An Error Analysis in Word Choices in Korean-English Translation

Byun Gil-Ja

doi:10.15749/jts.2011.12.4.010

The Journal of Translation Studies

Abbr : JTS
2011, 12(4), pp.263-289
DOI : 10.15749/jts.2011.12.4.010
Publisher : The Korean Association for Translation Studies
Research Area : Interpretation and Translation Studies

Byun Gil-Ja ¹

¹Macquarie University

ABSTRACT

It is worthless to mention that selecting correct words in translation is very important because misusing words gives readers wrong information. However, using correct English words is difficult for Korean students because English and Korean belong to different language groups and they are very different in terms of word forms and usage. What is more, they learn English in EFL situation where there is very little authentic language input. Given such facts, it is not surprising for Korean students to make word choice errors when translating Korean source text into English. Accordingly, to reduce word choice errors, it is meaningful to analyse what factors cause word choice errors and in which situations word choice errors happen. For this purpose, this paper analyses lexical errors on the basis of 9 categories (too general, too specific, terminology, register, addition, omission, part of speech, spelling and collocation) from 19 assignments in two different genres translated by Korean students in the first semester of the master degree course of interpreting and translation. As a result of that, it is found that Korean students make lexical errors because of first language transfer and insufficient vocabulary usage knowledge in the target language. To solve the problems, Korean students should focus on studying vocabulary quality such as usage and the different semantic features between the two languages as well as vocabulary quantity. This paper concludes that education which focuses on instruction in vocabulary usage in different contexts, which offers opportunities to practice the usage, and which provides sufficient authentic input should be given in order to translate source texts into target texts with native-like expression.
KEYWORDS

word choice errors, first language transfer, insufficient vocabulary usage knowledge, sufficient authentic input
REFERENCES (23)

[journal] Bialystok, Ellen / 1985 / Interlanguage is not a State of Mind: An Evaluation of the Construct for Second Language Acquisition / Applied Linguistics 6 : 101~117

[journal] Burt,Marina / 1975 / Error Analysis in the Adult EFL Classroom / TESOL Quarterly 9 : 53~63

[journal] Cha,Mi-yang / 2005 / English Vocabulary Learning and Use at the Tertiary Level / The Journal of Namseoul University 11(2) : 99~124

[journal] Corder,S.P / 1967 / The Significance of Learners’ Errors / IRAL 5 : 161~170

[journal] Daller, Helmut / 2003 / Lexical Richness in the Spontaneous Speech of Bilinguals / Applied Linguistics 24(2) : 197~222

[book] Fries,Charles Carpenter / 1945 / Teaching and Learning English as a Foreign Language / Michigan U. P

[book] Gile,Daniel / 1989 / Basic Concepts and Models for Interpreter and Translator Training / John Benjamins

[journal] Jiang,Nan / 2000 / Lexical Representation and Development in a Second Language / Applied Linguistics 21(1) : 47~77

[book] Jiang,Nan / 2002 / Form-Meaning Mapping in Vocabulary Acquisition in a Second Language / Cambridge U. P : 617~637

[journal] Jiang,Nan / 2004 / Semantic Transfer and Its Implications for Vocabulary Teaching in a Second Language / The Modern Language Journal 88(3) : 416~432

[book] Lado,Robert / 1957 / Linguistics across Cultures / Michigan U. P

[book] Laufer,Batia / 1997 / The Lexical Plight in Second Language Reading: Words You Don’t Know, Words You Think You Know, and Words You Can’t Guess In Second Language Vocabulary Acquisition / Cambridge U. P : 20~34

[journal] Mondahl, Margrethe / 1996 / Lexical Search Strategies in Translation / Meta 41(1) : 97~113

[book] Nation,Paul / 1993 / Vocabulary Size, Growth, and Use In The Bilingual Lexicon / John Benjamins Publishing Company : 115~134

[book] Nation,I.S.P / 2001 / Learning Vocabulary in Another Language / Cambridge U. P

[book] Read,John / 2000 / Assessing Vocabulary / Cambridge U. P

[journal] Robinson,Peter / 1989 / A Rich View of Lexical Competence / ELT Journal 43 : 274~282

[journal] Ronowicz, Eddie / 2003 / A Comparison of Task Management and Lexical Search Mechanisms in Novice and Professional Translators/Interpreters / Interpretation Studies 3 : 16~34

[journal] Eddie Ronowicz / 2007 / LEXICAL COMPETENCE OF STUDENT AND PROFESSIONAL TRANSLATORS / 통번역학연구 / 통번역연구소 11(1) : 169~192

[book] Schreuder, Robert / 1993 / The Bilingual Lexicon: An Overview In The Bilingual Lexicon / John Benjamins Publishing Company : 1~10

[thesis] Yoon,Hye-sook / 2003 / An Analysis of Vocabulary Errors and a Pedagogy for Vietnamese Learners of Korean / 석사 / Yeonsei University

[journal] Zareva,Alla Petrova / 2005 / Models of Lexical Knowledge Assessment of Second Language Learners of English at Higher Levels of Language Proficiency / System 33 : 547~562

[journal] Zareva, Alla / 2005 / Relationship between Lexical Competence and Language Proficiency / SSLA 27 : 567~595
KCI Citation (3)

KJC Korea
Journal Central

Statistics

Tools