National Thoght and Empire - Tsuda Sokichi's Writings on China and Asia in the 1930s-

Lee, Seok-Won

Sokichi Tsuda is one of the representative historians of Japan in the 20thcentury whose view is interpreted quite differently between Korea and Japan. The Korean history circles say Sokichi Tsuda distorted the ancient history ofKorea with his “colonial view of history” as he had proposed that Mimana (任那; rènnà; or imna in Korean) was a Japanese colony on the Korean peninsulathat existed from the 3rd to the 6th century. The Japanese counterparts,however, have a favorable opinion that Tsuda confronted with the Emperorsystem of Japan and took a critical view of the Asia-Pacific War through hisobjective and scientific description of history. This study is aimed at chasingTsuda’s basic view of civilization and history based on his writings byovercoming the dichotomy with regard to Tsuda and the Tsuda school ofhistory (津田史學): “a historian with a colonial view of history” vs. “anintellect of resistance.” This paper intends to closely examine Tsuda’s theory ofChina and of the non-existence of the East he maintained in the 1930s and tofind out that the national thoughts of Japan as an individual civilization - whichTsuda ultimately tried to establish - was fully based on his view of history based on which he took an affirmative view of imperialism of Japan that hadcolonized Asian nations and invaded China.

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (2)
열림/닫힘 버튼
REFERENCES (26)
열림/닫힘 버튼
* 2021년 이후 발행 논문의 참고문헌은 현재 구축 중입니다.

[journal] 노병호 / 2013 / Minoda Muneki’s Nihonshugi and Japan in the 1930s / 동북아역사논총 / 동북아역사재단 43(41) : 403~445

[journal] 박현숙 / 2009 / Tsuda Shoukichi’s uni-race theory and his perception of Korea-Japan relationship / 동북아역사논총 / 동북아역사재단 (26) : 7~33

[confproc] 이소마에 준이치 / 2013 / 쓰다 소키치(津田左右吉)의 국민주의 역사학과 제국주의 / 공동연구: 일본의 ‘식민주의 역사학’과 제국, 한양대 비교역사연구소 국제학술회의

[book] 최재석 / 1990 / 日本古代史硏究批判 / 일지사

[book] 丸山真男 / 1963 / 丸山真男集９券 / 岩波書店

[book] 蓑田胸喜 / 2004 / 蓑田胸喜全集四券 / 柏書房

[book] 森谷克己 / 1942 / 東洋的生活圏 / 育生社

[journal] 李建華 / 2006 / 津田左右吉の平民論と明治国家体制批判 / 政治経済史学 479

[journal] 李建華 / 2005 / 津田左右吉の国民思想研究における武士の思想 / 人間環境学研究 3

[book] 今井修 / 2006 / 津田左右吉歷史論集 / 岩波書店

[book] 家永三郎 / 1972 / 津田左右吉の思想史的硏究 / 岩波書店

[book] 송석원 / 2011 / 논단의 전후사 / 도서출판 소화

[book] 米谷匡史 / 2010 / 아시아/일본- 사이(間)에서 근대의 폭력을 생각한다 / 그린비

[journal] 禰津正志 / 1935 / ウィッツフォーゲル博士の日本訪問 / 支那學 8

[book] 鹿野政直 / 2008 / 근대 일본의 학문 - 관학과 민간학 / 소화

[book] 津田左右吉 / 1963 / 津田左右吉全集 20卷 / 岩波書店

[book] 津田左右吉 / 1963 / 津田左右吉全集 20卷 / 岩波書店

[book] 津田左右吉 / 1963 / 津田左右吉全集 6卷 / 岩波書店

[book] 津田左右吉 / 1963 / 津田左右吉全集 6卷 / 岩波書店

[book] 津田左右吉 / 1996 / 중국사상과 일본사상 / 소화

[book] 津田左右吉 / 1936 / 岩波講座-東洋思潮 / 岩波書店

[book] 津田左右吉 / 1963 / 津田左右吉全集 28卷 / 岩波書店

[book] Bauer Otto / 2006 / 민족문제와 사회민주주의 / 백산서당

[book] Brownlee John S. / 1999 / Japanese Historians and the National Myths, 1600-1945:The Age of the Gods and Emperor Jinmu / University of British Columbia Press

[book] Gordon Andrew / 2013 / A Modern History of Japan / Oxford University Press, 2013

[book] Szpilman Christopher W. / 2006 / Pan-Asianism in Modern Japanese History: Colonialism, Regionalism and Borders / Routledge

KJC Korea
Journal Central

Statistics

Tools

Sharing

Issue List

Citation status