Electrolyzed water has been proven to have antibacterial effects against various microorganisms. However, there are only a few studies about effects of electrolyzed water on oral bacteria. The purpose of this study was to examine the antibacterial effect of electrolyzed water on Streptococcus mutans in vitro.
Methods:
S. mutans KCOM 1054 was treated with electrolyzed water for 1 or 3 minutes and plated on Mitis Salivarius agar with 15% sucrose and bacitracin. After incubation for 48 hours, colony forming units (CFU) were counted, and dental plaque was quantified by crystal violet staining.
Results:
The growth of S. mutans was significantly inhibited by electrolyzed water (p<0.001). In addition, the dental plaque formation by S. mutans was decreased in a time-dependent manner by exposure to electrolyzed water (p<0.001).
Conclusions:
Our results suggest that electrolyzed water can effectively prevent dental caries by inhibiting growth of (and the formation of dental plaque by) S. mutans.
연구목적:
본 연구는 대표적인 치아우식 유발 세균인 Streptococcus mutans(S. mutans)에 대한 전기분해 수소수의 항균효과와 치면세균막 억제 효과를 평가하기 위해 실시하였다.
연구방법:
BHI 액체배지 상에서 6시간 배양한 S. mutans를 전기분해수소수에 1분 또는 3분 노출시켰다. 전기분해수소수의 증식억제 효과를 확인하기 위해 균주 현탁액을 Mitis Salivarius agar bacitracin(MSB) 배지 상에서 48시간 배양한 후 집락수를 계수하였으며, biofilm formation assay에 따라 crystal violet solution을 30분간 처리하여 치면세균막을 염색하고, 600 nm의 파장에서 흡광도를 측정하여 치면세균막 형성정도를 평가하였다.
연구결과:
전기분해수소수는 S. mutans의 증식과 치면세균막 형성을 유의하게 억제하였으며(p<0.001), 특히 치면세균막 형성의 경우 노출 시간이 증가함에 따라 치면세균막 형성도 유의하게 감소하였다(p<0.05).
결론:
수돗물 전기분해수소수는 S. mutans의 증식과 치면세균막 형성 억제를 통해 치아우식을 효과적으로 예방할 수 있다고 판단된다.
Dental caries is a chronic disorder caused by plaque accumulation that leads to irreversible tooth damage and loss [1]. Despite its decreasing incidence, dental caries remains an oral disease with the highest prevalence rate across all age groups [2,3]. Bacterial, host, and diet factors contribute to dental caries [4]. Of these, bacteria are the most prominent cause of dental caries [5]. Bacteria attach to tooth surfaces, where they proliferate and aggregate to form dental plaque. Organic acids from carbohydrates retained in dental plaque induce demineralization and consequently dental caries in the long term [5,6].
Over 700 bacterial strains contribute to dental plaque formation [7]. Streptococcus mutans is known to be the most cariogenic causal factor of dental plaque [8,9]. S. mutans produces highly concentrated organic acids thereby directly inducing tooth demineralization and playing a crucial role in dental plaque formation because S. mutans forms viscous polysaccharides such as glucan [10,11]. Therefore, preventing and eliminating dental plaque by inhibiting S. mutans proliferation is crucial for preventing dental caries [12].
Toothbrushing and flossing are the most basic methods for manual removal of dental plaque and preventing dental caries [13,14]. If not performed correctly, toothbrushing may fail to effectively remove dental plaque [15]. Furthermore, the anatomical characteristics of tooth pits and fissures make it difficult for bristles of a toothbrush to reach the occlusal and buccolingual surfaces [16]. To overcome this limitation, toothpaste or mouthwash products containing antimicrobial agents that inhibit bacterial growth and colonization have been used. However, these products contain large amounts of synthetic chemicals that can induce side effects such as tooth discoloration, a burning sensation, and dry mouth [17-19]. There is a growing need for safe antimicrobial agents that effectively remove oral bacteria.
Major antimicrobial substances include natural substances such as xylitol, mastic, and essential oils [20]. Active research is being conducted on electrolyzed water produced by electrolyzing water after its stability and antimicrobial effect were recently verified [21-23]. Electrolyzed water is produced by passing an electric current through water and contains over 300 ppb dissolved hydrogen [24]. Physical and chemical properties of electrolyzed water depend on the type of metal electrode used and ions added and on whether a membrane was used during electrolysis [25]. Although the efficacy of electrolyzed water depends on its physical and chemical properties, it is reported that electrolyzed water has anticancer, antioxidative, and antimicrobial effects [23,26,27]. Electrolyzed water has fewer side effects as compared to synthetic chemicals and is simpler and cheaper to use as compared to natural substances. This study was aimed at demonstrating the inhibitory effect of electrolyzed water on S. mutans proliferation and dental plaque formation and at obtaining basic data that can be used to develop oral supplements for preventing dental caries.
Methods1. Methods1) Bacterial culture
Freeze-dried S. mutans KCOM 1045 obtained from the Korean Collection for Oral Microbiology was inoculated on a Mitis Salivarius-Bacitracin (MSB) agar plate (Mitis Salivarius Agar, Difco Laboratories, MD, USA) containing 15% of sucrose (Duksan, Korea) and 0.2 U/mL bacitracin (Sigma Chemical, MO, USA) and cultured at 37℃ in a 5% CO2 incubator (Sanyo, Japan) for 48 hours. One of the several S. mutans colonies that formed on the MSB agar plate was inoculated into brain heart infusion (BHI, Difco Laboratories, MI, USA) broth and cultured for 24 hours under the same conditions. The cultured bacteria were then subcultured and used in the experiment.
2) Electrolyzed-water preparation
500 mL of 20℃ tap water was processed in Natural Gargle Plus (EBIOMW-100, Ebioteco, Korea) for 1 minute to produce neutral electrolyzed water (1.2–1.3 ppm dissolved hydrogen, oxidation-reduction potential of 500 mV, and pH 7.2). The electrolyzed water was filtered using a 0.2 μm syringe filter (Minisart, Sartorius Stedim, Germany) and used in the experiment.
3) Treatment with electrolyzed water
S. mutans cultured in BHI broth for 6 hours was centrifuged at 4℃ and 7,500 rpm for 15 minutes to precipitate the bacterial cells. After removal of the supernatant, the bacterial pellet was washed twice with 5 mL of phosphate-buffered saline (PBS), and 5 mL of electrolyzed water was added to the pellet. 45 mL of PBS was added immediately after exposing the sediment to electrolyzed water for 1 (group EW1) or 3 minutes (EW3). The solution was then centrifuged at 7,500 rpm for 15 minutes and evenly resuspended on 50 mL of BHI broth. Tap water (TW) was used as the negative control, and Listerine (Listerine, Korea Johnson & Johnson, Korea) was used as the positive control.
4) Analysis of <italic>S. mutans</italic> proliferation
The S. mutans suspension exposed to electrolyzed water was serially diluted 10-fold down to 1:10−7; 150 μL of the suspension was inoculated on MSB agar. Colonies were counted after 48 hours of incubation. The experiment was repeated three times.
5) Analysis of dental plaque formation by <italic>S. mutans</italic>
Dental plaque formation induced by S. mutans was analyzed using O’Toole’s dental plaque formation assay [28]. First, each well of a six-well polystyrene plate was coated with artificial saliva (Xerova solution, Kolmar Korea, Korea) and inoculated with 2 mL of the S. mutans suspension exposed to electrolyzed water. The plate was then incubated for 24 hours. The supernatant was removed from each well, and the wells were washed 3 times with 2 mL of PBS to remove any remnant bacteria from the plate. Each well was treated with 1 mL of 0.2% crystal violet solution for 30 minutes to stain the dental plaque. The plate was washed five times with PBS and treated with 10% acetic acid to extract the dye; 200 μL of the extracted dye was added into each well of a 96-well plate, and optical density was measured at 570 nm (OD570) (ELISA, ASYS, Austria). The experiment was repeated three times.
2. Statistical analysis
Obtained data were analyzed using IBM SPSS (IBM 25.0 for Windows, SPSS Inc, Chicago, IL, USA) with the level of statistical significance at 5%. Since the data did not show a normal distribution in the Shapiro–Wilk test, all data were analyzed using nonparametric tests. The results regarding S. mutans proliferation and dental plaque formation following the treatment with electrolyzed water were analyzed using the Kruskal–Wallis test in addition to Wilcoxon’s rank sum test for post hoc analysis. The level of statistical significance was corrected using the Bonferroni test during the post hoc analysis.
Results1. Effect of electrolyzed water on <italic>S. mutans</italic> proliferation
MSB agar plates were grossly examined to compare the extent of S. mutans colony formation. Colony formation was clearly reduced for S. mutans exposed to electrolyzed water as compared to that exposed to tap water. No clear difference in the extent of colony formation was observed between the exposure time points (1 or 3 minutes) <Fig. 1>.
Identification of the number of <italic>S. mutans</italic> processed for electrolyzed water in 15% sucrose MSB agar plate (A) Tap water, (B) 1 min treatment of electrolyzed water, (C) 3 min treatment of electrolyzed water, (D) Listerin
The actual count of S. mutans colonies exposed to tap water was 2.43×109 ±1.57×109 and that of S. mutans exposed to electrolyzed water was 3.00×107±1.16×107 after 1 minute of exposure and 4.70×107±1.08×107 after 3 minutes of exposure. The colony count was significantly lower for S. mutans exposed to electrolyzed water as compared to that exposed to tap water (p<0.001). However, no significant difference in the colony count was found between exposure time points (p>0.05). In the Listerine group (positive control), the colony count was 4.00×106 ±2.41×106, which was significantly lower than the colony counts in all other groups (p<0.05) <Table 1>.
Antibacterial effect of electrolyzed water on <italic>S. mutans</italic>
Unit: Mean±SD
Group
Colony forming unit (CFU)
Tap water
2.43×109 ± 1.57×109a
1 min treatment of electrolyzed water
3.00×107 ± 1.16×107b
3 min treatment of electrolyzed water
4.70×107 ± 1.08×107b
Listerin
4.00×106 ± 2.41×106c
p*
<0.001
*by Kruskal-Wallis test
a,b,cSame letter means there is no significant difference by Bonferroni-corrected Wilcoxon’s rank sum test (p>0.05)
2. Inhibitory effect of electrolyzed water on dental plaque formation by <italic>S. mutans</italic>
The amount of dental plaque formed by S. mutans was analyzed using the dental plaque formation assay. The amount of dental plaque was 0.79±0.02 for group after tap water exposure, 0.38±0.01 after 1 minute of exposure, and 0.13±0.00 for after 3 minutes of exposure. S. mutans exposed to electrolyzed water formed significantly less dental plaque as compared to S. mutans exposed to tap water (p<0.05). Additionally, dental plaque formation significantly decreased as exposure time increased from 1 to 3 minutes (p<0.05). S. mutans treated with Listerine (positive control) showed significantly reduced dental plaque formation compared to all other groups (p<0.05) <Table 2>.
Inhibition effect of electrolyzed water on Biofilm formation in <italic>S. mutans</italic>
Unit: Mean±SD
Group
OD570
Tap water
0.79 ± 0.02a
1 min treatment of electrolyzed water
0.38 ± 0.01b
3 min treatment of electrolyzed water
0.13 ± 0.00c
Listerin
0.05 ± 0.00d
p*
< 0.001
*by Kruskal-Wallis test
a,b,c,dSame letter means there is no significant difference by Bonferroni-corrected Wilcoxon’s rank sum test (p>0.05)
Discussion
While the antimicrobial effect of electrolyzed water against various microorganisms is being verified through research and electrolyzed water is being used in various fields for its antimicrobial effect, research on its effect on oral bacteria is lacking. This study was aimed at assessing the effect of electrolyzed water-produced by membraneless electrolysis of tap water-on S. mutans to determine whether it could be used to prevent dental caries.
In the analysis of the effect of electrolyzed water on S. mutans proliferation, electrolyzed water significantly inhibited S. mutans proliferation as compared to tap water. This result is consistent with previous studies reporting that electrolyzed water has antimicrobial effects against various bacterial strains [22,23]. Lee and Choi [23] cultured five strains of periodontal bacteria on plate media after exposing them to electrolyzed water and observed a clear reduction in bacterial proliferation as was also observed in this study. Additionally, they reported a significant reduction in the number of bacteria in the saliva of subjects who rinsed their mouth with electrolyzed water. Lee [22] observed significant inhibition of S. mutans and S. sobrinus growth following 30 seconds or 1 minute of exposure to electrolyzed water. The electrolyzed water used by Lee contained NaCl. Numerous studies that reported electrolyzed water to have potent antimicrobial effects used electrolyzed water containing a small amount of NaCl. Electrolyzed water containing NaCl has an excellent antimicrobial effect because it is highly acidic, has high oxidation-reduction potential, and contains high concentrations of hypochlorous acid and free chlorine [29]. Although the electrolyzed water used in this study was neutral hydrogen water produced by electrolyzing pure tap water, it clearly inhibited S. mutans proliferation. Although the electrolyzed water was not as effective as Listerine (used as the positive control) in inhibiting bacterial growth, its antimicrobial effect can be improved by increasing electrolysis duration and intensity according to Nakajima et al. [30]. Nakajima et al. [30] reported that the antimicrobial effect of tap water contaminated with four strains of gram-positive and negative bacteria increased as electrolysis time and intensity increased. Since free chlorine is responsible for the antimicrobial effect of electrolyzed water without NaCl, the antimicrobial effect of electrolyzed water can be enhanced by increasing electrolysis time to increase the concentration of free chlorine [30]. Electrolyzed water produced with appropriate electrolysis duration and intensity may effectively inhibit S. mutans proliferation without the addition of NaCl.
While the reduction in the S. mutans count is meaningful progress towards dental caries prevention, even a small population of remaining S. mutans can significantly contribute to the development and progression of dental caries since S. mutans is highly pathogenic. Dental plaque that forms on top of the viscous polysaccharides produced by S. mutans protects bacteria and free acids, thereby accelerating tooth demineralization; for this reason, inhibiting dental plaque formation is highly important for preventing dental caries [10-12].
In this study, electrolyzed water effectively inhibited S. mutans proliferation and dental plaque formation. This result is consistent with a study by Kim et al. [21] who reported exposure time-dependent inhibition of dental plaque formation by S. mutans and S. sobrinus as well as clear downregulation of the gtf and gbpC genes involved in dental plaque formation. Since genetic analysis was not performed in the present study unlike the study by Kim et al. [21], the possibility that the observed inhibition of dental plaque formation was simply due to the reduction in the S. mutans count cannot be ruled out. Additionally, this study has the inherent limitations of laboratory research. Although the mechanism of the antimicrobial and antiplaque effects of electrolyzed water could not be thoroughly elucidated due to these limitations, the results of previous studies [21-23,29,30] and the present study suggest that the free chlorine produced during the electrolysis of tap water destroys bacterial cell membranes and induces the aggregation of intracytoplasmic proteins thus inhibiting bacterial growth. Additionally, the hydrogen molecules that pass through the cellular membrane inhibit the expression of genes associated with dental plaque formation thereby inhibiting dental plaque formation.
Although this study does not elucidate the mechanism by which electrolyzed water prevents dental caries, it demonstrated that electrolyzed water produced from pure tap water can inhibit S. mutans proliferation and dental plaque formation, confirming the suitability of electrolyzed water as an oral care product. Unlike existing oral care products, electrolyzed water has no side effects, is easy to prepare, and is practical. With further research elucidating the anticaries mechanism of electrolyzed water using various laboratory techniques including genetic analysis and assessing the anticaries effect of electrolyzed water in clinical settings, electrolyzed water may be employed to develop an excellent anticaries agent to be used by those struggling with oral care.
Conclusions
In this study, S. mutans, a major causal bacterial pathogen of dental caries, was treated with electrolyzed water produced via membraneless electrolysis of tap water, and the following results were obtained.
1. Electrolyzed water significantly inhibited S. mutans proliferation (p<0.001).
2. Electrolyzed water inhibited dental plaque formation by S. mutans (p<0.001). Dental plaque formation was significantly more inhibited as the duration of exposure to electrolyzed water increased (p<0.05).
These results demonstrate that electrolyzed tap water can effectively prevent dental caries by inhibiting S. mutans proliferation and dental plaque formation by S. mutans.
Conflicts of Interest The authors declared no conflict of interest.
Authorship Conceptualization: JH Kim, HY Youn, EK Kim, KB Song; Data collection: JH Kim, HY Youn; Formal analysis: JH Kim, HY Youn; Writing - original draft: JH Kim; Writing - review & editing: JH Kim, HY Youn, EK Kim, YE Lee, JE Jang, KB Song
SelwitzRHIsmailAIPittsNBDental cariesLancet2007369515910.1016/0140-6736(07)60031-2KimJBPaikDIMoonHSMaDSA study on the percentage of extraction required by causes in KoreaJ Korean Acad Dent Health199519172810.5933/JKAPD.2018.45.4.407Ministry of Health and WelfareKorea Health Statistics 2019: Korea National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (KNHANES Ⅷ-1)Ministry of Health and WelfareChungcheongbuk-do2019206208DruckerDBThe role of sugar in the aetiology of dental caries. 4. The microbiological evidenceJ Dent19831120520710.1016/0300-5712(83)90185-9MarshPDMicrobiological aspects of the chemical control of plaque and gingivitisJ Dent Res1992711431143810.1177/00220345920710071501HouteJ vanRole of micro-organisms in caries etiologyJ Dent Res19947367268110.1177/00220345940730031301ZijngeVvan LeeuwenMBDegenerJEAbbasFThurnheerTGmürRet al.Oral biofilm architecture on natural teethPloS one2010245e932110.1371/journal.pone.0009321ZuccaMCennaSBerzioliSGariglioMFagnoniVStreptococcus mutans and dental caries: microbiological aspectsG Batteriol Virol Immunol199083108117LoescheWJRowanJStraffonLHLoosPJAssociation of Streptococcus mutans with human dental decayInfect Immun19751133233510.1128/iai.11.6.1252-1260.1975HamadaSSladeHDBiology, immunology, and cariogenicity of Streptococcus mutansMicrobiol Rev19804433138410.1128/mr.44.2.331-384.1980NapimogaMHHöflingJFKleinMIKamiyaRUGonçalvesRBTransmission, diversity and virulence factors of Streptococcus mutans genotypesJ Oral Sci200547596410.2334/josnusd.47.59BrinerWWPalque in relation to dental caries and periodontal diseaseInt Dent J197121293301JacksonRJNewmanHNSmartGJStokesEHoganJIBrownCet al.The effects of a supervised toothbrushing programme on the caries increment of primary school children, initially aged 5-6 yearsCaries Res20053910811510.1159/000083155WaerhaugJEffect of tooth brushing on subgingival plaque formationJ Periodontol198152303410.1902/jop.1981.52.1.30BarnettMLThe role of therapeutic antimicrobial mouthrinses in clinical practice: control of supragingival plaque and gingivitisJ Am Dent Assoc200313469970410.14219/jada.archive.2003.0255NewbrunECariology: Occlusal sealants3rd ed.QuintessenceChicago1989315FahimipourAKBen MamaarSMcFarlandAGBlausteinRAChenJGlaweAJet al.Antimicrobial chemicals associate with microbial function and antibiotic resistance indoorsmSystems2018320021810.1128/mSystems.00200-18SreenivasanPKGaffarAAntibacterials as anti-inflammatory agents: dual action agents for oral healthAntonie Van Leeuwenhoek20089322723910.1007/s10482-007-9197-8CiancioSGAgents for the management of plaque and gingivitisJ Clin Periodontol19989313310.1111/j.1600-051x.1998.tb02360.xPalomboEATraditional medicinal plant extracts and natural products with activity against oral bacteria: potential application in the prevention and treatment of oral diseaseEvid Based Complement Alternat Med2011201111510.1155/2021/6633845KimJKLeeHJHongSHInhibition of streptococcal biofilm by hydrogen waterJ Dent201758343910.1016/j.jdent.2017.01.004LeeKANeutral electrolyzed water for prevention of dental careisJ Korean Acad Pediatr Dent20164330631210.5933/JKAPD.2016.43.3.306LeeSHChoiBKAntibacterial effect of electrolyzed water on oral bacteriaJ Microbiol200644417422KimSGImDSHydrogen is the answerSang SangnamuGyeonggi-do20152456HricovaDStephanRZweifelCElectrolyzed water and its application in the food industryJ Food Prot2008711934194710.4315/0362-028X-71.9.1934KatoSSaitohYIwaiKMiwaNHydrogen-rich electrolyzed warm water represses wrinkle formation against UVA ray together with type-I collagen production and oxidative-stress diminishment in fibroblasts and cell-injury prevention in keratinocytesJ Photochem Photobiol B2012106243310.1016/j.jphotobiol.2011.09.006YeJLiYHamasakiTNakamichiNKomatsuTKashiwagiTet al.Inhibitory effect of electrolyzed reduced water on tumor angiogenesisBio Pharm Bull200831192610.1248/bpb.31.19O’TooleGAMicrotiter dish biofilm formation assayJ Vis Exp2011472437NakagawaraSGotoTNaraMOzawaYHottaKArataYSpectroscopic characterization and the pH dependence of bactericidal activity of the aqueous chlorine solutionAnal Sci19981469169810.2116/analsci.14.691NakajimaNNakanoTHaradaFTaniguchiHYokoyamaIHiroseJet al.Evaluation of disinfective potential of reactivated free chlorine in pooled tap water by electrolysisJ Microbiol Methods20045716317310.1016/j.mimet.2003.12.011