A Study on a Relevant Relation Between Arts and Nature : Focused on Aesthetic Theories of Kant, Hamann and Schiller

Sun-Kyu Ha

The Journal of Aesthetics and Science of Art

Abbr : JASA
2011, 34(), pp.181-223
Publisher : 한국미학예술학회
Research Area : Other Arts and Kinesiology

Sun-Kyu Ha ¹

¹홍익대학교

ABSTRACT

How relates art to nature? Does art fundamentally go with nature or go against or go beyond nature? Is it undoubtedly obvious that thinking of art always depends on thinking of nature? Under this consciousness this article aims to discuss aesthetic theory of I. Kant, J. G. Hamann and F. Schiller. According to his program of transcendental philosophy, Kant investigates into the subjective-formal principle which aesthetic judgments on the beautiful and the sublime presuppose implicitly. And he elaborates on the view that aesthetic idea which art work expresses pursues procreative nature(natura naturans). As for Kant, concrete and productive nature stands for the point of departure of aesthetic experience as well as the ideal of artistic expression. Kant's aesthetic theory is grounded on rational basis of universal reason and human being in general. Hamann's thought is just against this point for he blames rationalistic perception of things for not having their vivid concreteness. It is not able to feel and understand temporal, historic and linguistic character of living concrete nature. With regard to this Hamann underlines the significance of poetry and art. Languages of poetry and art are sensuous media by which silent nature can be awakened again from its objectified state. Schiller is also in accordance with Hamann's position of radical sensualism. In contrary to Hamann, however, he defines beauty as ‘living form(Gestalt)’ and justifies specific importance of playing drive and aesthetic state of mind from the viewpoint of philosophical anthropology. It can be said that Schiller tries to unify dialectically Kant's problem of possibility of determination and Hamann's radical historic sensualism. In spite of some striking differences of theoretical argumentation, three thinkers coincide with each other in the fact that considerations on art relate closely to reflections on nature.
KEYWORDS

modern aesthetics, Kant's aesthetics, Hamann's aesthetics, Schiller's aesthetics, arts and nature, aesthetic state of mind, aesthetic education
REFERENCES (49)

[book] Kant, I. / 1957 / Kritik der Urteilskraft / Suhrkamp

[book] Kant, I. / 1957 / Kritik der reiner Vernunft / Suhrkamp

[book] Hamann, J. G. / 1993 / Aesthetica in nuce / Reclam

[book] Hamann, J. G. / 1993 / Sokratische Denkwürdigkeiten / Reclam

[book] Hamann, J. G. / 2007 / Writings on Philosophy and Language / Cambridge Univ. Press

[book] Schiller, F. / 1989 / Über die ästhetische Erziehung des Menschen, mit Nachwort von K / Reclam

[book] Schiller, F. / 1982 / On the Aesthetic Education of Man / Oxford Univ. Press

[book] H. G. Zekl / 1995 / Aristoteles, Physica, Philosophische Schriften in sechs Bänden / WB

[book] Bayer, O. / 1988 / Zeitgenosse im Widerspruch. Johann Georg Hamann als radikaler Aufklärer / Piper

[book] Berlin,I. / 2005 / The Roots of Romanticism(1999) / 이제이북스

[book] Cassirer,E. / 1991 / Das Erkenntnisproblem in der Philosophie und Wissenschaft der neueren Zeit(1922) / WB

[book] Cassirer, E. / 1995 / 계몽주의 철학 / 민음사

[book] Darsow, G.-L. / 2000 / Friedrich Schiller / Metzler

[book] Diels, H. / 1974 / 소크라테스 이전 철학자들의 단편 선집 / 아카넷 : 2005~

[book] 하선규 / 2005 / Vernunft und Vollkommenheit (Reason and Perfection) / 독일 PETER LANG 출판사

[book] Hegel, G. W. F. / 1970 / Die Phänomenologie des Geistes(1807) / Ullstein

[book] Hegel, G. W. F. / 1986 / Hamanns Schriften(1828) / Suhrkamp

[book] Heidegger, M. / 1953 / Tübingen:Max Niemeyer / Max Niemeyer

[book] Jørgensen, S.-A. / 1976 / Johann Georg Hamann / Stuttgart

[book] Luserke-Jaqui, M / 2005 / Leben-Werk-Wirkung / Metzler

[book] Metzke, E., J. G / 1934 / Hamanns Stellung in der Philosophie des 18. Jahrhunderts / Max Niemeyer

[book] Metzke, E., J. G. / 1961 / Hamann und das Geheimnis des Wortes in Coincidentia oppositorum / Luther-Verlag : 271~293

[book] Metzke, E., J. G. / 1961 / Kant und Hamann in Coincidentia oppositorum / Luther-Verlag : 294~319

[book] Nietzsche, F. / 2007 / 비극의 탄생 / 아카넷

[book] Platon / 1973 / Nomoi, Sämtliche Werke / Hamburg

[book] Platon / 1997 / 국가-정체 / 서광사

[book] Pries, Ch. / 1995 / Übergänge ohne Brücken. Kants Erhabenes zwischen Kritik und Metaphysik / Akad. Verl

[book] Ritter, J. / 1976 / Historisches Wörterbuch der Philosophie / Schwabe

[book] Rousseau, J.-J. / 2007 / 학문과 예술에 대하여 외 / 한길사

[book] Scheible, H. / 1988 / Wahrheit und Subjekt. Ästhetik im bürgerlichen Zeitalter / Rowohlt

[book] Simon, J. / 1967 / Johann Georg Hamann. Schriften zur Sprache / Suhrkamp

[book] Weber, H. / 1904 / Hamann und Kant in Ein Beitrag zur Geschichte der Philosophie im Zeitalter der Aufklärung / Beck

[journal] 공병혜 / 2006 / Der Ursprung der Schnheit in der sthetik Kants und ihre gegenwrtige Bedeutung / 미학예술학연구 / 한국미학예술학회 24 : 49~74

[journal] 기정희 / 2002 / Schiller's Aesthetic Anthropology / 미학예술학연구 / 한국미학예술학회 15 : 153~134

[journal] 기정희 / 2008 / The meaning of play in Schiller's Über die ästhetische Erziehung des Menschen in einer Reihe von Briefen / 인문연구 / 인문과학연구소 54(54) : 249~276

[book] 김광명 / 2007 / 쉴러 미학에 대한 인간학적 이해, 미학대계 1 - 미학의 역사 / 서울대출판부 : 367~394

[journal] 김기수 / 2010 / A Study in Kant’s Notion of Aesthetic Imagination / 미학예술학연구 / 한국미학예술학회 31 : 297~335

[journal] 김대권 / 2004 / Zu Hamanns Sprachtheologie / 괴테연구 / 한국괴테학회 16(16) : 247~268

[journal] 김상현 / 2003 / The Antinomy of the Aesthetic judgment and the Aesthetic Rationality / 시대와 철학 / 한국철학사상연구회 14(1) : 128~144

[journal] 김상현 / 2006 / On the Relation of Emotion and Imagination in Kant's Aesthetics / 칸트연구 / 한국칸트학회 17(17) : 1~26

[book] 김헌 / 2007 / 아리스토텔레스 시학의 세 개념에 기초한 인간 행동 세계의 시적 통찰과 창작의 원리, 미학대계 1 - 미학의 역사 / 서울대출판부 : 94~101

[journal] 박배형 / 2008 / Das freie Spiel der Erkenntniskräfte ― Ein Problem in Kants Ästhetik / 美學(미학) / 한국미학회 27(53) : 27~60

[journal] 이경희 / 2005 / Geschlechtsspezifische Konzeptionen in Schillers aesthetischer Schrift ueber Anmut und Wuerde / 독일문학 / 한국독어독문학회 47(3) : 5~24

[journal] 인성기 / 2009 / Die ästhetische Totalität des modernen Menschen in F. Schillers Kunstauffassung / 독일어문학 / 한국독일어문학회 17(4) : 117~136

[journal] 조경식 / 2002 / Eine systemtheoretische Studie zu der Autonomie der Kunst in den“？sthetischen Briefen”Friedrich Schillers / 독일문학 / 한국독어독문학회 43(1) : 48~68

[journal] 조경식 / 2002 / Eine systemtheoretische Studie zu der Autonomie der Kunst in den ＜？sthetischen Briefen＞ Friedrich Schillers / 뷔히너와 현대문학 / 한국뷔히너학회 18 : 211~230

[journal] 하선규 / 1998 / 전 비판기 칸트에 있어 현실대립의 발견과 그 영향 / 대동철학 / 대동철학회 1 : 97~117

[journal] 하선규 / 2004 / Inter-subjective Horizon of Significant Form or Structure / 칸트연구 / 한국칸트학회 14(14) : 169~204

[journal] 하선규 / 2006 / Freiheit der Natur und Einbildungskraft: Versuch ber die Aktualitt der reflektierenden Urteilskraft Kants(II) / 미학예술학연구 / 한국미학예술학회 24 : 5~47
KCI Citation (6)

KJC Korea
Journal Central

Statistics

Tools