A Study on the Policy Network Analysis of the National Pension Fund Management Governance Process in Korea

이동호; Soon-Tak Suh

doi:10.17000/kspr.14.2.200801.157

This paper examines a few questions on the causes and backgrounds of the reform in the fund management governance of the National Pension, the response and role of each organization in that, and the relationship between the policy goals and policy outputs. To answer this question, I have categorized the policy processes of the fund management governance reform of the National Pension into three categories according to past administrations, and then compared the unique characteristics of each government's policy network as well as its policy outputs through analyzing the interaction among the policy making systems, policy processes and policy actors. In addition, in this paper, I have tried to find a direction for the development of the fund management governance reform by highlighting the role and function of the government and various interested organizations. Based on the result of the above analysis, the policy network, the key part of the fund management governance reform which has brought on discussion whenever political power was transferred, has evolved from a closed and vertical to an open and horizontal structure, while a system based on elitism has been changed into one based on a combination of policy communities and issue networks. In other words, I found that the expansion of policy participation of various non-government organizations led to an increase in the number and scale of policy making participants, and the type of policy making has been institutionalized towards emphasizing democracy and representation. How the government control system should be established at the time of fund management governance reform is the core analysis of this paper. I have concluded that the desirable direction for fund management governance reform is as follows; First of all, government intervention should be minimized; the independence of fund management should be secured; Secondly policy actors in the non-government organizations should promote their specialty and responsibility; Finally the Fund Operation Committee should be maintained as an ad-hoc committee, which allows representatives of insured persons to directly participate in it as at present, rather than as a specialist-centered standing committee.

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (6)
열림/닫힘 버튼
REFERENCES (32)
열림/닫힘 버튼
* 2021년 이후 발행 논문의 참고문헌은 현재 구축 중입니다.

[other] 경실련 / 2003 / 국민연금법중개정법률안에 대한 소견

[other] 경제단체 / 2004 / 국민연금법 개정안에 대한 경영계 의견

[book] 경향신문 / 2003 / 김대중 정부 5년 평가와 노무현 정부 개혁과제 / 한울

[report] 공공자금관리기금법안 / 1993 / 공공자금관리기금법중개정법률안(1998) 및 해당 법률안 검토보고서, 심사보고서

[other] 국민연금관리공단 / 1998 / 국민연금 10년사

[other] / 국민연금기금운용위원회 및 기금실무평가위원회 회의록 각년도(1999년 이후)

[other] 국민연금발전위원회 / 2003 / 2003국민연금재정재계산 및 제도개선방안

[other] / 국민연금법중개정법률안, 국민연금기금운용위원회설치및운영에관한법률안(제15대, 제16대, 제17대 국회),관련 법제정·개정입법청원안 및 해당 법률안의 검토보고서. 심사보고서

[other] 국민연금제도개선특별위원회 기금관리체계개선소위원회 / 2006 / 국민연금제도개선특별위원회 기금관리체계개선소위원회. 2006. 소위심사자료

[thesis] 권영규 / 2007 / 정책네트워크 분석을 통한 도시하천복원사업 정책과정 비교연구 / 박사 / 서울시립대학교

[other] / 기금관리기본법안, 기금관리기본법중개정법률안 및 해당 법률안의 검토보고서. 심사보고서

[book] 김성제 / 2005 / 정책혁신과 정책네트워크 / 학술정보(주)

[journal] 김순양 / 1995 / 의료보험정책과정에서의 참여자의 특성변화에 관한 연구 / 한국행정학보 29(2) : 415~434

[other] 보건복지부 / 2003 / 국민연금제도개선 및 기금운용위원회상설화방안에 관한 공청회

[thesis] 양재대 / 2003 / 정책네트워크 관점에서 본 도시계획 결정과정에서의 지방의회 역할에 관한 연구 / 박사 / 서울시립대학교

[other] / 언론기관 기사 각년도(1992년~2007년). 경향신문, 국민일보, 동아일보, 매일경제, 문화일보, 서울경제, 서울신문, 세계일보, 조선일보, 중앙일보, 한겨레, 한국경제, 한국일보 등

[book] 원종욱 / 2002 / 국민연금 기금운용관리체계의 개선 / 국민연금관리공단

[confproc] 이기영 / 2006 / 국민연금기금운용의 지배구조 / 한국사회보장학회 2006전반기 학술대회 : 69~99

[thesis] 이혜승 / 2004 / 한국의 사회보험정책네트워크의 성격에 관한 연구 / 박사 / 이화여자대학교

[book] 조성훈 / 2004 / 공적연금의 지배구조에 관한 연구 : 국민연금을 중심으로 / 한국증권연구원

[book] 한성윤 / 2005 / 국민연금기금관리체계개선방향 / 국민연금연구원

[book] 한성윤 / 2001 / 국민연금기금의 관리운용체계 개선방안 연구 / 국민연금연구센터

[book] Dohler, Marian / 1991 / Policy Networks, Opportunity Structures and Neo-Conservative Reform Stratiges in Healths Policy, Policy Networks / Westview Press : 235~298

[report] Iglesias A. / 2000 / Managing public pension reserves PartⅠ: Evidence from the international experience, Pension Reform Primer Series / World Bank

[journal] Jordan, Grant / 1992 / A perliminary ordering of policy network labels / European Journal of Political Research 21 : 7~27

[book] Keith P. Ambachtsheer / 1998 / Pension Fund Excellence : Creating Value for Stakeholders / John Wiley & Sons

[book] Kenis, Patrick / 1991 / Policy Networks and Policy Analysis, Policy Networks / Westview P : 25~62

[book] Marin, B. / 1991 / Policy Networks: Empirical Evidence and Theortical Considerations / Westview Press

[book] Rhodes, R. A. W. / 1997 / Understanding Governance: Policy Networks, Governance, Reflexivity and Accountability / Open University Press

[report] Robert Palacios / International Patterns of pension provision

[journal] Waarden, Van Frans / 1992 / Dimensions and types of policy networks / European Journal of Political Research 21 : 29~52

[journal] Yishai, Y. / 1992 / From an iron triangle to an iron duet? Health policy making in Israel / European Journal of Political Research 21 : 91~108

KJC Korea
Journal Central

Statistics

Tools

Sharing

Issue List

Citation status