In search for a distributive user involvement in policy-making process on ageing: a case study of UK Advisory Forum on Ageing

Yunjeong Yang; 정영순

doi:10.17000/kspr.18.2.201106.143

This study began by a research question whether or not a genuine user involvement based on power redistribution is possible, and by what conditions. The recently launched UK Advisory Forum on Ageing and older persons' involvement in the policy process is chosen as a case study as it represents a new initiative by the British government to "empower older people's engagement" by establishing a consultation body at the national level. We understand that user involvement in the participatory democratic approach is feasible only when a meaningful power redistribution is made and that the power redistribution can be achieved by meeting the following three conditions. Firstly, older participants in the process shall need to be respected and trusted as equal partners. Secondly, opportunities to participate in the policy process, as well as practical support for it (such as provision of physical arena and of financial support to attend any meetings), shall be provided. Lastly, supports to develop older persons' human resources and capacity building for active participation are also required. Only when these three conditions are met, the user involvement can be referred as genuine, with power being distributed to so-far marginalised users. The conclusion of this study is that for a genuine and successful user involvement in the policy process, the strong and continuous government support is necessary. The conclusion also includes implications for Korea where the desire for participation in policy-making process on ageing will be stronger around the time of retirement of the baby-boom generation in the foreseen future.

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (6)
열림/닫힘 버튼
REFERENCES (31)
열림/닫힘 버튼
* 2021년 이후 발행 논문의 참고문헌은 현재 구축 중입니다.

[journal] 김미혜 / 2010 / 베이비붐 세대의 노후준비 실태와 노후준비교육의 방향 / 노인인력개발포럼 5 : 29~58

[journal] 김용득 / 2007 / Conceptual Structure of User Involvement and Implications on Korean Disability Services / 한국사회복지학 / 한국사회복지학회 59(2) : 39~64

[journal] 박시내 / 2010 / 베이비붐 세대의 경제활동 및 소득현황 분석 / 노인인력개발포럼 5 : 5~28

[other] 보건복지부 / 2011 / 2011 노인보건복지사업안내

[report] 보건복지가족부 / 2009 / 2008년도 노인실태조사 -전국노인생활실태 및 복지 욕구조사- 기초분석보고서 / 보건복지가족부.

[journal] 양난주 / 2007 / Socio-Political Empowerment and Welfare for the Aged - Conceptualization, Development of Indicators and its Application - / 사회복지연구 / 한국사회복지연구회 (35) : 239~266

[journal] 이혁구 / 2000 / 권력의 장치로서의 사회복지: 푸코의 권력이론에 입각한 ‘권한부여’ 비판 / 한국사회복지학 43 : 328~357

[journal] Arnstein, S. R / 1969 / A ladder of citizen participation / Journal of the American Planning Association 35(4) : 216~224

[report] Audit Commission / 2008 / Don't stop me now: preparing for an ageing population / London: Audit Commission, Local Government National Report

[book] Barnes, M / 2007 / Power, participation and political penewal: case studies in public participation / Policy Press

[journal] Benington,J / 2000 / The modernization and improvement of government and public services / Public Money and Management : 3~8

[journal] Beresford,P / 2002 / User involvement in research and evaluation: Liberation or regulation / Social Policy and Society 1(2) : 95~105

[journal] Beresford,P / 2010 / Public partnerships, governance and user involvement: a service user perspective / International Journal of Consumer Studies 34 : 495~502

[journal] Beresford, P / 1994 / Disabled people, service users, user involvement and representation / Disability and Society 9(3) : 315~325

[journal] Bradshaw,P / 2008 / Service user involvement in the NHS in England: Genuine user participation or a dogma-driven folly / Journal of Nursing Management 16 : 673~681

[journal] Chapin, R / 2001 / Changing the paradigm: strengths-based and empowerment-oriented social work with frail elders / Journal of Gerontological Social Work 36(3) : 165~179

[journal] Cowden, S / 2007 / The ‘user’: friend, foe or fetish? A critical exploration of user involvement in health and social care / Critical Social Policy 27(1) : 5~23

[journal] Crawford, M. / 2002 / Systematic review of involving patients in the planning and development of health care / British Medical Journal 325(7375) : 1263~1265

[journal] Croft, S / 1992 / The politics of participation / Critical Social Policy 12(20) : 20~44

[book] DH / 2000 / The NHS plan: a plan for investment, a plan for reform / Department ofHealth

[book] DH / 2004 / Patient and public involvement in health: the evidence for policy implementation / Department of Health

[book] DWP / 2005 / Meeting the challenge of ageing in the 21st century / Department forWork and Pensions

[book] DWP / 2009 / Empowering engagement: a stronger voice for older people (The government response to John Elbourne's review ) / Department for Work and Pensions

[book] Elbourne, J / 2008 / Review of older people's engagement with government / Department for Work and Pensions

[journal] Glasby, J / 2006 / Who knows best? Evidence based practice and the service user contribution / Critical Social Policy 26 : 268~284

[journal] Harrison, S / 1998 / Which champions, which people? Public and user involvement in health care as a technology of legitimation / Social Policy and Administration 32(1) : 60~70

[journal] Hayden, C / 2000 / Multi-level networked governance - reflections from the better government for older people programme / Public Money and Management : 27~34

[journal] Martin, S / 2000 / Public participation and citizen-centred local government: lessons from the best value and better government for older people pilot programmes / Public Money and Management : 47~53

[web] / UK Advisory Forum on Ageing / http://www.dwp.gov.uk/policy/ageing-society/advisory-forums-on-ageing/uk-advisory-forum/

[web] / Vision/Mission Statement / http://www.dwp.gov.uk/docs/uk-advisory-forum-vision-mission.pdf

[web] / Terms of Reference / http://www.dwp.gov.uk/docs/uk-advisory-forum-terms-of-reference.pdf

KJC Korea
Journal Central

Statistics

Tools

Sharing

Issue List

Citation status