Location Estimate of Daebang-gun by Ikeuchi Hiroshi and Its Characteristics

Kaya Wee

Ikeuchi Hiroshi (池內宏) is one of the Japanese historians who devotedhimself to positive-historical research of East Asian history in modern Japan. This study is aimed at figuring out whether or not his estimate of thelocation of Daebang-gun (帶方郡) — one of the four Han Commanderies (漢郡縣) in ancient Korea — and its influence on “positive-historical” researchare based on “rationalism” from the academic perspective. As a result, thestudy has examined the following facts. Ikeuchi maintained that Daebang-gun was located downstream from theHan River during the period of the Han Commanderies (漢郡縣). Hispositive-historical research made in the process was less precise than otherstudies of his and was far from the mode of rationalism. Besides, whencompared with other studies of Ikeuchi, such an academic suggestion wasbased on a view that “the history and culture of old Korea had beensubordinate to Manchuria (滿鮮史觀),” which was fully based on theheterogenous character of Korean history at its core. Ikeuchi’s understanding of the location of Daebang-gun was almostidentical with that of Shiratori Kurakichi (白鳥庫吉) and Tsuda Soukichi (津田左右吉). It must be noted that both scholars were the so-called “historiansof Manchuria-Korea (滿鮮史學者)” who made research of the relations between Manchuria and Joseon as they were working at the Historic-geographical Research Center of South Manchuria Railway Companies (南滿州鐵道會社). Although Ikeuchi had long proclaimed the importance of “positive-historicalresearch” and “rationalism” in his academic study, he only betrayed his ownphilosophy when the two ideas encountered with what he had regarded ascommon knowledge: the heteronomy of Korean history. This clearly showsthat even positive-historical research is not totally irrelevant to the reality andthe period of a historian.

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (5)
열림/닫힘 버튼
REFERENCES (41)
열림/닫힘 버튼
* 2022년 이후 발행 논문의 참고문헌은 현재 구축 중입니다.

[journal] 김영하 / 2008 / 일제시기의 진흥왕순수비론－‘滿鮮’의 경역인식과 관련하여－ / 한국고대사연구 / 한국고대사학회 (52) : 435~466

[journal] 김영하 / 2011 / Development and Implication of the Theory of Shilla’s Unification / 한국사연구 / 한국사연구회 (153) : 37~75

[book] 김영한 / 1987 / 史觀이란무엇인가 / 청람

[journal] 김용섭 / 1966 / 日本⋅韓國에 있어서의 韓國史敍述 / 歷史學報 31

[journal] 노태돈 / 2008 / Century of Study on Korean Ancient History / 한국고대사연구 / 한국고대사학회 (52) : 5~18

[book] 미쓰이 다카시 / 2009 / 역사학의 세기 –20세기 한국과 일본의 역사학 / 휴머니스트

[journal] 오영찬 / 2003 / 帶方郡의 郡縣支配 / 강좌 한국고대사 / 駕洛國史蹟開發硏究院 10

[journal] 오영찬 / 2012 / A Study on Research Perspectives and Works on Han Commanderies by the Sirak Scholars' of the Late Joseon Dynasty / 역사와 담론 / 호서사학회 (64) : 1~36

[journal] 윤선태 / 2001 / 馬韓의 辰王과 臣濆沽國 -領西濊 지역의 歷史的推移와 관련하여- / 百濟硏究 34

[journal] 윤선태 / 2013 / Critical Evaluation of the Historical Science in Contemporary and New Discoveries of Literary Data / 역사학보 / 역사학회 (219) : 3~21

[book] 윤용구 / 2009 / 고조선사 연구 100년 –고조선사연구의 현황과 쟁점- / 학연문화사

[book] 이기백 / 1996 / 韓國古代政治社會史硏究 / 一潮閣

[book] 이병도 / 1976 / 韓國古代史硏究 / 博英社

[journal] 이성시 / 2011 / 한국고대사연구와 식민지주의-그 극복을 위한 과제- / 한국고대사연구 / 한국고대사학회 (61) : 193~219

[journal] 조인성 / 2009 / 李丙燾의 韓國古代史硏究-漢四郡·三韓의 歷史地理硏究를 중심으로- / 한국고대사연구 / 한국고대사학회 (55) : 5~38

[book] 최재석 / 1990 / 日本古代史硏究批判 / 一志社

[book] 고바야시 히데오 / 2004 / 만철(滿鐵) 일본제국의 싱크탱크 / 산처럼

[book] 旗田巍 / 1983 / 日本人의 韓國觀 / 一潮閣

[book] 하종문 / 2011 / 20세기 일본의 역사학 / 삼천리

[book] 스테판 다나카 / 2004 / 일본 동양학의 구조 / 문학과지성사

[book] 鎌田正 / 1992 / 東洋學の系譜 / 大修館書店

[journal] 關野貞 / 1914 / 國內城及丸都城の位置 / 史學雜誌 25(11)

[journal] 那珂通世 / 1894 / 朝鮮樂浪玄菟帶方考 / 史學雜誌 5(4)

[journal] 大原利武 / 1927 / 帶水考 / 朝鮮 140

[book] 武田幸男 / 1999 / 20世紀の歷史家たち(2) / 刀水書房

[book] 白鳥庫吉 / 1913 / 滿洲歷史地理第1卷 / 丸善株式會社

[book] 白鳥庫吉 / 1913 / 滿洲歷史地理第1卷 / 丸善株式會社

[book] 窪德忠 / 1994 / 東洋學の系譜<第2集> / 大修館書店

[journal] 李丙燾 / 1929 / 眞番郡考 / 史學雜誌 40(5)

[book] 箭內亘 / 1913 / 滿洲歷史地理第1卷 / 丸善株式會社

[book] 田中正美 / 1992 / 東洋學の系譜 / 大修館書店

[book] 池內宏 / 1951 / 滿鮮史硏究上世1 / 吉川弘文館

[book] 池內宏 / 1960 / 滿鮮史硏究上世2 / 吉川弘文館

[book] 池內宏 / 1938 / 通溝上 / 日滿文化協會

[book] 池內宏 / 1951 / 滿鮮史硏究上世1 / 吉川弘文館

[book] 池內宏 / 1951 / 滿鮮史硏究上世1 / 吉川弘文館

[book] 池內宏 / 1951 / 滿鮮史硏究上世1 / 吉川弘文館

[book] 津田左右吉 / 1913 / 朝鮮歷史地理第1卷 / 丸善株式會社

[book] 津田左右吉 / 1913 / 朝鮮歷史地理第1卷 / 丸善株式會社

[book] 井上直樹 / 2013 / 帝國日本と滿鮮史 –大陸政策と朝鮮⋅滿洲認識- / 塙書房

[book] 池內宏 / 1970 / 日本上代史の一硏究 / 中央公論美術出版

KJC Korea
Journal Central

Statistics

Tools

Sharing

Issue List

Citation status