On the Music in Lukács’ Theory of Mimesis
-
Georg Lukács looks on art as a kind of the reflection-forms, on the epistemological premise that cognition is a reflection of the reality. That is, art is defined as ‘a mimesis or reflection of the objective reality’. Here mimesis does not mean a mechanical, photographic reproduction of what is extant, but a transformation of the phenomenal world for representing the essential moments through the phenomena. From this point of view, he envisages this aesthetic reflection as corresponding to the category mediating between the universal and the individual: ‘pariculaity (Besonderheit)’. According to him, particularity, the central category of the aesthetic reflection, sublates mere individuality and abstract universality, and unites the both organically. It is through the type(Typus) that the principle of particularity is realized in the works of art, and the universal moments of the objective reality finds expression in the typical characters and situations. In this sense, the type is ‘the most pronounced appearance form of particularity’. One of the objections to Lukács’ theory of mimesis is that it cannot be applied to the non-representational forms of art, such as music. Music, because of its high abstractness, raises more problems to the theory than other forms of art. ‘Is it reasonable to say that music imitates the objective reality?’ ‘How is the principle of particularity realized in the works of music?’ ‘What is the ‘type’ found in a musical work at all?’ To these problems he gives the answer that music is twofold mimesis, that is, music directly imitates feelings and emotions but such feelings and emotions are in themselves the reflections of the objective reality. Like this, music is characterized as ‘mimesis of mimesis’, and therefore shares with other forms of art the feature of reflecting the objective reality. According to Lukács, the feelings that music imitates or expresses are not those a composer feels while writing a piece of music, but feelings themselves being objectified socio-historically. Thus music cancels out the merely individual, in that it eradicates the purely personal circumstances of its origin; on the other hand, since it has no verbal character, it is incapable of grasping universality in conceptual terms. Consequently music is also governed by the category of particularity, which raises itself above the merely individual and extracts ‘typical traits from every particular phenomenon’. Music, as Lukács puts it, reproduces and evokes the problems of the moment of its personal and historical origin, from the perspective of its enduring significance in the development of humanity. In this way, Lukács is able to give an account of music that is in line with his theory of mimesis as a whole.
-
[book] Adorno / 1974 / “Erpreßte Versöhnung” in Noten zur Literatur, Bd. 11 / Suhrkamp : 251~280
[journal] Brecht / “Against Lukács” / New Left Review 84 : 39~53
[book] Dahlhaus / 1994 / Musikalischer Realismus－Zur Musikgeschichte des 19. Jahrhundert in ,『음악적 리얼리즘: 19세기 음악사의 새로운 해석』 / 예솔
[journal] Dahlhaus / 1987 / 『음악미학』 / 이론과 실천
[thesis] Federici, Silvia / 1980 / The Development of Lukács’ Realism / 박사 / State University of New York at Baffalo
[journal] Horn / 1974 / “The Concept of Mimesis in Georg Lukács” / British Journal of Aestheitcs 14(1) : 26~40
[book] Kiralyfalvi / 1986 / The Aesthetics of György Lukács in ,『루카치 미학 연구』 / 이론과 실천
[journal] Kiralyfalvi / 1985 / “Georg Lukács or Bertolt Brecht?” / British Journal of Aestheitcs 25(4) : 340~348
[book] Kofler / 1962 / “Weder Widerspiegelung noch Abstraktion: Lukács oder Adorno” in Zur Theorie der modernen Literatur: Der Avantgardismus in soziologischer Sicht / Luchterhand : 160~187
[book] Lenin / 1972 / Materialism and Empirio-criticism in Collected Works / Progress Publishers
[book] Lukács / 1971 / Probleme des Realismus Ⅰ / Luchterhand
[book] Lukács / 1965 / Balzac und der französische Realismus, in: Bd. 6 / Luchterhand
[book] Lukács / 1969 / Beiträge zur Geschichte der Ästhetik, in: Bd. 10 / Luchterhand
[book] Lukács / 1969 / Über die Besonderheit als Kategorie der Ästhetik, in: Bd. 10 / Luchterhand
[book] Lukács / 1963 / Die Eigenart des Ästhetischen, Bd. 11-12 / Luchterhand
[book] Parkinson / 1986 / Georg Lukács: the Man, his Work and his Ideas in ,『루카치 미학사상』 / 문예출판사
[book] Pasternack / 1986 / Georg Lukács: Späte Ästhetik und Literaturtheorie, 2. ergänzte Auflage / Verlag Anton Hain
[book] Renner / 1976 / Ästhetische Theorie bei Georg Lukács: Zu ihrer Genese und Struktur / Francke Verlag
[book] Sorgner / 2008 / Musik in der deutschen Philosophie: Eine Einführung in ,『독일 음악미학』 / 아난케
[journal] 오희숙 / 「음악적 모방미학에 대한 논의」 / 『낭만음악』 29(29) : 65~92
[journal] 오희숙 / 1994 / 「음악적 리얼리즘에 대한 논의－칼 달하우스의 이론을 중심으로」,『 / 『낭만음악』 (24) : 215~243
[confproc] 원준식 / 2007 / 「아도르노 미학에서 미메시스와 합리성의 변증법」 / 『미학예술학 연구』 / 한국미학예술학회 : 57~83
[book] 이주영 / 1998 / 『루카치 미학 연구: 미메시스 문제를 통해 본 예술과 현실의 관계』 / 서광사
[confproc] 이주영 / 1998 / 「루카치의 미술관-회화에 있어서의 리얼리즘」 / 『문예미학』 / 문예미학회 : 181~209
[journal] 주성혜 / 1989 / 「모방 개념을 통한 음악적 리얼리즘의 가능성 고찰」 / 『낭만음악』 (5) : 124~208
-
KCI Citation (0)
122 Viewed
Print this page
Search PDF