The Analysis of Plato’s Sophist

김태경

Plato's Sophist is dialogue which is systematically discussing with being through practice of dialectic. So in the analysis of this dialogue dialectic and ontology is not understood separately. This paper analyze procedures of dialectic which is now yet controversial. By this analysis division in the preceding part of this dialogue is downward division from genus to eidos which is related to hierarchy of forms and division in the later part is one related to mutual relation of forms which distinguishes forms at assumption of combination. Particularly division related to mutual relation of forms is related to not-being. At this time not-being is possible to combine forms by distinguishing one form from other form. In this mean not-being which is able to distinguish forms is otherness. Thereafter this paper bring out more clearly meaning of otherness by discussing of not-being.

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (0)
REFERENCES (61)
열림/닫힘 버튼
* 2022년 이후 발행 논문의 참고문헌은 현재 구축 중입니다.

[book] / 1990 / Platonis Opera I, Ⅱ, Ⅳ, Oxford Classical Texts / Clarendon Press

[book] / 1952 / Plato I, Ⅱ, Ⅲ / Havard Univ. Press

[book] / 1950 / Platon Ⅱ / Association Guillame Bude

[book] / 1977 / Platon Werke Ⅴ, Ⅵ, Ⅶ / Wissenschaftliche Buchgesellschaft

[book] 김태경 / 2000 / 소피스테스 / 한길사

[book] R.E. Allen / 1965 / Studies in Plato's Metaphysics

[book] / 1970 / Plato's 'Euthyphro' and the Earlier Theory of Forms

[book] Seth Benardete / 1984 / The Being of the Beautiful. Plato's Theaetetus, Sophist, and Statesman / Chicago Univ. Press

[book] R.G. Bluck / 1975 / Plato's Sophist / Manchester Univ. Press

[book] R.L. Campbell / Sophistes and Politikus of Plato / Clarendon

[book] H.F. Cherness / 1944 / Aristotle's Criticism of Plato and the Academy

[book] F.M. Cornford / 1970 / Plato's Theory of Knowledge / Routledge & Kengan Paul Ltd

[book] / 1957 / Plato and Parmenides / The Liberal Arts Press

[book] H. Diels / Die Fragmente der Vorsokratiker / Weidmann

[book] Hans-Georg Gadamer / 1980 / Dialogue and Dialectic / Yale Univ. Press

[book] N. Gulley / 1973 / Plato's Theory of Knowledge / Metheun & Co. Ltd

[book] R. Hackforth / 1972 / Plato's Phaedrus / Cambridge Univ. Press

[book] / 1972 / Plato's Philebus / Cambridge Univ. Press

[book] J. Klein / 1977 / Plato's Trilogy / Chicago Univ. Press

[book] Polarity and Analogy / 1966 / Polarity and Analogy / Cambridge Univ. Press

[book] E.M. Manasse / 1937 / Platons Sophistes and Politikos / Das Problem der Wahrheit

[book] M.H. Miller / 1980 / The Philosopher in Plato's Statesman

[book] J. Moline / 1981 / Plato's Theory of Understanding / Winsconsin Univ. Press

[book] R. Patterson / 1985 / Image and Reality in Plato's Metaphysics / Hackett Publishing Co. Inc

[book] W.J. Prior / 1985 / Unity and Development in Plato's Metaphysics / Croom Helm

[book] De. Rijk, L. M / 1986 / Plato's Sophist: A Phlisophical Commentary

[book] R. Robinson / 1958 / Plato's Earlier Dialectic / Clarendon Press

[book] S. Rosen / 1983 / Plato's Sophist / Yale Univ. Press

[book] W.G. Runciman / 1962 / Plato's Later Epistemology / Cambridge Univ. Press

[book] K.M. Sayre / Plato's Analytic Method / 1969

[book] / Plato's Late Ontology / 1983

[book] H.R. Scodel / 1987 / Diaeresis and Myth in Plato's Statesman / Vandenhoeck & Ruprecht

[book] J.B. Skemp / 1952 / Plato's Statesman / Loutledge & Kegan Paul Ltd

[book] H. Teloh / 1981 / The Development of Plato's Metaphysics / The Pensylvania State Univ. Press

[book] N.P. White / 1976 / Plato on Knowledge and Reality / Hacktett Publishing Co.

[journal] 김태경 / 1998 / 플라톤의 후기 변증술 / 철학연구

[journal] / 1999 / 플라톤의 변증술에 있어서 나눔과 결합 / 철학

[journal] / 2003 / 플라톤의 『소피스테스』편에서 변증술과 존재론 / 철학연구

[journal] 박종현 / 1987 / 플라톤의 結合理論 / 서양고전학연구 (창간)

[journal] 최정식 / 1996 / 『소피스트』편의 존재론적 성격」: 『소피스트』편 분석(Ⅰ) / 서양고전학연구

[journal] 양문흠 / 1992 / 소피스테스편에서의 ‘존재하는 것과 그렇지 않은 것을 구분하는 기준’의 문제 / 철학연구

[journal] H.C. Baldry / 1937 / “Plato's `Technical Terms'" in Classical Quarterly / ⅩⅩⅩⅠ 3(4)

[journal] M. Fattal / 1991 / LE SOPHISTE, Logos de la synthese ou logos de la division? / ETUDES SUR LE SOPHISTE PLATON

[journal] A. Gomez-Lobo / 1977 / Plato's Description of Dialectic in the Sophist 253d1-e2 / Phronesis

[confproc] C.H. Kahn / 1995 / The Place of Politicus in Plato's Later Work / Reading the Statesman: Proceedings of the Ⅲ Symposium Platonicum / Academia Verlag-Sankt Augustin

[journal] E.N. Lee / 1972 / Plato On Negation And Not-Being In The Sophist / Philosophical Review

[journal] A.C. Lloyd / Plato's Description of Division / Studies in Plato's Metaphysics

[journal] J.M.E. Moravcsik / 1973 / The Anatomy of Plato's Division / Exegesis and Argument, Phronesis Supplement

[journal] J.M.E. Moravscik / Plato's Method of Division / Patterns in Plato's Thought.

[journal] G.E.L. Owen / 1973 / Plato on the Undepictable / Exegesis and Argument, Phronesis Supplement

[journal] / 1971 / Plato On Not-Being / Plato

[journal] J. Reagan / 1965 / Being and Nonbeing in Plato's Sophist / The Modern Schoolman

[journal] Jean Roberts / 1998 / The Problem about Being in the Sophist / Plato

[journal] J. Standard / 1959 / Socratic Eros and Platonic Dialectic / Phronesis

[journal] J.R. Trevaskis / 1967 / Division and its Relation to Dialectic and Ontology in Plato / Phronesis

[journal] / 1968 / The μεγιστα γενη and the Vowel analogy of Plato, Sophist253 / Phronesis

[journal] / 1955 / The Sophistry of Noble Lineage (Plato, Sophistes 230a5-232b9) / Phronesis

[journal] M. Vanhoutte / 1948 / Note sur la communaute des genres dans le <Sophiste> / Revue Philosophique de Louvain

[journal] W. Waletzki / 1979 / Platons Ideenlehre und Dialektik in Sophistes 253d / Phronesis

[journal] M.V. Wedin / 1987 / Collection and Division in The Phaedrus and Statesman / Revue de Philosophie Ancienne

[journal] G. Wills / 1959 / Being in The Sophist / The Modern Schoolman

KJC Korea
Journal Central

Statistics

Tools

Sharing

Issue List

Citation status