The Politics of Modernist Criticism of Art Photography : Medium-Specificity and Abstraction in Photography
-
This essay explores the relation between modernist photography criticism and modernist art criticism, tracing the transition in American art criticism from the era of Stieglitz’s dominance to that of Greenberg. It problematizes Greenberg’s marginalization of art photography in his modernist art criticism. Greenberg denies decades of the unique American contribution to photography theory and criticism his predecessor Stieglitz ardently had pursued. The essay argues that unlike Greenberg’s disconnection of photography from being a modernist art medium, photography was an integral part of American modernism and his denial of the tradition created a fissure in modernist art criticism and beyond. To prove this, the essay analyzes the notions of medium-specificity and abstraction in photography, mostly known as two root concepts of Greenberg’s modernist art criticism. It introduces how the concepts emerged and gradually developed in American art photography since the early twentieth century, along with the varied activities of the promoter of art photography and American modern art, Stieglitz. Greenberg creates a direct genealogy between Analytic Cubism and American abstract paintings, and he excludes photography from that tradition of abstraction. The essay makes a counterargument by investigating evidences of commonalities found in both Stieglitz’s The Steerage and Pollock’s abstract painting mediated through Picasso’s Analytical Cubism. Further, through the analysis of Stieglitz’s series of cloud photographs, Equivalents, created in the 1920s-30s, and Jackson Pollock’s abstract paintings created in the 1930s-50s, it proves the Greenbergian root modernist concepts which had excluded photography are equally applicable to both photography and painting. Lastly, it investigates the underlying politics of the photography criticism of Greenberg during the 1940s and 50s. He assured art photography’s exclusion in American modernism in favor of painting and of authority of his art criticism, though the practice of art photography continued to develop and Greenberg himself still considered photography as an art under certain conditions. It argues that photography, far from being marginal from abstraction, occupied a leading position in American modernism until the 1930s, continually developing abstraction in form and theory in the sense that Greenberg appreciated from abstract paintings.
-
[other] MoMA / 1951 / Abstraction in Photography / MoMA
[book] Andy Grundberg / 1989 / Abstraction in Contemporary Photography / Virginia Commonwealth University
[other] A Debate on Abstraction / 1988 / An Exhibition Catalog / The Bertha and Karl Leudsdorf Art Gallery
[other] Baldessari, Anne / 1997 / Picasso and Photography : The Dark Mirror / Museum of Fine Arts
[journal] Bayley, Gilbert / 1947 / Photographer's America / York Times Magazine : 37~39
[book] Baudelaire, Charles / 1981 / The Salon of 1859, Art in Paris 1845-1862: Salons and Other Exhibitions / Phaidon
[journal] Bohn, Willard / 1980 / The Abstract Vision of Marius de Zayas / The Art Bulletin 62(3) : 434~452
[book] Buerger,Janet E / 1984 / The Last Decade : The Emergence of Art Photography in the 1890s / International Museum of George Eastman House
[book] Caffin, Charles / 1901 / Photography as a Fine Art : The Achievement and Possibilities of Photographic Art in America / Doubleday, Page & Company
[book] Coke, Van Deren / 1964 / The Painter and the Photograph / Albuquerrque
[book] Connor, Celeste / 2001 / Democratic Vision : Art and Theory of Stieglitz Circle / University of California Press
[book] Dell, Virginia / 1984 / John Szarkowski's Guide / Afterimage : 8~11
[journal] Evans, Frederick H / 1900 / On Straight Photography / The Photographic Journal 59 : 236~241
[book] FitzGerald, Michael C / 2006 / Picasso and American Art / Yale University Press
[book] Golding, John / 1959 / Cubism : A History and Analysis: 1907-1914 / George Wittenborn
[book] Greenberg, Clement / 1986 / The Collected Essays and Criticism, vol. I-Vl / The University of Chicago Press
[journal] Greenberg, Clement / 1942 / Study in Stieglitz : Review of The Emergence of an American Art by Jerome Mellquist / The Collected Essays and Criticism I : 106~108
[book] Greenberg, Clement / 1961 / American-Type Painting / Art and Culture : 208~229
[journal] Greenberg, Clement / 1946 / The Camera's Glass Eye : Review of an Exhibition of Edward Weston / The Collected Essays II : 60~63
[journal] Greenberg, Clement / 1946 / Review of an Exhibition on Georgia O'Keeffe / The Collected Essays II : 85~87
[journal] Greenberg, Clement / 1947 / Review of the Whitney Annual and Exhibitions of Picasso and Henri Cartier-Bresson / The Collected Essays 1 : 137~140
[journal] Greenberg, Clement / 1949 / The Role of Nature in Modern Painting / The Collected Essays II : 271~275
[book] Greenough, Sarah / 2002 / Alfred Stieglitz: The Key Set / Abrams
[book] Greenberg, Clement / 2000 / Modern Art and America: Alfred Stieglitz and His New York Galleries / National Gallery of Art
[book] Grundberg, Andy / 1984 / An Interview with John Szarkowski / Afterimag : 12~13
[book] Hartmann, Sadakichi / 1910 / On the Possibility of New Laws of Composition / Camera Work : 199~
[journal] Greenberg, Clement / 1900 / On Plagiarism & Imitation / Camera Notes 3 : 108~
[journal] Greenberg, Clement / 1904 / A Plea for Straight Photography / American Amateur Photographer 16 : 101~109
[book] Hoffman, Katherine / 2004 / Stieglitz: A Beginning Light / Yale University Press Studio
[other] San Francisco Museum of Modern Art / 2010 / Is Photography Over? / http://www.sfmoma.org/pages/research_projects_photography_over
[other] Johnson, Caitlin / 2010 / Picasso's Influence on American Artists / http://www.cbsnews.com/stories/2007/01/18/sunday/main2371451.shtml.
[journal] Kelsey, Robin / 2002 / The Stieglitz Circle Retraced / Review of the Painting Gender 9(1) : 177~184
[book] Krauss, Rosalind / 1980 / Reading Photographs as Text / Agrinde Publications
[book] Krauss, Rosalind / 1979 / Stieglitz/Equivalents : 129~140
[journal] Norman, Dorothy / 1942 / Alfred Stieglitz : Four Happenings (8) : 105~137
[book] Lyon, N / 1966 / Photographers on Photography / George Eastman House
[other] Smith, Terry / 2009 / Review of Clement Greenberg at 100 : Looking Back to Modern Art / http://www.caareviews.org/reviews/1298
[other] Stein, Gertrude / 1938 / Picasso
[journal] Stieglitz, Alfred / 1911 / Letter, Wilson's Photographic Magazine 48 : 437~
[other] Stieglitz, Alfred / 1916 / Letter to R. C. Bayley / ASA/YU : 17~
[journal] Stieglitz, Alfred / 1916 / Camera Work (48) : 11~
[journal] Stieglitz, Alfred / 1917 / Camera Work (49) : 36~
[book] Stieglitz, Alfred / 2000 / Stieglitz on Photography / Aperture
[journal] Szarkowski, John / 1995 / The Sky Pictures of Alfred Stieglitz / MoM (20) : 15~17
[book] Pollock, Jackson / 1999 / Handwritten Statement / Museum of Modern Art
[book] Rexer, L / 2009 / The Edge of Vision : The Rise of Abstraction in Photography / Aperture
[journal] Taylor, Richard P / 2002 / The Construction of Jackson Pollock's Fractal Drip Paintings / Leonardo 35(2) : 203~207
[journal] Tonelli, Edith / 1982 / Precision and Modern Photography / Art Journal : 341~345
[book] Travis, David / 1979 / Photography Rediscovered : American Photographs, 1900-1930 / Whitney Museum of Art
[journal] Tucker, Paul Hayes / 1982 / Picasso, Photography, and the Development of Cubism / Art Bulletin LXIV(2) : 275~298
[book] Underwood, Sandra Lee / 1893 / A Voice for Modernism 1897-1918 / UMI Research Press
[book] / 1951 / What is Modern in Photography / American Photography : 130~148
[journal] Wilson, Kristine / 2003 / The Intimate Gallery and the Equivalents : Spirituality in the 1920s Work of Stieglitz / The Art Bulletin 85(4) : 746~768
[journal] de Zayas, Marius / 1912 / Camera Work (39) : 17~21
[journal] de Zayas, Marius / 1913 / Photography / Camera Work (41) : 13~17
[book] de Zayas, Marius / 1916 / A Study of the Modern Evolution of Plastic Expression
-
439 Viewed
Print this page
Search PDF