북

[journal] 박지연 / 2013 / An Analysis of Factors Affecting North Korea's Decision-Making under Economic Sanctions: Developing and Applying a Prospect Theory Model / 북한연구학회보 / 북한연구학회 17(1) : 57~92

[journal] 박홍서 / 2006 / China's Management of Alliance Dilemma over the Nuclear Crisis in the Korean Peninsula: its Theory and Practice / 국제정치논총 / 한국국제정치학회 46(1) : 103~122

[report] 백학순 / 2014 / 제2기 오바마정부 시기의 북미관계 2013~2014 : ‘핵무기 사용 위협’과 관계의 파탄 / 세종연구소

[journal] 서보혁 / 2003 / 북-미관계 정상화의 국내정치적 제약: 국가정체성의 상호작용을 중심으로 / 사회연구 (2)

[journal] 양운철 / 2012 / Limits of UN’s Economic Sanctions against North Korea: Restraining Coercion and Enlarging Strategic Choice / 통일정책연구 / 통일연구원 21(2) : 143~175

[journal] 오준철 / 2017 / The Effect of Economic Sanction on North Korea’s Military Capabilities / Journal of North Korea Studies / 공공정책연구소 3(1) : 23~51

[book] 양문수 / 2016 / 북한에서 사적경제활동이 공적경제부문에 미치는 영향 분석 / 통일연구원

[report] 전봉근 / 2018 / 6·12 북미정상회담 평가와 한국외교에 대한 함의

[journal] 정한범 / 2018 / 미국의 대북제재에 대한 효과성 분석 / 광장 (219)

[report] 정형곤 / 2018 / 비핵화에 따른 대북경제제재 해제: 분석과 시사점 / 대외경제정책연구원

[book] 조성렬 / 2019 / 한반도 비핵화 리포트 : 포괄적 안보-안보 교환론 / 백산서당

[journal] 허재영 / 2016 / Analyzing the Effectiveness of Economic Sanctions against North Korea: Focus on Withholding of Food Aid / 한국과 국제정치 / 극동문제연구소 32(3) : 89~123 / 10.17331/kwp.2016.32.3.004

[report] KOTRA / 2019 / 2018년도 북한 대외무역 동향 / KOTRA

[journal] Ang, Adrian U-Jin / 2007 / When Do Economic Sanctions Work? Asymmetric Perceptions, Issue Salience, and Outcomes / Political Research Quarterly 60(1)

[journal] Blanchard, Jean-Marc F. / 1999 / The Political Economy of Naional Security: Economic Statecraft, Interdependence, and International Conflict / Security Studies 9

[book] Chan, Steve / 2000 / Sanctions as Economic Statecraft: Theory and Practice / Palgrave Macmillan

[journal] Cha, Victor / 2018 / The Right Way to Coerce North Korea - Ending the Threat Without Going to War / Foreign Affairs 97(3)

[journal] Drezner, Daniel W / 2000 / Bargainig, Enforcement, and Multilateral Sanctions: When Is Cooperation Counterproductive? / International Organization 54(1)

[journal] Early, Bryan R / 2012 / Alliances and Trade with Sanctioned States: A Study of U.S. Economic Sanctions, 1950-2000 / Journal of Conflict Resolution 56(3)

[other] FAO / 2019 / FAO/WFP Joint Rapid Food Security Assessment - Democratic People’s Republic of Korea / Bangkok

[book] Haggard, Stephan / 2017 / Hard Target: Sanctions, Inducements, and the Case of North Korea / Stanford University Press

[book] Hufbauer, Gary Clyde / 1990 / Economic Sanctions Reconsidered: History and Current Policy / Institute for International Economics

[book] Kim, Byung-Yeon / 2017 / Unveiling the North Korean Economy: Collapse and Transition / Cambridge University Press

[journal] McLean, Elena V. / 2010 / Friends or Foes? Major Trading Partners and the Success of Economic Sanctions / International Studies Quarterly 54(2)

[journal] Pape, Robert A / 1997 / Why Economic Sanctions Do Not Work / International Security 22(2)

[book] Taylor, Brendan / 2010 / Sanctions as Grand Strategy / Routledge

[other] / UNSCR 825, 1695, 1718, 1874, 2087, 2094, 2270, 2321, 2371, 2375, 2397

[journal] Whang, Taehee / 2011 / Playing to the Home Crowd? Symbolic Use of Economic Sanctions in the United States / International Studies Quarterly 55(3)

[other] / 2016 / 제7차 노동당대회 개회사 전문 / 한국일보

[other] / 트럼프 “대북 추가 제재 철회 지시”··· 북미 새로운 국면 맞나? / 경향신문

[other] / 2016 / [미국, 김정은 직접 제재]중 외교부” 대화·협력으로 북 인권 해결해야 “일방적 제재 반대 / 경향신문

[other] / 2011 / 中 ‘북 UEP 안보리 논의’ 반대 / 경향신문

[other] / 2013 / 北 “안보리 제재 배격... 핵보유국 지위 영구화 / 서울신문

[other] / 2019 / 김정은, 백마 타고 백두산 찾아...‘미(美)가 강요한 고통에 인민 분노’ / 조선일보

[other] / 2015 / 시진핑은 김정은에게 화나지 않았다 / 한국일보

[web] / 2016 / <北당대회> 김정은, 핵-경제 병진 ‘항구적 전략’ 선언...핵보유국 굳히기 / 연합뉴스 / https://www.yna.co.kr/view/AKR20160508016800014?input=1195m

[web] / 2013 / 北黨중앙위 전원회의, 경제·핵무력 병진노선 채택 / 연합뉴스 / https://news.naver.com/main/read.nhn?mode=LSD&mid=sec&sid1=100&oid=001&aid=0006177698

[other] / 2018 / North Korea Evades Sanctions / Washington Post

[other] Sanger, David E / 2016 / List of Options on North Korea Shrinrks for U.S / New York Times

[web] / 2018 / Final report of the Panel of Experts submitted pursuant to resolution 2345(2017) / UN Security Council / https://www.undocs.org/S/2018/171

[web] / 2014 / Report of the Panel of Experts established pursuant to resolution 1874(2009) / UN Security Council / https://www.undocs.org/S/2014/147

[web] / 2017 / Report of China on the implementation of Security Council resolution 2321(2016) / UN Security Council / https://www.un.org/ga/search/view_doc.asp?symbol=S/AC.49/2017/33

[web] 남북교류협력지원협회 / 2019 / I-RENK 북한지하자원넷 / http://www.irenk.net/v3.1/page1/p2_3.asp?m=3

[web] 우리은행 / 2019 / [환율조회]-[기간별 평균환율 조회]-[매매기준율] / https://sbiz.wooribank.com/biz/Dream?withyou=BZFXD0021

[web] 통계청 / 2019 / 북한통계 / http://kosis.kr/bukhan/statisticsList/statisticsList_01List.jsp#SubCont

[web] 통일부 / 2019 / [대북지원정보시스템]-[북한현황지표] / https://hairo.unikorea.go.kr/info/ExpIndex0202.do

[web] 한국광물자원공사 / 2019 / [KOMIS 한국자원정보서비스] / https://www.kores.net/komis/price/mineralprice/ironoreenergy/pricetrend/ironOreEnergy.do

[web] 한국은행 / 2007 / (2006년-2018년) 북한 경제성장률 추정결과 / https://www.bok.or.kr/portal/bbs/P0000559/list.do?menuNo=200690&searchWrd=%EB%B6%81%ED%95%9C%EA%B2%BD%EC%A0%9C&searchCnd=1&sdate=&edate=

KJC Korea
Journal Central

Statistics

Tools

Sharing

Issue List

Citation status