In serarch for patient and public involvement in health care policy-making process: case studies of England NHS under new labor government (1998-2009)

LeeWeonYoung

doi:10.17000/kspr.19.4.201212.175

This study explored the experiences of the public and patient involvement(PPI) in the NHS under the Labor government(1998-2009). From the outset, the Labor government had applied actively the PPI policy to all NHS organizations. Though there was a little backdrop due to the reinforcement of the marketization of the NHS after the midpoint of the lifetime of the labor government, these policy has maintained continuously without a break. Three PPI programs were analyzed on the points that their process met four criteria for effective participation process and influenced the outcome of a decision-making. Local Involve Networks was built up to reflect patient and public views on a decision making process of Primary Care Trust and Local Authority. It had access to information, official route for delivering public view to decision maker, educational and technical support for participants despite of there being a lack of representation. Citizen and patient governors, who are members of the board of governors for NHS foundation trust, had somewhat representation due to being elected by members, while they had little influence on the board of directors as well as insufficiency of the other three criteria for effective participation process. Two lay people among patients or carers concerned with target disease of clinical guidelines were involved in the guildeline development and also patient organization related to the disease could work as a stakeholder in the condition that the patient organziation had members nationally. These program met sufficiently four criteria for the effective participation process and also showed a visible impact on clinical guideline even though it was concentrated on non medical part such as family education. These experiences in the NHS may be very available for making judgement over introuducing PPI policy, designing a effective participation process, and predicting what that policy will bring to us.

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (7)
열림/닫힘 버튼
REFERENCES (43)
열림/닫힘 버튼
* 2021년 이후 발행 논문의 참고문헌은 현재 구축 중입니다.

[confproc] 김상묵 / 2004 / 중앙정부 정책과정과 민간참여유형 / 한국행정학회 2004년도 추계학술대회발표논집

[confproc] 김창보 / 2010 / 건강보험정책심의위원회 구조의 문제와 주요쟁점 / 국회의원 백원우, 박은수 주최 건강보험 정책결정 구조에 대한 국회 토론집

[journal] 박천오 / 2002 / 정부관료제의 시민참여 수용성 : 한국 공무원의 인식을 중심으로 / 행정논총 / 한국행정연구소 40(2) : 1~28

[book] Abelson, J. / 2006 / Assessing the impacts of public participation: concepts, evidence and policy implications / Canadian Policy Research Networks Inc

[journal] Abelson, J. / 2004 / Will it make a difference if I show up and share? A citizens’ perspective on improving public involvement processes for health system decision-making / Journal of Health Service Research Policy 9(4) : 205~212

[journal] Arstein, S.R. / 1969 / A ladder of citizen participation in the USA / American Institute of Planners Journal 35 : 216~224

[book] Conklin, A. / 2010 / Involving the public in healthcare policy / Europe RAND

[book] Daniels, N. / 2009 / Accountability for reasonableness and the citizens council, In Patients’, the public and priorities in healthcare / Radcliffe

[book] Department of Health / 1999 / Patient and public involvement in the new NHS / Department of Health

[book] Department of Health / 2000 / The NHS plan: a plan for investment, a plan for reform / Department of Health

[book] Department of Health / 2004 / The NHS improvement plan: putting people at the heart of the public services / Department of Health

[book] Department of Health / 2007 / Getting ready for LINKs - Planning your local involvement network / Department of Health

[report] Department of Health / 2010 / Local involvement networks-analysis of 2009-10 annual reports / Department of Health

[book] Dixon, A. / 2011 / Understanding the new labor’s market reforms of the English NHS / Kings Fund

[journal] Dixon, A. / 2010 / Accountability of foundation trusts in the English NHS: views of directors and governors / Journal of Health Service Research Policy 15(2) : 82~89

[journal] Ford, J.C. / 1990 / General practice fundholders / British Medical Journal 300 : 1027~1028

[journal] Foster, R. / 2008 / Voice or choice? patient and public involvement in the National Health Service in England under new Labor / International Journal of Health Services 38(2) : 333~356

[web] / Foundation Trust Governors’ Association / http://www.ftga.org.uk/about-the-ftga/

[journal] Frankish, C.J. / 2002 / Challenges of citizen participation in regional health authorites / Social Science & Medicine 54 : 1471~1480

[book] Ham, C. / 2008 / Membership governance in NHS foundation trusts: a review for the Department of Health / University of Birmingham & Mutuo

[book] Health Canada / 2000 / Public involvement: framework and guidelines / Minister of Public Works and Government Services

[book] Hogg, C. / 2002 / National Health Service frameworks: involving patients and the public / Patient Forum

[journal] Hughes, D. / 2009 / Choice vs. voice? PPI policies and the re-positioning of the state in England and Wales / HEALTH EXPECTATIONS 12 : 237~250

[book] Kelson, M. / 2009 / NICE's commitment to patient, carer and public involvement, In Patients’, the public and priorities in healthcare / Radcliffe

[journal] Kitzhaber, J.A. / 1993 / Prioritising health services in an era of limits: the Oregon experience / British Medical Journal 307 : 373~377

[journal] Lewis, R. / 2008 / Citizen and staff involvement in health service decision-making: have National Health Service foundation trusts in England given stakeholders a louder vice? / Journal of Health Service Research and Policy 13(1) : 19~25

[book] Lupton, C. / 1997 / Managing public involvement in health care purchasing / Open University Press

[journal] Marks, L. / 2011 / Governance for health and wellbeing in the English NHS / Journal of Health Service Research and Policy 16(1) : 14~21

[book] Monitor / 2009 / Your statutory duties: a reference guide for NHS foundation trust governors / Monitor

[book] Monitor / 2011 / Current practice in NHS foundation trust member recruitment and engagement / Monitor

[book] Monitor / 2011 / Survey of NHS foundation trust governors / Monitor

[web] / National Resource Centre for Consumer Participation in Health / http://www.participateinhealth.org.gu/

[book] NHS Executive / 1994 / Developing NHS purchasing and GP fundholding towards a primary care-led NHS / NHS Executive

[book] OECD / 2001 / Citizens as partners: Information, consultation and public participation in policy-making / OECD

[report] Patient Involvement Unit / 2004 / A report on a study to evaluate patient and carer membership of the first NICE guideline development groups / National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence

[journal] Patient View / 2004 / The end of the world’s most ambitious user-led experiment in healthcare restructuring? / Health and Social Campainer's Network News International 9 : 6~20

[book] Pollock, A.M. / 2004 / NHS plc: the privatisation of our health care / Verso

[journal] Rowe, G. / 2005 / A typology of public engagement mechanisms / Science, Technology, & Human Values 30(2) : 251~290

[book] Thomas, V. / 2009 / Patient and care involvement in NICE clinical guidelines, In Patients’, the public and priorities in healthcare / Radcliffe

[book] Thomas, V. / 2009 / Patient and voluntary organization support for implementing NICE guidance, In Patients’, the public and priorities in healthcare / Radcliffe

[journal] Tritter, J.Q. / 2009 / Revolution or evolution: the challenges of conceptualizing patient and public involvement in a consumerist world / Health Expectations 12 : 275~287

[journal] Van de Bovenkamp, H.M. / 2010 / Patient participation in collective health care decision making: the Dutch model / Health Expectations 13(1) : 73~85

[journal] Wait, S. / 2006 / Public involvement policies in health: exploring their conceptual basis / Health Economics, Policy and Law 1 : 149~162

KJC Korea
Journal Central

Statistics

Tools

Sharing

Issue List

Citation status