Relationship among ‘Secular Giving’, ‘Religious Giving’ and Traditional ‘Mutual-aid Giving’ in Korean Households

Chul Hee Kang; 편창훈; 오장용

doi:10.17000/kspr.22.2.201506.195

This study attempts to examine the relationships between religious giving & mutual- aid giving and secular giving in Korean households. Data used for this study is the ‘National Survey of Tax and Benefit’ (NSTB) which has been collected at the form of panel data by Korea Institute of Public Finance (KIPF). Controlling for effects of household factors and financial indicators of households, it showed that religious giving has a substitutive relationship with secular giving in terms of amount of giving and philanthropic effort. Mutual-aid giving has a complementary relationship with secular giving in terms of amount of giving, not philanthropic effort. Among control variables, the following variables are statistically significant; education level of householders, house ownership, household income, and amount of other expenditures. This study contributes to building new knowledge about the relationships among various forms of giving at household level. Particularly, this study makes us understand that the relationships on secular giving can be different in a society with different culture: complementary with mutual aid giving and substitutive with religious giving in Korea. Indeed, it broadens and deepens our understanding of the relationships among each form of giving. Moreover, this study makes us realize that such analysis can provide significant contextual knowledge for governmental policy interventions on secular giving.

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (15)
열림/닫힘 버튼
REFERENCES (38)
열림/닫힘 버튼
* 2021년 이후 발행 논문의 참고문헌은 현재 구축 중입니다.

[journal] 강철희 / 2001 / 사회복지 부문 민간복지재원 규모 파악에 관한 연구 / 한국사회복지행정학 (4) : 1~29

[journal] 강철희 / 2003 / 자선적 기부행동 및 자원봉사 참여행동에 대한 탐색적 분석 / 한국비영리연구 2(2) : 161~205

[journal] 강철희 / 2012 / An Empirical Exploration on Secular Giving: Analysis on Relationships with Religious Giving and Mutual Aid Giving / 사회복지정책 / 한국사회복지정책학회 39(1) : 163~197

[journal] 강철희 / 2013 / A Study of the Relationship between Religion and Giving Behavior -Analyzing Moderating Effect of Religiosity- / 한국사회복지학 / 한국사회복지학회 65(4) : 341~365

[journal] 강철희 / 2014 / A Study of the Relationship between Giving and Financial Indicators of Household: Comparative Study according to Giving Area(Religious, Secular and Total Giving) / 사회복지정책 / 한국사회복지정책학회 41(3) : 1~25

[journal] 김주원 / 2008 / An Empirical Study on the Determinants of Donator’s Giving Behavior to the Charitable Organization / 경영학연구 / 한국경영학회 37(3) : 629~658

[journal] 김혜연 / 2001 / 경조비에 대한 의식 및 지출변화 – IMF 경제위기 이후 제주지역을 중심으로 / 대한가정학회지 39(1) : 65~80

[confproc] 아름다운재단 / 2012 / Giving Korea 2012 / 제12회 국제기부문화심포지엄 / 아름다운재단 기부문화연구소

[journal] 이수애 / 2009 / A study on the Factors Influencing Individual's Giving Behavior : Focusing on the Mediating Effects of Organizational Trust and Commitment / 한국사회복지행정학 / 한국사회복지행정학회 11(3) : 69~95

[confproc] 조주희 / 2014 / 민간나눔자원 총량 추계 연구 / 한국사회복지행정학회 학술대회 자료집 : 83~121

[journal] 조선주 / 2007 / An Economic Analysis on Private Giving and Government Grants : Based on Empirical Studies of Social Welfare Centers in Seoul / 공공경제 / 한국재정학회 12(2) : 65~88

[journal] 한상복 / 1980 / 한국인의 공동체 의식에 관한 연구 / 한국의사회와문화 / 한국정신문화연구원 3

[journal] Andreoni, J. / 1990 / Impure altruism and donations to public goods : a theory of warm-glow giving / The economic journal 100(401) : 464~477

[journal] Bekkers, R. / 2006 / To give or not to give, that is the question : How methodology is destiny in Dutch giving data / Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 35(3) : 533~540

[report] Brown, E. / 2004 / Social capital and philanthropy / International Society for Third Sector Research

[journal] Brown, E. / 2007 / Social capital and philanthropy : Ananalysis of the impact of social capital on individual giving and volunteering / Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 36(1) : 85~99

[journal] Cnaan, R. A. / 2014 / Informal social networks in Korea : Covering the cost of major life events / The Social Science Journal 51(4) : 627~637

[journal] Duncan, B. / 1999 / Modeling charitable contributions of time and money / Journal of Public Economics 72(2) : 213~242

[journal] Eckel, C. C. / 2004 / Giving to secular causes by the religious and non religious : An experimental test of the responsiveness of giving to subsidies / Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 33(2) : 271~289

[journal] Garner, T. I. / 1991 / Economic dimensions of household gift giving / Journal of Consumer Research : 368~379

[journal] Handy, F. / 2008 / Donating behavior : if time is money, which to give? A preliminary analysis / Journal of Economic Studies 35(4) : 323~332

[journal] Hill, J. P. / 2011 / Substitution or symbiosis? Assessing the relationship between religious and secular giving / Social Forces 90(1) : 157~180

[other] Hodgkinson, V. A. / 1990 / The future of individual giving and volunteering: The inseparable link between religious community and individual generosity / Faith and philanthropy in America: Exploring the role of religion in America’s voluntary sector : 284~312

[journal] James III, Russell N. / 2007 / The ‘Sect Effect’ in Charitable Giving : Distinctive Realities of Exclusively Religious Charitable Givers / American Journal of Economics and Sociology 66(4) : 697~726

[journal] Jones, A. / 1994 / Determinants of the level and methods of charitable giving in the 1990 Family Expenditure Survey / Applied Economics Letters 1(11) : 200~203

[journal] Jones, A. / 1991 / Charitable donations by UK households : evidence from the Family Expenditure Survey / Applied Economics 23(2) : 343~351

[journal] Putnam, R. / 2001 / Social capital : Measurement and consequences / Canadian Journal of Policy Research 2(1) : 41~51

[journal] Regnerus, Mark D. / 2005 / Selection Effects in Studies of Religious Influence / Review of Religious Research 47(1) : 23~50

[book] Robbins, K. / 2004 / History of Philanthropy. Philanthropy in America: A Comprehensive Historical Encyclopedia Volume 1 / ABC-Clio, Inc

[journal] Rooney, P. M. / 2001 / A methodological comparison of giving surveys : Indiana as a test case / Nonprofit and Voluntary Sector Quarterly 30(3) : 551~568

[journal] Schervish, P. G. / 1993 / The dependent variable of the independent sector : the definition and measurement of giving and volunteering / Voluntas : International Journal of Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations 4(2) : 223~232

[journal] Skarmeas, D. / 2011 / Relationship quality and giving behaviour in the UK fundraising sector : Exploring the antecedent roles of religiosity and self-construal / European Journal of Marketing 45(5) : 720~738

[journal] VanSlyke, D. M. / 2005 / Why do people give? New evidence and strategies form on profit managers / The American Review of Public Administration 35(3) : 199~222

[journal] Wang, L. / 2008 / Social capital, volunteering, and charitable giving / Voluntas : International Journal of Voluntary and Nonprofit Organizations 19(1) : 23~42

[confproc] Wiepking, P. / 2004 / Do the poor donate more? The effect of income on philanthropic donations / In 33rd Annual Conference of the Association for Research on Nonprofit Associations and Voluntary Action

[journal] Wilhelm, M. O. / 2008 / The intergeneration altransm is sion of generosity / Journal of Public Economics 92(10) : 2146~2156

[book] Wuthnow, R. / 1990 / Faith and philanthropy in America : Exploring the role of religion in America's voluntary sector / Jossey-Bass

[journal] Yen, S. T. / 2002 / A neconometric analysis of household donations in the USA / Applied Economics Letters 9(13) : 837~841

이 논문은 한국연구재단의 지원을 받아 작성되었습니다.

KJC Korea
Journal Central

Statistics

Tools

Sharing

Issue List

Citation status