After Neo-evolutionism and Processual Archaeology: Establishment and Development of the Political Economy Approach in Evolutionary Archaeology

Park, Hae-Woon

Journal of Humanities

2015, (58), pp.109-152
Publisher : Institute for Humanities
Research Area : Other Humanities

Park, Hae-Woon ¹

¹ 성균관대학교

ABSTRACT

North American and Western European archaeology underwent rapid paradigm shift from the mid-1970s. Post-processual archaeologists who refuted the uniformity and scientific rationality of human behaviours bitterly criticised the theoretical bases of processual archaeology based on neo-evolutionism in anthropology, which was the main theoretical framework of Western archaeology from the 1960s. Under this circumstance, a group archaeologists have insisted the multi-linear evolutionary processes of human societies by rejecting the general evolutionary perspective that human culture has unilinearly evolved. Neo-Marxism, which combines the class struggle theory of Marx with the Weberian conflict approach, provided the theoretical base of evolutionary archaeology based on the political economy perspective. In order to overcome the weakness point of traditional Marxism that social structure is only determined by economic substructure, they thought that the historical event occurred by political relations among various groups, which include status, sex, ethnic and age groups as well as classes is the most important factor to decide the direction of human evolution. Studies on the appearance and development of complex societies in Mesoamerica conducted by them well show the political economy perspective in archaeology. Firstly, political conflict between groups is one of the important causes to trigger social evolution. Secondly, social groups act for their interests. Thirdly, the execution of power is not an one-way street. Therefore, the dominant group has to make the ideological apparatus for legitimating their interests. Fourthly, the society is not maintained by only one managing principle. To summarise, archaeologists based on the political economy approach have recognised that the human itself is not a passive being who adapt environment and social system, but a active being who can change social structure dynamically. The key concept of the neo-Marxist archaeology is that human societies have evolved different directions by the political behaviours of the human being.
KEYWORDS

evolutionary archaeology , complex societies , neo-Marxism in archaeology , multi-linear evolutionary process , ideological legitimation
REFERENCES (68)

[book] 박양진 / 1997 / 인물로 본 고고학사 / 한울

[journal] 박해운 / 2013 / A Critical Review on the Social Theories of the 19th Century Influencing Neo- evolutionism / 사림 / 수선사학회 (46) : 265~294

[journal] 이기동 / 1989 / 한국고대국가형성사 연구의 현황과 과제: 신진화론의 원용문제를 중심으로 / 산운사학 1

[book] 이현혜 / 1991 / 현대 한국사학과 사관 / 일조각

[journal] 이희준 / 2011 / On the Power Bases of Chieftains and Their Transformation from the Bronze Age to the Proto-Three Kingdoms Period in Southern Korean Peninsula / 영남고고학 / 영남고고학회 (58) : 35~77

[journal] 전경수 / 1988 / 신진화론과 국가형성론 -인류학이론의 올바른 적용을 위하여- / 한국사론 19

[journal] 최광식 / 1987 / 고대국가형성에 대한 이론적 검토 / 신라문화 3

[book] 최몽룡 / 2000 / 한국 지석묘 연구 이론과 방법: 계급사회의 발생 / 주류성

[book] 최몽룡 / 1997 / 한국고대국가형성론: 고고학상으로 본 국가 / 서울대학교출판부

[confproc] 한국고고학회 / 2006 / 계층사회와 지배자의 출현 / 제30회 한국고고학전국대회

[confproc] 한국고고학회 / 2009 / 갈등과 전쟁의 고고학 / 제33회 한국고고학전국대회

[book] Althusser. L / 1969 / For Marx / Allen Lane

[book] Anderson. P / 1976 / qConsideration on Western Marxism / Verso

[journal] Binford. L. R / 1962 / Archaeology as Anthropology / American Antiquity 28 : 217~225

[journal] Blanton. R. E / 1996 / A Dual Processual Theory for the Evolution of Mesoamerican Civilization / Current Anthropology 37 : 1~14

[book] Brumfiel. E / 1976 / The Early Mesoamerican Village / Academic Press : 234~249

[journal] Brumfiel. E / 1983 / Aztec State Making : Ecology, Structure, and the Origin of the State / American Anthropologists 85 : 261~284

[book] Brumfiel. E / 1987 / Specialization, exchange, and complex societies / Cambridge University Press : vii~

[book] Brumfiel. E / 1994 / Factional Competition and political development in the new world / Cambridge University Press

[journal] Carneiro. C / 1970 / A theory of the origin of the state / Science 169 : 733~738

[journal] Costin. C / Status distinction and legitimation of power as reflected in changing patterns of consumption in late prehispanic Peru / American Antiquity 54 : 691~714

[journal] D’Altroy. T / 1985 / Staple finance, and storage in the Inca political economy / Current Anthropology 26 : 187~206

[journal] DeMarrais. E / 1996 / Ideology, materialization and power strategies / Current Anthropology 37 : 15~31

[book] Earle. T. K / 1991 / Chiefdoms: power, economy and ideology / Cambridge University Press : 1~15

[book] Earle. T. K / 1997 / How Chiefs Come to Power: The Political Economy in Prehistory / Stanford University Press

[journal] Flannery. K / 1972 / The Cultural Evolution of Civilizations / Annual Review of Ecology and Systematics 3 : 399~426

[book] Feinman. G. M / 1995 / Foundation of Social Inequality / Plenum Press : 255~279

[book] Feinman. G. M / 2001 / From Leaders to Rulers / Plenum Publishers : 151~175

[journal] Feinman. G. M / 1984 / Too Many Types : An Overview of Sedentary Prestate Societies in the America / Advances in Archaeological Method and Theory 7 : 39~102

[book] Fried. M / 1967 / The Evolution of Political Society: An Essay in Political Anthropology / Random House

[journal] Friedman. J / 1974 / Marxism, Structuralism and Vulgar Marxism / Man 9 : 444~469

[book] Friedman. J / 1976 / The Evolution of Social System / Duckworth : X~XIV

[journal] Gilman. A / 1976 / Bronze Age dynamics in southeast Spain / Dialectical Anthropology 1 : 307~319

[book] Gilman. A / 1989 / Archaeological Thought in America / Cambridge University Press : 63~73

[book] Godelier. M / 1976 / The Evolution of Social System / Duckworth : 13~28

[book] Haas. J / 2001 / From Leaders to Rulers / Kluwer Academic/Plenum Publishers : 3~18

[book] Hayden. B / 1995 / Foundation of Social Inequality / Plenum Press : 15~86

[book] Johnson. A. W / 2002 / The Evolution of Human Society: From Foraging Group to Agrarian State / Stanford University Press

[journal] Joyce. A / 1996 / Ideology, Power, and Urban Society in Pre-Hispanic Oaxaca / Current Anthropology 37 : 33~47

[journal] Kohl. P. L / 1976 / The Archaeology of Trade / Dialectical Anthropology 1 : 43~50

[journal] Kohl. P. L / 1978 / The balance of trade in southwestern Asia in the mid-third millennium B.C / Current Anthropology 19 : 463~492

[journal] Kohl. P. L / 1981 / Materialist approaches in prehistory / Annual Review of Anthropology 10 : 89~118

[journal] McGuire. R / 1983 / Breaking Down Cultural Complexity: Inequality and Heterogeneity / Advances in Archaeological Method and Theory 6 : 91~142

[book] Kohl. P. L / 1992 / A Marxist Archaeology / Academic Press

[book] Mann. M / 1986 / The Source of Social Power / Cambridge University Press

[book] Patterson. T. C / 2003 / Marx’s Ghost: Conversation with Archaeologists / Berg

[book] Paynter. R / 1991 / The Archaeology of Inequality / Blackwell : 1~27

[book] Parsons. T / 1947 / Max Weber: The Theory of Social and Economic Organization / Oxford University Press : 1~86

[journal] Peace, W. J / 1988 / Vere Gordon Child and American Anthropology / Journal of Anthropological Research 44 : 417~433

[confproc] Renfrew. C / 1974 / Beyond a Subsistence Economy: The Evolution of Social Organization in Prehistoric Europe / Reconstructing Complex Society: An Archaeological Colloquium. Supplement to the Bulletin of the American Schools of Oriental Research 20 : 69~95

[book] Sanders. W. T / 1978 / Social Archaeology:Beyond Sunsistence and Dating / Academic Press : 249~308

[book] Sanderson. S. K / 2001 / The Evolution of Human Sociality: A Darwinian Conflict Perspective / Rowman & Littlefield

[book] Shanks. M / 1987 / Reconstructing Archaeology / Cambridge University Press

[book] Service. E. R / 1962 / Primitive Social Organization: An Evolutionary Perspective / Random House

[book] Service. E. R / 1975 / Origin of the State and Civilization: The Process of Cultural Evolution / Norton

[book] Service. E. R / 1978 / Origin of the State: The Anthropology of Political System / Institute for the Study of Human Issues : 21~34

[book] Smith. M. G / 1976 / The Evolution of Social System / Duckworth : 29~48

[book] Spriggs. M / 1984 / Marxist perspectives in archaeology / Cambridge University Press : 1~9

[book] Steward. J / 1953 / Evolution and Process / University of Chicago Press : 313~326

[book] Trigger. B. G / 2006 / A History of Archaeological Thought / Cambridge University Press

[book] Watson. P. J / 1971 / Explanation in Archaeology: An Explicitly Scientific Approach / Columbia University Press

[book] Weber. M / 1948 / From Max Weber: essays in sociology / Routledge and Kegan Paul

[journal] Webster. D / 1975 / Warfare and evolution of the state / American Antiquity 40 : 464~470

[journal] Webster. G / 1990 / Labor control and emergent stratification in prehistoric Europe / Current Anthropology 31 : 337~366

[book] Willey. G. R / 1958 / Method and Theory in American Archaeology / University of Chicago Press

[book] Willey. G. R / 1974 / A History of American Archaeology / University of Chicago Press

[journal] Wright. H. T / 1977 / Recent Research on the Origin of the State / Annual Review of Anthropology 6 : 379~397

[book] Yoffee. N / 1993 / For Archaeological Theory: Who Sets the Agenda? / Cambridge University Press : 60~78
KCI Citation (1)

KJC Korea
Journal Central

Statistics

Tools