A Systematic Review of Moxibustion for Frozen Shoulder

Si-Hoon Han; Gi-Eon Lee; Da-Young Byun; Young-Ik Kim; Min-Kyun Kim; Boo-Ki Min; Han-Bit Lim; Yun-Jae Jeong; Minseok Oh

doi:https://doi.org/10.18325/jkmr.2019.29.3.35

Journal of Korean Medicine Rehabilitation

Abbr : JKMR
2019, 29(3), pp.35-49
DOI :https://doi.org/10.18325/jkmr.2019.29.3.35
Publisher : The Korean Academy Of Oriental Rehabilitation Medicine
Research Area : Korean Medicine

Si-Hoon Han ¹ , Gi-Eon Lee ² , Da-Young Byun ³ , Young-Ik Kim ⁴ , Min-Kyun Kim ⁵ , Boo-Ki Min ⁶ , Han-Bit Lim ⁷ , Yun-Jae Jeong ⁸ , Minseok Oh ⁹

¹ 대전자생한방병원 한방재활의학과
² 대전자생한방병원 한방재활의학과
³ 대전자생한방병원 한방재활의학과
⁴ 대전자생한방병원
⁵ 대전자생한방병원 한방재활의학과
⁶ 대전자생한방병원 한방재활의학과
⁷ 대전자생한방병원 한방재활의학과
⁸ 대전자생한방병원 한방재활의학과
⁹ 대전대학교 한의과대학 한방재활의학과교실

ABSTRACT

Objectives The purpose of this research is to evaluate the effectiveness of moxibustion theraphy for frozen shoulder through systematic review and meta-analysis. Methods The effect of moxibustion for frozen shoulder was constructed as a key question to search randomized controlled trials (RCTs) in 16 databases without type of publication restriction. Results A total of 790 studies were searched and 22 RCTs were finally selected through primary and secondary selection/exclusion process. In most of the evaluation indexes used in each study, moxibustion treatment for shoulder pain was statistically significant compared with other treatments. A meta-analysis of effective rate in 10 studies comparing moxibustion with acupuncture and acupuncture showed a statistically significant effect of moxibustion treatment. And there was a significant effect on the improvement of the shoulder mobility, but the effect size of shoulder pain was no significant effect for shoulder pain reduction. In addition in the result of meta-analysis of 4 studies' effective rate comparing moxibustion with electronic acupuncture, the effect of moxibustion was significantly higher than that of electronic acupuncture in frozen shoulder. Conclusions Moxibustion therapy was effective in symptoms in patients with frozen shoulder. However because of the high risk of bias in the quality of the included studies, the applicability of this study seems to be limited. It is thought that future randomized controlled trials will need to be designed and performed by reviewing ways to minimize bias. (J Korean Med Rehabil 2019;29(3):35-49)
KEYWORDS

Frozen shoulder , Moxibustion , Randomized controlled trial , Systematic review , Meta-analysis
REFERENCES (42)

[book] Han TR / 2011 / Rehabilitation medicine / Koonja Publishing : 814~816

[book] Brent BS / 2012 / Clinical orthopaedic rehabilitation: an evidence-based approach / Hanmi : 114~117

[book] American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons / 2013 / Essentials of musculoskeletal care / Panmun Education : 5~7

[journal] Clarke GR / 1975 / Preliminary studies in measuring range of motion in normal and painful stiff shoulders / Rheumatology 14 (1) : 39~46

[book] Peggy AH / 2010 / Therapeutic exercise for musculoskeletal injuries / Ymsbook : 737~738

[journal] Lee YJ / 1990 / Clinical study on frozen shoulder / Journal of Korean Acupuncture & Moxibustion Society 7 (1) : 57~63

[journal] Byun JY / 1997 / The clinical study on the treatment of frozen shoulder / Korean J Ori Med 3 (1) : 279~287

[journal] 김도호 / 2009 / Effect of Scolopendrid Pharmacupuncture Therapy on Frozen Shoulder Patients / Journal of Acupuncture Research / 대한침구의학회 26 (1) : 1~14

[journal] 홍승원 / 2014 / Case Report Combined Therapy of Acupuncture and Fire Needling is Effective to Treat Frozen Shoulder / 동의생리병리학회지 / 한의병리학회 28 (1) : 122~127

[journal] 육동일 / 2012 / Five Cases of Frozen Shoulder Patients Treated by Acupotomy Combined with Oriental Medical Treatments / Journal of Acupuncture Research / 대한침구의학회 29 (5) : 167~176

[confproc] Ji CC / 2007 / A survey of clinical research on moxibustion for treatment of frozen shoulder in recent ten years / Paper presented at: Proceedings of the 15th National Acupuncture Symposium of the Clinical Branch of the Chinese Acupuncture and Moxibustion Society : 288~290

[journal] 유혜숙 / 2015 / The Effects of Moxibustion on Chronic Back Pain and Activities of Daily Living in Aged / 재활간호학회지 / 한국재활간호학회 18 (1) : 38~45

[book] The Textbook Compilation Committee of The Korean Acupuncture and Moxibustion Society / 2012 / The acupuncture and moxibustion / Jipmoon-Dang : 327~328

[book] National Evidence-based Healthcare Collaborating Agency / 2011 / NECA's guidance for undertaking systematic reviews and meta-analyses for intervention / National Evidence-based Healthcare Collaborating Agency

[book] Hwang SD / 2014 / Easy to understanding meta-analysis / Hakjisa

[journal] Zeng XL / 2005 / Clinical observation on acupuncture at pain point combined with moxibustion at Zusanli(ST 36)for treatment of periarthritis of shoulder / Chinese Acupuncture & Moxibustion 25 (5) : 326~328

[journal] Han F / 2017 / Effective observation on treating frozen shoulder by balance acupuncture on the Jiantong point and the Leihuo moxibustion / Clinical Journal of Chinese Medicine 24 (9) : 117~118

[journal] Wang XH / 2010 / Frozen shoulder due to cold damp treated with acupuncture and moxibustion on tender points / Chinese Acupuncture & Moxibustion 30 (5) : 364~366

[journal] Jiang C / 2018 / Therapeutic effect of"Shoulder Three Points Needles(肩三針)"acupuncture combined with fire grass moxibustion on cold and wet type of frozen shoulder / Journal of Practical Traditional Chinese Medicine 34 (10) : 1240~1241

[journal] Yan XL / 1999 / Clinical observation on 68 cases of periarthritis of shoulder treated by Taiyishen acupunctrue(太乙神针) / Journal of Guangxi Medical University 16 (5) : 699~

[journal] Lu J / 2012 / Abdominal acupuncture combined with scarring moxibustion at Qihai(CV 6)for 15 cases of periarthritis of shoulder / World Journal of Acupuncture-Moxibustion 22 (3) : 43~46

[journal] Wu YC / 2012 / Clinical study on moxibustion-derived E-moxa for shoulder periarthritis / Shanghai Journal of Acupuncture and Moxibustion 31 (10) : 773~775

[journal] Zhao WN / 2015 / Clinical observation on treatment of periarthritis of shoulder by moxibustion shoulder point / Clinical Journal of Chinese Medicine 35 (7) : 30~31

[journal] Li XZ / 2011 / The curing effect of treatment with acupuncture near pain spot combined ginger moxibustion in 60 cases periarthritis of shoulder / Modern Hospital 11 (12) : 46~47

[journal] Xu KS / 2009 / Clinically randomized controlled trials of moxibustion with salt in bamboo circle for treatment of periarthritis of shoulder / Chinese Acupuncture & Moxibustion 29 (1) : 77~80

[journal] Wu B / 2013 / Treatment of 106 cases of night pain in periarthritis of shoulder by ginger moxibustion / Zhejiang Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine 48 (2) : 131~

[journal] Lin YX / 2014 / Therapeutic effect of moxibustion combined with acupuncture exercise therapy on frozen shoulder / Nei Mongol Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine 33 (19) : 59~60

[journal] Xie WJ / 2018 / Clinical study on the treatment of periarthritis of shoulder by heat-sensitive moxibustion combined with acupuncture exercise therapy / Journal of Contemporary Medicine 25 (24) : 125~126

[journal] Chen J / 2016 / Clinical observation on 50 cases of periarthritis of shoulder treated by acupoint application of analgesia and moxibustion / Hunan Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine 32 (7) : 92~94

[journal] Peng CH / 2018 / Therapeutic effect of heat-sensitive moxibustion combined with massage on 30 cases of frozen shoulder / Jiangxi Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine 49 (5) : 58~59

[journal] Jin RK / 2014 / Comparative study on thermal sensitive moxibustion and needle warming moxibustion for the treatment of scapulohumeral peria / Shanghai Journal of Traditional Chinese Medicine 48 (5) : 86~88

[thesis] Ye L / 2016 / Clinical efficacy observation of thermal moxibustion treatment on scapulohumeral periarthritis (cold-damp type) / Shandong University of Traditional Chinese Medicine

[journal] Chen S / 2011 / Clinical observation on treatment of periarthritis of shoulder with acupuncture at ashi point and moxibustion zusanli / Guangming Journal of Chinese Medicine 26 (11) : 2278~2279

[journal] Wang SQ / 2011 / Therapeutic effect of Chinese moxibustion acupoint application on severe periarthritis of shoulder / West China Medical Journal 26 (1) : 87~88

[journal] Zhao JL / 2010 / Therapeutic effect of painless scar moxibustion on frozen shoulder / Journal of New Chinese Medicine 42 (5) : 76~77

[journal] Yu DS / 2004 / Clinical observation on acupuncture and moxibustion treatment of periarthritis of shoulder / Chinese Journal of Rehabilitation Medicine 19 (2) : 129~

[journal] Ning XJ / 2016 / Effects of acupuncture plus moxibustion on frozen shoulder of Hanshi type / Clinical Journal of Chinese Medicine 17 (8) : 34~35

[journal] Park DS / 1981 / A clinical study on the effect of acupuncture treatment in pain of shoulder and arm / J Korean Med 2 (2) : 55~61

[journal] Kim YI / 2006 / Comparison study acupuncture treatment with Acupuncture & moxibustion combined treatment for forzen shoulder patients / Research Institute of Korean Medicine 15 (2) : 1~7

[journal] Hur B / 2007 / Study on clinical effects of indirect moxibustion at Geogol(LI16)on the shoulder pain / Research Institute of Korean Medicine 16 (2) : 211~216

[journal] 최유경 / 2007 / A Case Report of Ge-yan-jiu & Herbal Medicine Complex Treatment on Jue zheng (厥證) caused by Wang yang(亡陽) / 대한한방내과학회지 / 대한한방내과학회 28 (1) : 187~192

[journal] 배고은 / 2018 / Moxibustion for Benign Prostatic Hyperplasia: A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis / 대한한방내과학회지 / 대한한방내과학회 39 (3) : 372~388
KCI Citation (1)

KJC Korea
Journal Central

Statistics

Tools