A Preliminary Study on the Ethnic Identities of the Karen People in Myanmar

김인아

doi:10.22801/svn.2010.2.2.29

The diversity of Southeast Asia can be also represented at the tremendous number of ethnic groups residing throughout its various regions even beyond national boundaries. What does it mean by the composite of numerous peoples? It has triggered a lot of problems in a nation or overall Southeast Asia. Among them, the most serious one seems to be ethnic conflicts having damaged national integration and caused political, economical, and social instability. In that respect, Karen people have been a minority group situated in the most chronic dispute in Myanmar. Since 1947 some of the Karen equipped with armed forces have been fighting against the military government currently ruling Myanmar. As the result, the refugees over 200,000 population had moved to the mountain camps located at neighboring Thailand, attracting a lot of attention throughout international societies. According to 1931 census by British colonial government, the Karen have the greatest numbers in population as minority and include 16 subgroups including Karenni(Kayah) and Pa-O seemingly excluded from its category in contemporary point of view. It means that Karen people should not be regarded as an ethnic group, and in fact do not show a homogeneous identity under the title of Karen. Given the situation, we need to reconsider the category of Karen. What does the Karen mean in a real sense? Previous studies on the Karen had been performed mainly by anthropologists or missionaries such as Marshall(1922), Hamilton (1976), Hanson Tadaw(1959), Smeaton(1920), Keyes(1979), Hayami (1992; 2004), etc. Most of them examined the Karen as a group and ignored the possibilities of representing the divergent identities vis-à-vis their subgroups. Therefore, they have focused on the myth to convert Karen people to Christianity, although the Christian Karens are less than 20% of total population. As a result, I argue that they would fail to define the real meaning of Karen. It has been caused us to recognize the Karen as a meaningless total entity to be accepted by all means. According to their arguments, the difference among Karen's subgroups is just dealt with the trivial matters that do not affect the ethnic boundary itself, still maintaining the ethnic identity as Karen. As we shall see on this thesis, this is never the case. My thesis aims at uncovering and scrutinizing the real meaning of the category of Karen. For the purpose of it, I will consider Karen people as a linguistic group from the beginning as shown in 1931 census. I argue that the Karen have been affected or exposed by various conditions or environments throughout the harsh history having happened on the areas of current Myanmar and Thailand, leading the vicissitudes of their ethnic identities.

Citation status

KCI Citation Counts (0)
REFERENCES (27)
열림/닫힘 버튼
* 2021년 이후 발행 논문의 참고문헌은 현재 구축 중입니다.

[journal] 박장식 / 1995 / 미얀마 까렌족의 분리주의 운동 / 동남아연구 4 : 255~282

[journal] 이상국 / 2008 / Migrants, Illegality and a Border Social System: A Study of a Border Social System in the Thailand-Myanmar Borderland / 동남아시아연구 / 한국동남아학회 18(1) : 109~150 / 10.21652/kaseas.18.1.200802.109

[book] Adas, Michael / 1941 / The Burma Delta: Economic Development and Social Change on the Asian Rice Frontier / Wisconsin University Press

[journal] Baldwin, J. W / 1949 / The Karens in Burma / Journal of the Royal Central Asian Society 34 : 102~113

[book] Benedict, Paul K / 1972 / Sino-Tibetan: A Conspectus / Cambridge University Press : 127~

[book] Bennison, J. J / 1933 / Census of India, 1931. Vol Ⅺ (Burma Part Ⅰ-Report) / Govt. Printing and Stationery

[book] Boucaud, Andre / 1988 / Burma's Golden Triangle: On the Trail of the Opium Warlords / Asia 2000

[journal] Brailey, Nigel J / 1970 / A Re-Investigation of the Gwe of 18th Century Burma / Journal of Southeast Asian Studies 1(2) : 33~47

[book] Cady, John F. / 1958 / A History of Modern Burma / Cornell University Press

[book] Durkheim, Emile / 2001 / The Elementary Forms of the Religious Life / Oxford University Press

[book] Furnivall, J. S. / 1956 / Colonial Policy and Practice: A Comparative Study of Burma and Netherlands India / New York University Press

[book] Gravers, Mikael / 2007 / Exploring Ethnic Diversity in Burma / Nanas Press

[book] Hall, D. G. E. / 1968 / History of South East Asia / Macmillan

[book] Hamilton, James W / 1976 / Pwo Karen: At the Edge of Mountain and Plain / West Publishing

[book] Keenan, Paul / 2008 / Saw Ba U Gyi: Voice of the Revolution / Karen History and Culture Preservation Society

[web] / http://www.burmalibrary.org/docskaren/Karen%20Heritage%20Web/pdf/Voice%20of%20the%20Revolution_1_Saw%20Ba%20U%20Gyi.pdf / http://www.burmalibrary.org/docskaren/Karen%20Heritage%20Web/pdf/Voice%20of%20the%20Revolution_1_Saw%20Ba%20U%20Gyi.pdf

[book] Keyes, Charles F / 1977 / The Golden Peninsula / MacMillan Publishing

[book] Keyes, Charles F / 1979 / Ethnic Adaptation and Identity: The Karen on the Thai Frontier with Burma / Institute for the Study of Human Issues

[book] LeBar, F. M / 1964 / Ethnic Groups of Mainland Southeast Asia / Human Relations Area File

[book] Linter, Bertil / 1948 / Burma in Revolt: Opium and Insurgency Since 1948 / Westview Press

[book] Marshall, Harry I / 1922 / The Karen People of Burma: A Study in Anthropology and Ethnology / Ohio State University

[book] Min Naung, U / 2000 / National Ethnic Groups of Myanmar / Thein Myint Win Press

[other] / 1929 / Selected Correspondence for the Years 1825-26 to 1842-43 in the Office of the Commissioner Tenasserim Division / Government Printing and Stationery

[book] Smith, Martin / 1991 / Burma: Insurgency and the Politics of Ethnicity / Zed Books

[book] Smith, Martin / 1994 / Ethnic Groups in Burma: Development, Democracy and Human Rights / Anti-Slave International

[book] Symes, Michael / 1800 / An Account of an Embassy to the Kingdom of Ava, Sent by the Governor-General of India, in the Year 1795 / W. Bulmer and Co

[web] TBBC / 2007 / Internal Displacement in Eastern Burma: 2007 Survey / http://www.tbbc.org

KJC Korea
Journal Central

Statistics

Tools

Sharing

Issue List

Citation status