The Historical Function of the Trickster: A Study of the Clever Servant Tale

Charles La Shure

This paper examined the historical function of the trickster figure and the tales in which he appears. In particular, it attempted to provide an answer to the question of why seemingly negative tales were continuously handed down when they ran afoul of the ethical and moral value systems supported by the social order. It was in part a reaction to Jonathan Gotschall’s claim in The Storytelling Animal that narrative plays a morally supportive role, and in part an attempt to come to a deeper understanding of the trickster tale. I first discussed scholarly opinions in the West on the trickster’s dual or ambiguous nature and then introduced the concept of liminality as the trickster’s defining feature. This was followed by an examination of the trickster’s practicality, an examination that dealt with the question of what sort of evolutionary practicality could trickster tales have if they did not reinforce moral values and thereby also reinforce the social order. Native American tricksters and the Scandinavian trickster deity Loki were offered as examples, but the main focus of the discussion was the Korean tale of the clever servant who deceived his master. This tale can be seen as one that deals with class conflict, but there are other victim’s of the servant’s wiles besides the master: lower-class characters such as a common woman and a passerby down on his luck. This shows that the trickster here is not a lower-class hero who defies his upper-class master, but a liminal figure who seeks to bring down the entire social structure. This desire is an expression of the understanding that it is only possible to create a new world once the old world has been torn down. Finally, I also examined in brief some recorded tales and a novel that deal with the same themes and characters, showing how the trickster may be imagined differently depending on the author’s social values. Ultimately, the strong opposition to the social structure seen in tricksters in oral tales like that of the clever servant is a result of the historical function they play as pathfinders to the creation of a new world.

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (3)
열림/닫힘 버튼
REFERENCES (35)
열림/닫힘 버튼
* 2021년 이후 발행 논문의 참고문헌은 현재 구축 중입니다.

[book] / 1988 / 한국구비문학대계 / 정신문화연구원

[book] 김현룡 / 2000 / 한국문헌설화 7 / 건국대학교출판부

[book] 한기형 / 2007 / 역주 신단공안 神斷公案 / 창비

[book] Ballinger, Franchot / 2004 / Living Sideways: Tricksters in American Indian Oral Traditions / University of Oklahoma Press

[book] Erdoes, Richard / 1998 / American Indian Trickster Tales / Penguin Books

[journal] Meeker, Louis / 1902 / White Man. A Siouan Myth / Journal of American Folklore 15(57) : 84~87

[book] Radin, Paul / 1956 / The Trickster: A Study in American Indian Mythology / Schocken Books

[book] Sturluson, Snorri / 2006 / The Prose Edda, Arthur Gilchrist Brodeur / Dover Publications

[book] 김대숙 / 1994 / 한국설화문학연구 / 집문당 : 291~314

[book] 정준식 / 2005 / 한국 노지서사의 논리와 미학 / 월인 : 237~264

[book] Anderson, Rasmus B. / 1897 / Norse Mythology; or, The Religion of Our Forefathers, Containing All The Myths of the Eddas, Systematized and Interpreted. With an Introduction, Vocabulary and Index / S. C. Griggs and Co.

[book] Basso, Ellen / 1987 / In Favor of Deceit: A Study of Tricksters in an Amazonian Society / University of Arizona Press

[book] Boas, Franz / 1898 / Traditions of the Thompson River Indians of British Columbia / Houghton Mifflin : 1~18

[book] Brinton, Daniel / 1890 / Essays of an Americanist / Porter & Coates : 130~134

[book] Brinton, Daniel / 1868 / The Myths of the New World: A Treatise on the Symbolism and Mythology of the Red Race of America / Trübner & Co.

[book] Gottschall, Jonathan / 2012 / The Storytelling Animal / Mariner Books

[book] Harrison, Alan / 1989 / The Irish Trickster / Sheffield Academic Press

[book] Thompson, Stith / 1946 / The Folktale / Holt, Rinehart and Winston : 319~328

[book] Turner, Victor / 1967 / The Forest of Symbols: Aspects of Ndembu Ritual / Cornell University Press : 93~111

[book] Van Gennep, Arnold / 1960 / The Rites of Passage / University of Chicago Press

[journal] 김국희 / 2006 / The Transmission and the Meaning of a Disloyal Servant’s Story / 한국문학논총 / 한국문학회 (44) : 157~188

[journal] 김열규 / 1980 / 北韓의 탈춤(III) 트릭스터탈춤의 主役들(I) / 북한 104 : 221~225

[book] 김열규 / 1983 / 韓國文學史 : 그 形象과 解釋 / 집문당 : 385~416

[thesis] 나수호 / 2002 / <토끼전>과 북미원주민 설화에 나타난 트릭스터 비교 연구 / 석사 / 서울대학교 대학원

[thesis] 나수호 / 2011 / 한국설화에 나타난 트릭스터 연구 : 방학중·정만서·김선달을 중심으로 / 박사 / 서울대학교 대학원

[journal] 신동흔 / 1989 / 신분갈등 설화의 공간구성과 주제 / 관악어문연구 / 서울대학교 국어국문학과 14 : 103~128

[journal] 신동흔 / 1995 / 가면극 양반마당과 꾀쟁이하인 설화의 비교 / 한국극예술연구 / 한국극예술학회 2 : 7~31

[journal] 신연우 / 2003 / The social and mythic reflections on the folktale <The servant who deceived his master> / 한국민속학 / 한국민속학회 37 : 109~128

[journal] Babcock-Abrahams, Barbara / 1975 / ‘A Tolerated Margin of Mess’: The Trickster and His Tales Reconsidered / Journal of the Folklore Institute 11(3) : 147~186

[journal] Beidelman, T. O. / 1980 / The Moral Imagination of the Kagaru: Some Thoughts on Tricksters, Translation and Comparative Analysis / American Ethnologist 7(1) : 27~42

[journal] Boas, Franz / 1914 / Mythology and Folk-Tales of the North American Indians / Journal of American Folklore 27(106) : 374~410

[book] Doueihi, Anne / 1993 / Mythical Trickster Figures: Contours, Contexts, and Criticisms / University of Alabama Press : 193~201

[book] Karl Kerényi / 1956 / The Trickster: A Study in American Indian Mythology / Schocken Books : 171~191

[journal] Klapp, Orrin / 1949 / The Folk Hero / Journal of American Folklore 62(243) : 17~25

[journal] Klapp, Orrin / 1954 / The Clever Hero / Journal of American Folklore 67(263) : 21~24

KJC Korea
Journal Central

Statistics

Tools

Sharing

Issue List

Citation status