Understanding Quranic Jesus Based on Its Narrative on Crucifixion

Ah Young Kim

doi:10.30532/mce.2018.11.2.9

Did Jesus die on the cross and then rise from the dead? This question has generated vigorous discussion between Muslims and Christians for more than fourteen centuries. The long history of Christian-Muslim encounter has seen Christology as a primary issue of controversy, often the subject of acrimonious debate, rarely productive of interreligious understanding. Aware of this, some scholars from both religions argue that Christology should be put aside because Islamic meanings of Christ are quite different from those of Christian theological confession: There can be nothing theologically agreed upon on this matter, they argue, because Islam rules out any incursion of the human into the sphere of the divine. While the Quran elevates Jesus above other mortals, he remains no more than“a subject of the history of prophets”by which God guided humankind until revelation was sealed by the final prophet, Muhammad. Christians and Muslims have differed sharply especially over the question of whether Jesus Christ died on the cross; Christians affirm that he did and Muslims insist on the basis of the prevailing interpretations of Quran 4:157-158, that he did not. The Quran indisputably denies the core of Christian doctrine, that is, death at crucifixion. In other terms, God’s prophet could not be killed by human beings. The Quran clearly speaks on the people’s intention to kill Jesus, only to fail because of God’s intervention. However, discussions and analyses show what a rich and diverse range of answers to this question have historically been seen as legitimately supported within the Muslim community. I believe that there can be room to find common ground regarding the reason why crucifixion had to historically occur, especially based on the understanding on the human condition. The crucifixion represents an urgent and ongoing call – addressed to Christians and Muslims alike - to faith in the divine power which redeems, transforms and delivers through suffering love; and only through this faith, we can overcome evil with good.

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (2)
열림/닫힘 버튼
REFERENCES (18)
열림/닫힘 버튼
* 2021년 이후 발행 논문의 참고문헌은 현재 구축 중입니다.

[confproc] 손주영 / 1992 / 이슬람 전통에서 보는 그리스도-꾸란 속에 예수를 중심으로 / 한국 이슬람 연구소 특강 강의안

[other] Ata Ur-Rahim, Muhammad / 1980 / Jesus, A Prophet of Islam Karachi Begum Aisha Bawany Waqf

[book] Balic, Smail / 1979 / The Image of Jesus in Contemporary Islamic Theology / Seabury Press

[book] Cragg, Kenneth / 1985 / The Call of the Minaret / Daystar Press

[book] Cragg, Kenneth / 1985 / Jesus and the Muslim / George Allen &Unwin

[book] Cumming, Joseph L / 2005 / Muslims and Christian: Reflections on Peace: Divine and Human Dimensions / University Press of America

[book] Glaser, Ida / 2017 / Cross, Qiblah and Glory: What Should Direct Christian Responses to Islam? / Torch Trinity Center for Islamic Studies : 10~53

[confproc] Jones, Richard J / 1980 / Wilfred Cantwell Smith and Kenneth Cragg on Islam as a Way of Salvation / IBMR / Uzima Press Ltd

[book] Kerr, David / 1993 / Christology in Dialogue Cleveland / The Pilgrim Press

[journal] Kuites, Roelf S / 1992 / Christology in the Quran / Missiology : An International Review (3)

[book] Lawson, Todd / 2009 / The Crucifixion and the Quran : A Study in the History of Muslim Thought / One World Publications

[book] Moucarry, Chawkat / 2001 / The Prophet and the Messiah Downers Grove / InterVarsity Press

[journal] al-Nowaihi, Muhamed / 1976 / The Religion of Islam / International Review of Missions

[book] Nasr, Seyyed Hossein / 2015 / The Study Quran: A New Translation and Commentary / Harper Collins Publishers

[book] Parrinder, Geoffrey / 1996 / Jesus in the Quran / One World

[book] Robinson, Neal / 1991 / Christ in Islam and Christianity / McMillan Press

[book] Roberts, Nancy / 2013 / Islam-Christian-Muslim Relations / Routledge

[book] Zafrulla Khan, Muhammad / 1978 / Deliverance from the Cross / The London Mosque

KJC Korea
Journal Central

Statistics

Tools

Sharing

Issue List

Citation status