The Theory of Mind Cultivation by Jeong Yak-Yong － The Conflicts over the Methods of Controlling Mind with Manners by the Sorai School －

lee giwon

doi:10.31310/HUM.071.10

This paper has made a comparative analysis of the idea of proprieties of Jeong Yak-Yong and those of Sorai and Shundai from the perspective of the theory of mind cultivation. In terms of the understanding of proprieties, Jeong Yak-Yong, Sorai, and Shundai have similar, but different aspects to each other. Jeong Yak-Yong mentions the issue of heartburn, by emphasizing the importance of mind control based on proprieties. He says that the Song Confucian scholars’ theory of mind cultivation eventually causes the ‘heartburn’, which is supported by Sorai and Shundai. Nevertheless, Jeong Yak-Yong, Sorai, and Shundai show differences with regard to the methods of overcoming the ‘heartburn’. Jeong Yak-Yong shows a strong belief in mind while Sorai and Shundai do not trust mind because Sorai and Shundai deny the universality of mind. In accordance with the matter of acknowledging the universality of mind for the mind control with proprieties, Jeong Yak-Yong, Sorai, and Shundai stand in a position different to each other. In the aspect of the theory of mind cultivation, Jeong Yak-Yong, Sorai, and Shundai show a considerable distance from each other. The expansion of this philosophical distance could be led to the differences in the study of Confucianism in the Joseon dynasty and Japan. In order to more closely examine these differences, a comparative approach to the respective Confucian scholars would be an important task.

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (0)
REFERENCES (26)
열림/닫힘 버튼
* 2021년 이후 발행 논문의 참고문헌은 현재 구축 중입니다.

[book] 丁若鏞 / 1985 / 與猶堂全書 5-6 / 驪江出版社

[book] 丁若鏞 / 1985 / 與猶堂全書 4 / 驪江出版社

[book] 丁若鏞 / 1985 / 與猶堂全書 4 / 驪江出版社

[book] 丁若鏞 / 1985 / 與猶堂全書 4 / 驪江出版社

[book] 丁若鏞 / 1985 / 與猶堂全書 14 / 驪江出版社

[book] 丁若鏞 / 1985 / 與猶堂全書11 / 驪江出版社

[book] 丁若鏞 / 1985 / 與猶堂全書2 / 驪江出版社

[book] 荻生徂徠 / 1973 / 日本思想大系36 / 岩波書店

[book] 荻生徂徠 / 1973 / 日本思想大系36 / 岩波書店

[book] 荻生徂徠 / 1973 / 日本思想大系36 / 岩波書店

[book] 荻生徂徠 / 1977 / 荻生徂徠全集第三巻 / みすず書房

[book] 太宰春台 / 1903 / 日本倫理彙編6 / 育成會

[book] 太宰春台 / 1972 / 日本思想大系37 / 岩波書店

[book] 太宰春台 / 1986 / 近世儒家文集集成六巻 / ペリカン社

[book] 太宰春台 / 1745 / 論語古訓外傳 / 嵩山房版

[book] 금장태 / 2004 / 도와 덕-다산과 오규 소라이의 중용과 대학 해석 / 이끌리오

[book] 윤사순 / 1984 / 한국의 사상 / 열음사

[book] 이기원 / 2013 / 지의 형성과 변용의 사상사 / 경인문화사

[book] 하우봉 / 1989 / 조선후기 실학자의 일본관 연구 / 일지사

[book] 금장태 / 1998 / 조선후기의 유학사상 / 서울대 출판부 : 488~

[journal] 김언종 / 2002 / 다산 「논어고금주」에 수용된 훤원학파 논어설 / 茶山學 (3) : 449~

[journal] 박종천 / 2012 / Characteristics of Tasan's Ritual Studies from the Perspective of Ritual Governance / 한국실학연구 / 한국실학학회 (24) : 195~224

[journal] 하우봉 / 1988 / 다산 정약용의 일본유학연구 / 한국문화 / 서울대출판부 9 : 263~

[journal] 하우봉 / 2002 / 정약용과 오규소라이의 경학사상 비교연구 / 茶山學 (3) : 449~

[book] 尾藤正英 / 1972 / 日本思想大系 37 / 岩波書店 : 594~

[journal] 澤井啓一 / 1988 / 荻生徂徠における天と人情 / 東洋の思想と宗教 / 早稲田大学 (5) : 160~

KJC Korea
Journal Central

Statistics

Tools

Sharing

Issue List

Citation status