A Study on the Development Process of Community Involvement and Policy Implications in the U.K.: Focusing on the Nabatchi’s Modified Spectrum of Participation

Lee, Ja-Eun; Soon-Tak Suh

doi:10.15793/kspr.2018.98..006

Community involvement in urban regeneration is shown in various forms of interaction. It is certain that community involvement in dealing with local issues is an important keyword. The purpose of this study is to consider how the issue of community involvement is being dealt with in UK’s urban regeneration. Especially it considered the power of government and social context in response to the urban regeneration policy and interpreted the level of decision-making authority through participation spectrum. As a result of the analysis, the first step for the success of community involvement is to construct trust by securing sufficient time and room for 1-2 years. Secondly, to create more contact between local residents by promoting local representatives or active citizens. It could establish a weak but direct network of ties. Finally, the neighborhood planning that the community is the main actor for the decision could be adopted step by step. Although the UK’s initiatives to encourage community involvement could not bring all local revitalization, it is worthy of notice that UK policy is becoming more mature than ever.

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (10)
열림/닫힘 버튼
REFERENCES (66)
열림/닫힘 버튼
* 2021년 이후 발행 논문의 참고문헌은 현재 구축 중입니다.

[journal] 권순만 / 2012 / Public Participation in Healthcare Decision Making: Experience of Citizen Council for Health Insurance / 보건행정학회지 / 한국보건행정학회 22(4) : 467~496

[report] 문정호 / 2006 / 참여시대 공공계획의 패러다임에 관한 연구 / 국토연구원

[journal] 박인석 / 2009 / Actors and Collaboration System in English Urban Regeneration Program - Cases of Single Program and Neighbourhood Renewal Program - / 대한건축학회논문집 계획계 / 대한건축학회 25(12) : 349~360

[journal] 서순탁 / 2008 / A Study on the Reform of Planning System in line with Governance Changes in Korea / 도시행정학보 / 한국도시행정학회 21(1) : 85~105

[confproc] 양재섭 / 2007 / 도시재생정책의 국제비교 연구 / 한국주거환경학회 학술대회 발표논문집 (1) : 21~32

[report] 양재섭 / 2011 / 서울의 도시계획 수립과정에서 시민참여 실태와 개선방향 / 서울연구원

[journal] 윤일성 / 2010 / Lessons from the Change of Urban Regeneration Policy in Britain / 지역사회학(Korean Regional Sociology) / 지역사회학회 11(2) : 131~164

[journal] 이태희 / 2017 / A Review on the Changes in the UK’s Neighbourhood Regeneration Policy and Its Background : From the Thatcher Administration to New Labour Administration / 국토연구 / 국토연구원 95 : 21~40 / 10.15793/kspr.2017.95..002

[journal] 임기택 / 2010 / An Analysis of the Clusterization Process in UK Urban Regeneration Partnership / 대한건축학회논문집 계획계 / 대한건축학회 26(05) : 277~284

[journal] 정성훈 / 2014 / Characteristics of the Neighbourhood Plan and Community Partnership in the United Kingdom / 한국경제지리학회지 / 한국경제지리학회 17(4) : 864~875 / 10.23841/egsk.2014.17.4.864

[journal] 천현숙 / 2008 / A Study on Partnerships for Urban Regeneration in Sheffield, UK / 국토연구 / 국토연구원 57 : 19~48 / 10.15793/kspr.2008.57..002

[journal] 최현선 / 2012 / Community Development for Urban Regeneration: Comparative Analysis of the United States, the United Kingdom, and Japan / 현대사회와 행정 / 한국국정관리학회 22(3) : 255~275

[book] Allmendinger, P. / 2002 / Urban Planning and the British New Right / Routledge

[journal] Arnstein, S. R. / 1969 / A ladder of citizen participation / Journal of the American Institute of Planners 35(4) : 216~224

[journal] Ball-Petsimeris, S. / 2004 / Urban policy under new labour: A new dawn? / Dela 21 : 171~181

[report] Balsall Heath Neighbourhood Planning Forum / 2014 / Balsall Heath Neighborhood Development Plan 2014-2031 / BHNPF

[web] / Birmingham City Council / https://www.birmingham.gov.uk/info/20054/planning_strategies_and_policies

[book] Blair, T. / 1996 / New Britain: My vision of a young country / Fourth Estate

[book] Blair, T. / 1998 / The Third Way: New politics for the new century / The Fabian Society

[journal] Blakeley, G. / 2009 / Who participates, how and why in urban regeneration projects? The case of the new ‘city’ of East Manchester / Social Policy and Administration 43(1) : 15~32

[journal] Bracht, N. / 1990 / Principles and strategies of effective community participation / Health Promotion International 5(3) : 199~208

[book] Brownill, Sue / 1990 / Developing London’s Docklands: Another great planning disaster? / Paul Chapman Publishing

[journal] Brownill, S. / 1998 / Ethnic minorities and British urban policy: A discussion of trends in governance and democratic theory / Local Governance 24(1) : 43~55

[confproc] Boateng, I. / 2008 / Sustainable participatory approaches in urban regeneration processes: Lessons from Portsmouth harbour and inner-city Hulme / Proceedings of The International Federation of Surveyors Working Week 2008- Integrating Generations / Stockholm Technical Office

[book] Butler, S. / 1991 / Enterprise Zones: New directions in economic development / Sage

[report] Carley, B. / 2012 / Better governance, bigger society? Lessons from the New Deal for Communities regeneration initiative:a comparative case study of community social networks and social capital in east Manchester / University of Manchester

[journal] Carpenter, J. / 2014 / Regeneration and the legacy of thatcherism / Metropolitics

[report] Chafe, R. / 2007 / A Framework for Involving the Public in Health Care Coverage and Resource Allocation Decisions / Canadian Institutes of Health Research

[journal] Cornwall, A. / 2006 / Historical perspectives on participation in development / Journal of Comparative and Commonwealth Politics 44(1) : 62~83

[journal] Davoudi, S. / 1995 / City Challenge: A sustainable process or temporary gesture? / Environment and Planning C:Politics and Space 13(1) : 79~95

[report] Department for Business, Innovation and Skills / 2010 / Local Growth: Realising every place’s potential / The Stationery Office

[other] Department for Communities & Local Government / 2013 / Neighbourhood Community Budget Pilot Programme / DCLG

[other] Department of the Environment / 1991 / City Challenge:Government Guidance / DoE

[other] Department of the Environment, Transport and the Regions / 2001 / Local Strategic Partnerships / DETR

[book] Dickson, G. / 2002 / Urban Regeneration / Faculty of Environmental Design University of Calgary

[book] Drydyk, J. / 2010 / New Directions in Development Ethics: Essays in Honor of Denis Goulet / University of Notre Dame Press : 333~356

[book] Duffy, B. / 2008 / Searching for the Impact of Empowerment / Ipsos MORI

[journal] Duffy, K. / 1997 / Urban policy and the turn to community / The Town Planning Review 68(3) : 347~362

[thesis] Eklund, L. / 1999 / From Citizen Participation towards Community Empowerment: An analysis on health promotion from citizen perspective / The University of Tampere

[journal] Englund, T. / 2006 / communication: A pragmatist proposal / Journal of Curriculum Studies 38(5) : 503~520

[thesis] Farzaneh, M. / 2011 / Urban Development, Regeneration and Public Participation: A comparison between the UK and Iran / Newcastle University

[web] Forum for Neighbourhood Planning / Case Studies. Balsall Heath: A case study about the process and demands of consultation / https://www.ourneighbourhoodplanning.org.uk/case-studies/view/407

[journal] Healey, P. / 2002 / On creating the ‘city’ as a collective resource / Urban Studies 39(10) : 1777~1792

[book] Hill, M. / 2012 / The Public Policy Process / Routledge

[web] / International Association for Public Participation(IAP2) / http://iap2canada.ca

[journal] Kisby, B. / 2010 / The big society: Power to the people? / The Political Quarterly 81(4) : 484~491

[book] Lees, L. / 2003 / Urban Renaissance? New Labour, Community and Urban Policy / Policy Press : 61~82

[journal] Lyons, M. / 2001 / Participation, empowerment and sustainability: (How) do the links work? / Urban Studies 38(8) : 1233~1251

[other] Ministry of Housing, Communities & Local Government / 2008 / Community Engagement: Some lessons from the new deal for communities programme / CLG

[report] Lyons, M. / 2012 / National Planning Policy Framework / CLG

[thesis] Morgan-Trimmer, S. A. / 2010 / Governing Through Networks:Participation dynamics in new deal for communitie / Ph.D. / University of Bath

[journal] Nabatchi, T. / 2012 / Putting the public back in public values research: Designing participation to identify and respond to values / Public Administration Review 72(5) : 699~708

[report] Nelimarkka, M. / 2014 / Comparing Three Online Civic Engagement Platforms Using the Spectrum of Public Participation Framework / UC Berkeley, CITRIS

[journal] Perkins, D. D. / 1995 / Empowerment theory, research and application / American Journal of Community Psychology 23(5) : 569~579

[journal] Rifkin, S. B. / 1988 / Primary health care: On measuring participation / Social Science and Medicine 26(9) : 931~940

[book] Roberts, N. C. / 2008 / The Age of Direct Citizen Participation / M. E. Sharpe

[journal] Robinson, F. / 2005 / On the side of the angels: Community involvement in the governance of neighbourhood renewal / Local Economy 20(1) : 13~26

[journal] Robinson, H. S. / 2005 / Business performance measurement practices in construction engineering organizations / Measuring Business Excellence 9(1) : 13~22

[book] Rudlin, D. / 1995 / Building to Last / URBED/Joseph Rowntree Foundation

[report] Social Exclusion Unit / 1998 / Bringing Britain Together : A national strategy for neighbourhood renewal. London : The Stationery Office / The Stationery Office

[journal] Somerville, P. / 1998 / Empowerment through residence / Housing Studies 13(2) : 233~257

[report] The Pioneer Group / 2018 / Changing Places: Stories of innovation and tenacity in five birmingham neighbourhoods / Social Life

[book] Tsenkova, S. / 2002 / Urban Regeneration : Learning from the British experience. Calgary : Faculty of Environmental Design University of Calgary / Faculty of Environmental Design University of Calgary

[report] Winden, W. / 2010 / Community participation in knowledgebased local economic development projects: The case of Newcastle’s Science Central / REDIS Network

[report] World Bank / 1999 / The World Bank Annual Report / World Bank

[journal] Zimmerman, M. A. / 1988 / Citizen participation, perceived control, and psychological empowerment / American Journal of Community Psychology 16(5) : 725~750

이 논문은 한국연구재단의 지원을 받아 작성되었습니다.

KJC Korea
Journal Central

Statistics

Tools

Sharing

Issue List

Citation status