A study on Criticism about Su Shi's historical essays

JUNG, Ha-jung

This paper aims to explore historical essays which performed as a place for debate by arguing previous discussions. Therefore, this paper will examine the reasons why Su shi's historical essays were criticized by Joseon writers and how the literary works that criticized Su shi's historical essays refute Su shi's perspectives. First, we looked through the perception of Joseon writers on Su shi's essays. As a result, Su shi's essays were implacably considered as a model and we were able to identify several criticisms which praise Su shi's novelty opinions and clear development of logics. However, there were also negative opinions on Su Shi's essays which refute the aspect of the underlying philosophy in Su Shi's works. These parts are correlated with historical essays. The reasons why Su Shi's historical essays, regarded as a model, were criticized by Joseon writers can be inferred in terms of Su shi’s ideological problem revealed in his works. Su shi created some works which refute the conventional confucian views, and these creation is derived from his ideological openness. However, these works could not avoid Joseon writers' criticism infatuated with Confucian ideas. In addition, regarding the historical essays' tendency of creation that establish its logic by criticizing previous discussions, it is expected that Su shi's work were regarded as a target which needs to be overcome to the later writers. This leads Joseon writers to devise specific narration strategies in order to attain cogency.

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (3)
열림/닫힘 버튼
REFERENCES (18)
열림/닫힘 버튼
* 2021년 이후 발행 논문의 참고문헌은 현재 구축 중입니다.

[book] 金富弼 / 後彫堂集 / 한국고전번역원

[book] 權諰 / 炭翁集 / 한국고전번역원

[book] 申昉 / 屯菴集 / 한국고전번역원

[book] 李瀷 / 星湖先生全集 / 한국고전번역원

[book] 李恒老 / 華西集 / 한국고전번역원

[book] 李獻慶 / 艮翁集 / 한국고전번역원

[book] 林象德 / 老村集 / 한국고전번역원

[book] 趙龜命 / 東溪集 / 한국고전번역원

[book] 崔昌大 / 昆侖集 / 한국고전번역원

[web] / 한국고전종합DB / http://db.itkc.or.kr/

[journal] 백진우 / 2008 / A study on Lee Chun-bo’s historical essays / 민족문화 / 한국고전번역원 31(31) : 213~241

[thesis] 백진우 / 2011 / 조선후기 사론 산문 연구 / 박사 / 고려대학교 대학원

[book] 성백효 / 2010 / 譯註唐宋八大家文鈔 소식3 / 전통문화연구회 : 66~71

[journal] 송혁기 / 2006 / 17-18세기 조선 문인의 蘇軾 산문 批評 / 한자한문연구 2 : 73~97

[book] 김만중 / 2010 / 서포만필 상 / 문학동네 : 1~663

[book] 김만중 / 2010 / 서포만필 하 / 문학동네 : 1~705

[journal] 윤세순 / 2013 / THE RESEARCH ABOUT THE NOBLEMEN'S ATTITUDES ABOUT HISTORICAL CHARACTER WU ZIXU(伍子胥) IN CHOSUN DYNASTY / 민족문학사연구 / 민족문학사학회 (51) : 200~229

[journal] 조규백 / 2012 / Remarks about Su Dongpo's Personality and Prose by Literary Men of Choseon Dynasty / 대동문화연구 / 대동문화연구원 (80) : 235~256

KJC Korea
Journal Central

Statistics

Tools

Sharing

Issue List

Citation status