Commodification of knowledge: A mechanism of knowledge appropriation
2011, 7(3), pp.145-167
Publisher : Institute of Distance Education
Research Area : Education
-
The purpose of this paper is to critically review issues of knowledge appropriation. The current society, the so called knowledge-based society, tries to facilitate the standardization and manualization of knowledge in order to transfer knowledge to people easily and efficiently increase economic value. In this process, the commodification of knowledge is inevitable and it creates the possibility that someone may create a monopoly of knowledge. To critically analyze this process, this paper investigates what kinds of perspectives on knowledge exist, what are the implications of terms, reification, commodities, and the commodification in Marxism to the commodification of knowledge, and what is the commodification of knowledge. To achieve its purpose, this paper scrutinizes and analyzes discussions on the commodification and appropriation of knowledge utilizing Marxist theoretical frameworks. This paper does not argue that no knowledge should be transformed into a kind of commodity. To develop social and economic growth for survival, some levels of knowledge need to be used to improve economic value. What this paper aims to highlight is that there are some kinds of knowledge that cannot and should not be changed into economic values. In addition, to defend our lifeworld from this danger of commodification, we need to critically understand and analyze the mechanism of this process. In this context, Marx's ideas can create a good starting point for understanding and analyzing the commodification of knowledge as a mechanism of knowledge appropriation.
-
[web] Aurini, J / 2003 / Market professionals in the private tutoring industry: Balancing profit ability with the humanistic face of schooling / http://www.oise.utoronto.ca/depts/sese/csew/nall/new/Aurini.pdf
[book] Bailey,L / 1994 / Critical theory and the sociology of knowledge: A comparative study in the theory of ideology / P.Lang
[book] Belenky, M. / 1986 / Women’s ways of knowing / Harper Collins
[book] Bellaver, R. F. / 2002 / Knowledge management strategy and technology / Artech House
[web] Blunden, A / 1999 / Knowledge for sale / http://home.mira.net/andy/works/knowage.htm
[book] Bourdieu, P. / 1977 / Reproduction in education, society and culture / Sage Publications
[book] Brookfield,S / 1987 / Developing critical thinkers: Challenging adults to explore alternative ways of thinking and acting(1st ed.) / Jossey-Bass
[book] Coakes, E / 2003 / Knowledge management: Current issues and challenges / IRM Press
[book] Collins,M / 1991 / Adult education as vocation: A critical role for the adult educator / Routledge
[book] Cromby, J. / 1999 / What’s wrong with social constructionism?, In Social constructionist psychology: A critical analysis of theory and practice / Open University Press
[confproc] Cunningham, P. M / 1993 / Let’s Get Real: A Critical Look at the Practice of Adult Education / Paper presented at the Fifty-first Annual Meeting of the Mountain Plains Adult Education Association
[book] Derrida,J / 1978 / Writing and difference / University of Chicago Press
[book] Drucker, P. F / 1993 / Post-capitalist society / Harper Business
[book] Feldman, R / 2003 / Epistemology / Prentice Hall
[journal] Fleissner, P / 2006 / Commodification, information, value and profit / Poiesis & Praxis: International Journal of Technology Assessment and Ethics of Science 4(1) : 39~53
[book] Foucault, M. / 1980 / Power/knowledge: Selected interviews and other writings, 1972-1977 / Pantheon Books
[book] Gadamer,H.G / 1975 / Truth and method / Seabury Press
[book] Glasersfeld,E / 2005 / Aspects of constructivism: Theory, perspectives, and practice / Teachers College Press
[book] Gramsci,A / 1973 / Letters from prison(1st ed.) / Harper & Row
[book] Habermas,J / 1971 / Knowledge and human interests / Beacon Press
[book] Hekman,S.J / 1986 / Hermeneutics and the sociology of knowledge / Polity Press
[book] Hetherington, S. C / 2003 / Reality? knowledge? philosophy!: An introduction to metaphysics and epistemology / Edinburgh University Press
[journal] Jacob,M / 2003 / Rethinking science and commodifying knowledge / Policy Futures in Education 1(1) : 125~142
[book] Jarvis,P / 2008 / Democracy, lifelong learning and the learning society: Active citizenship in a late modern age / Routledge
[journal] Kessels, J. W / 2004 / Andragogy and social capital theory: The implications for Human Resource Development / Advances in Developing Human Resources 6(2) : 146~157
[book] Kilgore, D / 2011 / Toward a postmodern pedagogy, In Contemporary issues in adult education / Jossey-Bass Publishers
[book] Kouwenhoven,G.W / 2003 / Designing for competence in Mozambique: Towards a competencebased curriculum for the faculty of education of the Eurado Mondlane University / The University of Twente
[book] Lacan, J. / 1968 / The language of the self: The function of language in psychoanalysis / Johns Hopkins Press
[book] Lave, J. / 1991 / Situated learning: Legitimate peripheral participation / Cambridge University Press
[journal] Livingstone, D. W / 2003 / Hidden dimensions of work and learning: The significance of unpaid work and informal learning in global capitalism / Journal of Workplace Learning 15(7) : 359~367
[book] Livingstone, D. W. / 2004 / Hidden knowledge: Organized labor in the information age / Rowman and Little field
[book] Lyotard,J.F / 1984 / The postmodern condition:A report on knowledge(Vol.10) / University of Minnesota Press
[book] Mankin,D / 2009 / Human resource development / Oxford University Press
[book] Mannheim, K / 1948 / Ideology and utopia: An introduction to the sociology of knowledge / Routledge & Kegan Paul
[book] Marx, K. / 1867 / Capital: A new abridgement / Oxford University Press
[book] McDermott, R. / 2006 / Estranged learning, In Critical perspectives on activity / Cambridge
[book] Merriam, S. B. / 2007 / Learning in adulthood: A comprehensive guide(3rd.) / Jossey-Bass Publishers
[journal] Moore, D. R. / 2002 / Competence, competency, and competencies: Performance assessment in organization / Work study 5(6) : 413~319
[book] Morrow, R. A. / 1995 / Social theory and education: A critique of theories of social and cultural reproduction / State University of New York Press
[journal] Nentwich,M / 2001 / De-commodification in academic knowledge distribution / Science Studies: an Interdisciplinary Journal for Science and Technology Studies 14(2) : 21~42
[book] Nonaka, I. / 1995 / The knowledge-creating company: How Japanese companies create the dynamics of innovation / Oxford University Press
[book] OECD / 1996 / The knowledge-based economy / OECD Press
[book] OECD / 2003 / Definition and selection of competencies: Theoretical and conceptual foundation / OECD Press
[book] Polanyi,M / 1958 / Personal knowledge: Towards a post-critical philosophy / Routledge & Kegan Paul
[book] Polanyi,M / 1966 / The tacit dimension(1st ed.) / Doubleday
[confproc] Robert, J / 2000 / The drive to codify: Implications for the knowledge-based economy / 8th International Joseph A. Schumpeter Society Conference
[book] Ryle,G / 1949 / The concept of mind / University of Chicago Press
[book] Sawchuk, P. H / 2003 / Adult learning and technology in working - class life / Cambridge University
[journal] Suarez-Villa,L / 2001 / The rise of technocapitalism / Science Studies: An Interdisciplinary Journal for Science and Technology Studies 14(2) : 4~20
[web] Sumner, J / 2003 / Charting the course from the knowledge economy to the learning society: Adult educators as mapmakers / http://www.oise.utoronto.ca/CASAE/cnf2003/2003_papers/jennifersumnerCAS03a.pdf
[book] Thrift,N / 1994 / Commodification, In The dictionary of human geography(3rd ed.) / Blackwell Publishers Inc
[book] Toffler,A / 1980 / The third wave(1st ed.) / Morrow
[book] Vygotsky,L.S / 1978 / Mind in society: The development of higher psychological processes / Harvard University Press
[book] Welton, M. R / 1995 / In defense of the lifeworld: Critical perspectives on adult learning / State University of New York Press
[book] Wenger, E. C / 1998 / Communities of practice: Learning, meaning and identity / Cambridge University Press
-
KCI Citation (0)
155 Viewed
Print this page
Download PDF