A Study on the Importation and Indigenization of Pay-for-Performance

Lee Geon

The New Public Management(NPM) movement allows governmental agencies to initiate reforms in a way that various managerial techniques are implanted in the public sector. One of the techniques is pay-for-performance(PFP) which links pay to job performance in order to improve both individual-and organization-level performance. PFP had been operating for 20 years in government agencies since the Kim Dae-Jung administration adopted. The main purpose of this study is to diagnose the indigenization of PFP and analyze the causes of policy success or failure in Korea. Rather than imitating the PFP type of the specific country, Korean government designed our unique PFP system based on PFP ideas from OECD countries. Yet some problems of using PFP in government have emerged such as complaints and resistance of public managers, equal pay redistribution, and counter-evidence of PFP. Although the limitations of PFP are obvious, it has been operated in a path-dependence way. This paper suggests the three main reasons why PFP is implemented in an instable indigenization manner.

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (3)
열림/닫힘 버튼
REFERENCES (78)
열림/닫힘 버튼
* 2021년 이후 발행 논문의 참고문헌은 현재 구축 중입니다.

[book] 강성철 / 2018 / 인사행정론 / 대영문화사

[journal] 권일웅 / 2012 / Performance-Related Compensation in the Korean Public and Private Sectors: A Test of Principal-Agent Theory / 행정논총 / 한국행정연구소 50(2) : 113~142 / http://dx.doi.org/

[journal] 금재덕 / 2009 / 성과관리체계의 부정적 효과에 관한 실증연구: 중앙정부 각 부처 공무원의 인식도를 중심으로 / 한국사회와 행정연구 / 서울행정학회 20(2) : 347~377

[book] 김병섭 / 2008 / 휴먼조직론 / 대영문화사

[journal] 김봉식 / 1968 / 한국의 사고방식을 통해 본 한국행정문화 / 한국행정학보 2 : 341~354

[journal] 김호섭 / 2002 / 한국 행정문화 연구의 동향과 과제 / Journal of Korean Culture 3 : 1~12

[journal] 남성일 / 1999 / 외환위기 이후 우리나라 실업의 특성분석: 외환위기 이전과의 비교 / 노동경제논집 22(1) : 87~108

[journal] 노종호 / 2016 / The Influence of Performance-Related Pay and Public Service Motivation on the Job Performance of Public Employees / 한국인사행정학회보 / 한국인사행정학회 15(2) : 93~122

[journal] 도명록 / 2018 / Performance-Based Personnel System and Organizational Performance: A Comparison of Public and Private Sector Employees / 행정논총 / 한국행정연구소 56(1) : 93~117

[journal] 백완기 / 2008 / The Compatibility of Korean Administrative Culture with Administrative reform based on Foreign Theory / 정부학연구 / 정부학연구소 14(1) : 5~35

[book] 백완기 / 2013 / 행정학 / 박영사

[journal] 손상식 / 2009 / A Study on the Pay-for-performance System of the Civil Service / 법학연구 / 법학연구원 19(1) : 377~416

[journal] 오석홍 / 2010 / 성과급제도의 이상과 좌절 / 행정논총 38(1) : 191~207

[journal] 오성호 / 2003 / 지방공무원의 성과급제 실시에 따른 문제점과 개선 방안 / 한국행정연구 / 한국행정연구원 12(4) : 219~247

[journal] 윤광재 / 2011 / Exploring the Characteristics of Public Administration in Korea: Conceptualizing Administrative Culture / 한국정책과학학회보 / 한국정책과학학회 15(2) : 29~51

[journal] 윤영근 / 2019 / A Study on the Introduction and Indigenization of Government Team System / 한국사회와 행정연구 / 서울행정학회 29(4) : 1~29

[journal] 이근주 / 2007 / The Determinants of the Performance: Expectancy of Rewards and Public Service Motivation / 한국행정학보 / 한국행정학회 41(2) : 117~140

[book] 이면우 / 1992 / W이론을 만들자 / 지식산업사

[journal] 이명수 / 2007 / A Study on the Changes in the Role of a State Before and After IMF Foreign Exchange Crisis / 한국동북아논총 / 한국동북아학회 12(44) : 225~250

[journal] 이종범 / 2003 / 행정이론의 토착화의 재음미 / 한국사회와 행정연구 14(2) : 1~22

[journal] 이종범 / 2005 / 한국행정학 연구의 한국화: 이론의 세계화 / KAPA＠포럼 112 : 11~14

[confproc] 이형우 / 2015 / 성과중심 인사관리제도의 효과성에 관한 연구 / 한국행정학회 학술발표논문집

[journal] 이희태 / 2010 / Motivation Effect Analysis of Pay-for-Performance System for Public Servants -Focusing on the Performance Bonus System- / 지방정부연구 / 한국지방정부학회 14(1) : 159~180

[report] 인사혁신처 / 2017 / 공무원 성과-보상의 다양성 및 유연성 제공방안 연구

[journal] 전영평 / 2011 / 행정학의 토착화･한국화 담론의 성찰과 대안적 연구 모색 / 공공정책과 국정관리 5(1) : 3~36

[journal] 조성한 / 2012 / Universality of Naturalization of Public Administration Theories from the Perspective of Government Tool Theorists / 한국정책학회보 / 한국정책학회 21(4) : 33~52

[other] 중앙인사위원회 / 2000 / 인사제도에 대한 공무원 여론조사

[book] 중앙인사위원회 / 2002 / 공무원인사개혁백서

[book] 중앙인사위원회 / 2005 / 공무원인사개혁백서

[journal] 최유진 / 2017 / Performance-related Pay in Government: Present Challenges and Suggestions for the Future / 한국인사행정학회보 / 한국인사행정학회 16(1) : 75~102

[journal] 하미승 / 2004 / A Study on the Effective Management of Performance Bonus Program in the Public Sector / 한국사회와 행정연구 / 서울행정학회 15(2) : 1~22

[journal] 하상근 / 2005 / A Study on the Determinants of Non-compliance of Policy Implementation: A Case Study on Pay-for-Performance System in Public Organization / 한국정책학회보 / 한국정책학회 14(4) : 1~28

[thesis] 하상묵 / 1999 / 공무원 성과급의 효과성에 관한 연구 : 동기 부여 효과에 대한 한국 공무원의 인식 / 박사 / 韓國外國語大學校大學院

[journal] 하혜수 / 2014 / The Effects of Performance-based Pay from the Experience of Eleven Public Enterprises / 행정논총 / 한국행정연구소 52(3) : 145~177

[report] 한국행정연구원 / 2001 / 행정에 관한 공무원의 인식과 태도

[book] 한석태 / 2017 / 정책학개론 / 대영문화사

[journal] 한승주 / 2010 / Response of Civil Servants to Pay for Performance: An Application of Grounded Theory / 한국행정학보 / 한국행정학회 44(4) : 29~58

[journal] 허창수 / 2012 / Institution, Institutional Process, and Institutional Effects: Institutional Process and Institutional Effects of Performance-based Payment in the Public Sector / 한국행정학보 / 한국행정학회 46(2) : 55~83 / http://dx.doi.org/

[journal] 황성원 / 2003 / 공공조직의 성과급제에 관한 소고 / 한국행정연구 / 한국행정연구원 12(4) : 123~147

[journal] 황성원 / 2016 / The Effect of Performance related Pay System Satisfaction of National Universities on the Job Satisfaction, Organizational Commitment and Public Service Motivation / 융합사회와 공공정책 / 융합사회연구소 10(3) : 233~266

[journal] Alvarez, R. M. / 2006 / The Principal-Agent Problems in Election Administration / Policy Studies Journal 34(4) : 491~510

[journal] Braun, D. / 2003 / Principal-Agent Theory and Research Policy: An Introduction / Science and Public Policy 30(5) : 302~308

[journal] DiMaggio, P. / 1983 / The Iron Cage Revisited: Institutional Isomorphism and Collective Rationality in Organizational Fields / American Sociological Review 48 : 147~160

[journal] Dolowitz, D. P. / 2000 / Learning from Abroad: The Role of Policy Transfer in Contemporary Policy-Making

[journal] Eisenhardt, K. M. / 1989 / Agency Theory: An Assessment and Review / Academy of Management Journal 14(1) : 57~74

[book] Frey, B. S. / 1997 / Not Just for the Money: An Economic Theory of Personal Motivation / Edward Elgar

[journal] Houston, D. J. / 2009 / Motivating Knights or Knaves? Moving beyond Performance-related Pay for the Public Sector / Public Administration Review 69 : 43~57

[book] Hofstede, G. / 2010 / Cultures and Organizations / McGraw-Hill Education

[journal] Ingraham, P. W. / 1993 / Of Pigs in Pokes and Policy Diffusion: Another Look at Pay-for-Performance / Public Administration Review 53(4) : 348~356

[journal] James, O. / 2003 / The Limitations of ‘Policy Transfer’ and ‘Lesson Drawing’ for Public Policy Research / Political Studies Review 1 : 179~193

[book] Kettl, F. D. / 2005 / The Global Public Management Revolution / The Brookings Institution

[book] Lane, J. E. / 2000 / New Public Management / Routledge

[journal] 이건 / 2017 / Performance-oriented managerial practices and job attitude in public organizations / International Review of Public Administration / 한국행정학회 22(3) : 245~256 / https://doi.org/10.1080/12294659.2017.1344452

[journal] Locke, E. A. / 1978 / The Ubiquity of the Technique of Goal Setting in Theories of and Approaches to Employee Motivation / Academy of Management Review 3(3) : 594~601

[book] Moynihan, D. P. / 2008 / Motivation in Public Management: The Call of Public Service / Oxford University Press : 247~267

[journal] Nutley, S. / 2003 / Evidence-Based Policy and Practice: Cross-Sector Lessons from the United Kingdom / Social Policy Journal of New Zealand 20 : 29~48

[book] OECD / 1993 / Private Pay for Public Work: Performance-Related Pay for Public Sector Managers

[book] Perrow, C. / 1986 / Complex Organizations / McGraw-Hill

[book] Perry, J. L. / 2003 / Public Personnel Administration: Problems and Prospects / Upper Saddle Rivers

[journal] Perry, J. L. / 2009 / Back to the Future? Performance-Related Pay, Empirical Research, and the Perils of Persistence / Public Administration Review 69(1) : 39~51

[journal] Pfeffer, J. . / 1998 / Six Dangerous Myths about Pay / Harvard Business Review 76(3) : 109~119

[book] Porter, L. W. / 1968 / Managerial Attitudes and Performance / Irwin

[book] Rainey, G. H. / 1997 / Understanding and Managing Public Organizations / Jossey-Bass

[journal] Rose, R. / 1991 / What is Lesson Drawing? / Journal of Public Policy 11(1) : 3~30

[book] Rose, R. / 1993 / Lesson-Drawing in Public Policy / Chatham House

[journal] Stroh, L. K. / 1996 / Agency Theory and Variable Pay Competition Strategies / Academy of Management Journal 39(3) : 751~787

[book] Taylor, W. F. / 1998 / The Principles of Scientific Management / Dover Publications

[book] Triandis, H. / 1995 / Individualism and Collectivism / Taylor & Francis

[book] Zey, M. / 1998 / Rational Choice Theory and Organizational Theory: A Critique / Sage Publications

[other] 광주일보 / 2015 / 공무원 성과급 제도 처음부터 다시 논의를

[other] 뉴시스 / 2015 / 광주 서구 성과급 재배분 논란...지역 공직사회 불똥

[other] 동아일보 / 2015 / 시민들 ‘공무원 성과급 나눠먹기 그만’

[other] 문화일보 / 2003 / 공무원 성과급 나눠먹기

[other] 세계일보 / 2015 / 공무원 성과상여금 16년째 ‘나눠먹기’

[other] 세계일보 / 2015 / 공무원 성과금 ‘나눠먹기’ 더 이상 안 된다

[other] 한국경제신문 / 2015 / 성과급 나눠먹기 제동 건 임우진 구청장을 지지한다

[other] 한국경제신문 / 2015 / 차등 성과급 나눠먹은 세종시 공무원

[other] 한국경제신문 / 2017 / 성과급 361억 똑같이 나눠 가진 공무원노조

KJC Korea
Journal Central

Statistics

Tools

Sharing

Issue List

Citation status