A Meta Analysis of Policy Implementation Cases in Korea

Lee Hye Young; 고효진

This study is based upon a meta-analysis of Korean policy implementation cases, in order to overcome a limitation of existing policy implementation studies: A focus on single case studies. The purpose of this study is to explore theory building possibilities for implementation research, and to investigate factors and characteristics which influenced policy implementation. A total of 55 articles, published in Korea from 1990 to 2015, were selected. Based on the theoretical and case surveys, 47 detailed factors are identified that can influence the policy implementation process. The analysis results are as follows: First, key high frequency factors are policy clarity, policy consistency, bureaucratic expertise, capacity and leadership, executive resources such as budget, collaboration among organizations, target group behavior and interest, and environmental support. Second, there were relative differences among significant variables according to policy type or level of government. Based on these results, policy consistency, collaboration among organizations, and target group characteristics need to be explored further in future implementation studies. Lastly, this study has important implications concerning the considerations of policy practitioners at the early-design stage in order to increase policy feasibility.

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (15)
열림/닫힘 버튼
REFERENCES (45)
열림/닫힘 버튼
* 2021년 이후 발행 논문의 참고문헌은 현재 구축 중입니다.

[journal] 강제상 / 1996 / 질규제정책에 대한 정책대상집단의 순응에 관한 연구 / 한국정책학회보 5(2) : 349~367

[journal] 권혁주 / 2007 / 정책집행과 정책핵임성: 거버넌스적 접근의 가능성과 한계 / 국정관리연구 2(1) : 59~78

[journal] 김렬 / 1999 / 문화예술정책의 집행요인분석: 98 경제세계문화EXPO사업을 중심으로 / 한국행정논집 11(4) : 911~932

[journal] 김인종 / 2010 / A Study on the Factors Influencing the Implementation of Anti-Corruption Policy / 한국조직학회보 / 한국조직학회 7(2) : 183~206

[journal] 김주현 / 1999 / 정책집행의 불응에 관한 실증적 연구: 혐악시설의 입지선정과정을 중심으로 / 국가정책연구 13(1) : 19~35

[journal] 김호균 / 2007 / A Causal Relationship Study on Impact Factors andEffectiveness in Cultural Policy Implementation / 정책분석평가학회보 / 한국정책분석평가학회 17(1) : 167~192

[journal] 문영세 / 2012 / Successful Implementation of Public Policy by Emotion Management / 정책분석평가학회보 / 한국정책분석평가학회 22(2) : 65~94 / http://dx.doi.org/

[journal] 민기 / 2006 / The Impact of Tangerine Farmers' Characters in Jeju Province on the Agricultural Policy Compliance of Local Government / 지방정부연구 / 한국지방정부학회 10(1) : 7~24

[journal] 박동석 / 1997 / 지역정책사업집행에서 주민불응요인에 관한 연구: 용담다목적댐건설사업을 중심으로 / 한국지역개발학회지 9(2) : 47~58

[journal] 박은미 / 2006 / A Study on the Influential Factors to the Implementation of Maternity Protection Policy Effectiveness: Focused on the Application of Structural Equation Modeling / 한국행정논집 / 한국정부학회 18(4) : 1205~1232

[journal] 양숙미 / 2012 / Policy Compliance Factors on System of the Parking Area for the Handicapped / 지체.중복.건강장애연구 / 한국지체.중복.건강장애교육학회 55(2) : 99~113 / http://dx.doi.org/

[confproc] 오영석 / 1998 / 98 경주세계문화엑스포의 기획 및 정책평가와 개선방향,98 경주세계문화엑스포에대한 평가와 향후 개선방안 / 동국대학교 정책세미나자료

[journal] 옥화영 / 2008 / The Policy Effect and Factors influencing in the Fair Trade Policy's Implementation : Focusing on the Difference in Recognition between the Regulator and Group regulated / 한국공공관리학보 / 한국공공관리학회 22(3) : 53~75

[journal] 윤태섭 / 2005 / A Study on the Influencing Factors of Policy Implementation Attitude of Street Level Bureaucracy / 한국공공관리학보 / 한국공공관리학회 19(1) : 135~157

[journal] 이규환 / 2012 / A Study on the policy implementation factors in the New address system / 한국지방자치학회보 / 한국지방자치학회 24(1) : 123~144

[journal] 이성룡 / 1998 / 정책집행에 영향을 미치는 요인에 관한 연구: 선거운동규제정책을 대상으로 / 지역개발연구 6 : 203~226

[journal] 이순자 / 2010 / Research on Influential Effect of Executing Welfare Policy: Focused on Awareness of Public Employees in Gyeongbuk / 한국지방자치연구 / 대한지방자치학회 11(4) : 61~79

[journal] 이연택 / 2014 / A Study on the Influencing Factors of Policy Implementation of Tourism Police System / 관광연구논총 / 관광연구소 26(3) : 25~49

[journal] 이혜영 / 2004 / A Study on the Actual Condition in the Self-Evaluation Instituion: The Perspective of Policy Implementation / 한국지방자치학회보 / 한국지방자치학회 16(3) : 43~65

[journal] 이혜영 / 2009 / A Study on the intergovernmental Unfunded Mandate in Regulatory Implementation / 지방정부연구 / 한국지방정부학회 12(4) : 75~94

[journal] 전형원 / 1991 / 한국의 환경정책집행에 관한 연구: 집행공무원의 인지를 중심으로 / 한국자치행정학보 4 : 87~101

[book] 정정길 / 2005 / 정책학원론 / 대명문화사

[journal] 조국현 / 2004 / Factors of Successful Policy Implementation in National Projects for Technology Innovation / 기술혁신연구 / 기술경영경제학회 12(3) : 73~96

[journal] 주동근 / 2009 / Why do Travel Agencies not Comply with the Regulation of Tourism Contract? / 한국정책학회보 / 한국정책학회 18(2) : 271~298

[journal] 차용진 / 2005 / A Study on the Regulatory Compliance: With Focus on the Environmental Regulation / 한국정책과학학회보 / 한국정책과학학회 9(4) : 113~132

[journal] 채재은 / 2014 / An Analysis on the Implementation Process of the Regional Lifelong Learning Policy / 평생교육학연구 / 한국평생교육학회 20(2) : 89~119

[report] 최성락 / 2014 / 규제･민원행정 불만 요인 분석 / 한국규제학회･감사연구원

[journal] 최성모 / 1992 / 정책집행의 정치적 성격과 특징: 의약분업정책을 중심으로 / 한국행정학보 26(3) : 771~797

[journal] 최종원 / 1998 / 정책집행연구의 이론적 틀에 대한 비판적 고찰 / 한국정책학회보 7(1)

[journal] 최종원 / 2001 / 한국의 정책집행 실증연구에 관한 고찰 / 행정논총 39(3) : 167~193

[journal] 하규만 / 2000 / 정책집행 이론의 재검토: 미국과 한국의 실태 / 지방정부연구 4(1) : 9~22

[journal] 허훈 / 2001 / 지방환경정책집행에 대한 참여의지의 영향요인에 관한 연구: 포천군의 재활용정책을 중심으로 / 한국지방자치학회보 13(2) : 183~203

[book] Beierle, T.C. / 2002 / Democracy in Practice. Public Participation in Environmental Decisions / Resources for the Future

[journal] Bennear, Lori S. / 2007 / Are Management-based Regulations Effective? Evidence from State Pollution Prevention Programs / Journal of Policy Analysis and Management 26 : 327~348

[journal] Elmore, R. F. / 1980 / Backward Mapping: Implementation Research and Policy Decisions / Political Science Quarterly 94(4) : 601~616

[report] Geist, H.J. / 2001 / What Drives Tropical Deforestation? A meta-analysis of proximate and underlying causes of deforestation based on subnational case study evidence / LUCC

[book] Goggin, Malcom L. / 1990 / Implementation Theory and Practice: Toward a Third Generation / Harper Collins Publishers

[journal] Jensen, J.L. / 2001 / Cumulating the Intellectual Gold of Case Study Research / Public Administration Review 61(2) : 235~246

[journal] Larsson, R. / 1993 / Case Survey Methodology: Quantitative Analysis of Patterns across Case Studies / The Academy of Management Journal 36(6) : 1515~1546

[book] Newig, Jens / 2009 / The Case Survey Method and Applications in Political Science / Paper persented at the APSA 2009 meeting, Panel on Case study meta-analysis: Methodolagical challenges and applications in the political science

[journal] Newig, J. / 2009 / Environmental Governance: Participatory, Multi-Level – And Effective? / Environmental Policy and Governance 19(3) : 197~214

[journal] O’Toole, Jr. Laurence J. / 2000 / Research on Policy Implementation: Assessment and Prospects / Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory: J-PART 10(2) : 263~288

[journal] O’Toole, Jr. Laurence J. / 1984 / Interorganizational Policy Implementation: A Theoretical Perspective / Public Administration Review 44(6) : 491~503

[journal] Sabatier, Paul P. / 1986 / Top-Down and Bottom-Up Approaches to Implementation Research: A critical Analysis and Suggested Synthesis / Journal of Public Policy 6(1)

[journal] Wolf, P.J. / 1993 / A Case Survey of Bureaucratic Effectiveness in U.S. Cabinet Agencies: Preliminary Results / Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory 3(2) : 161~181

KJC Korea
Journal Central

Statistics

Tools

Sharing

Issue List

Citation status