Journal of the Korean Society for Information Management 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 1.31
-
pISSN : 1013-0799 / eISSN : 2586-2073
- https://journal.kci.go.kr/kosim
KJCKorea
Journal Central
A Study on the Citation Behavior by Academic Background of Researchers
- Journal of the Korean Society for Information Management
- Abbr : JKOSIM
- 2016, 33(1), pp.247~268
- DOI : 10.3743/KOSIM.2016.33.1.247
- Publisher : 한국정보관리학회
- Research Area : Interdisciplinary Studies > Library and Information Science
- Received : March 2, 2016
- Accepted : March 17, 2016
- Published : March 30, 2016
OH YUJIN 1, Hyo-Jung Oh 1, Kim Chonghyuck 1, Yong Kim 1
1전북대학교
Accredited
ABSTRACT
Although it has been a long subject of study why researchers prefer some cited documents to others, the existing relative researches have had a variety of perspectives on the nature and complexity of the citation behavior and not provided a complete answer to this question. In particular, Korea researchers mainly used statistical analysis of bibliographic information, which has limitations in revealing dynamic and complex cognitive aspects of the citation process. In this study, I investigate the citer perception of citing motives and bibliographic factors through survey and compared the responses according to the researchers’ characteristics. After extracting the 22 motivations and 21 factors through the literature analysis and configuring a 5-point Likert scale questions, I conducted a survey in the wat of an e-mail attachment. From the SPSS 22.0, the frequency analysis, t-test, and one-way ANOVA were performed on the 354 valid samples. As a result, it is found that supporting is considered the most important citing motive and social connection, self-citation have little influence. In the case of bibliographic factors, the journal’s reputation was recognized the most influential factor and the number of pages and authors was the least. Significant differences in fields of study and research careers were showed in some parts. These results can substantiate earlier studies, determine whether the factors assumed influential in selecting references were intended, and suggest the search point to the specialty library or academic database.
Statistics
-
318 Viewed
-
60 Downloaded
Tools
Issue List
Citation status
* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.
[journal]
Abt, H. A.
/ 1993
/ Institutional productivities
/ Publications of the Astronomical Society of the Pacific
105
: 794~798
[journal]
Ahmed, T.
/ 2004
/ Highly cited old papers and the reasons why they continue to be cited: Part II., The 1953 Watson and Crick article on the structure of DNA
/ Scientometrics
61(2)
: 147~156
[journal]
Baldi, S.
/ 1998
/ Normative versus social constructivist processes in the allocation of citations: a network-analytic model
/ American Sociological Review
63(6)
: 829~846
[journal]
Baird, L. M.
/ 1994
/ Do citations matter?
/ Journal of Information Science
20(1)
: 2~15
[journal]
Beaver, D. B.
/ 2004
/ Does collaborative research have greater epistemic authority?
/ Scientometrics
60(3)
: 399~408
[journal]
Brooks, T. A.
/ 1985
/ Private acts and public objects: an investigation of citer motivations
/ Journal of the American Society for Information Science
36(4)
: 223~229
[journal]
Brooks, T. A.
/ 1986
/ Evidence of complex citer motivations
/ Journal of the American Society for Information Science
37(1)
: 34~36
[journal]
Bornmann, L.
/ 2008
/ What do citation counts measure? A review of studies on citing behavior
/ Journal of Documentation
64(1)
: 45~80
[journal]
Burrell, Q. L.
/ 2003
/ Predicting future citation behavior
/ Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology
54(5)
: 372~378
[journal]
Camacho-Miñano, M.
/ 2009
/ The multilayered nature of reference selection
/ Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology
60(4)
: 754~777
[journal]
Cano, V.
/ 1989
/ Citation behavior: classification, utility, and location
/ Journal of the American Society for Information Science
40(4)
: 284~290
[journal]
최선희
/ 2011
/
A Study of Citing Patterns of Korean Scientists on Korean Journals
/ 정보관리학회지
/ 한국정보관리학회
28(2)
: 97~115
[journal]
Chubin, D. E.
/ 1975
/ Content analysis of references: Adjunct or alternative to citation counting?
/ Social Studies of Science
5(4)
: 423~441
[book]
Cole, S.
/ 1975
/ The idea of social structure: Papers in honor of Robert K. Merton
/ Harcourt Brace Jovanovich
: 175~220
[journal]
Cronin, B.
/ 1981
/ Agreement and divergence on referencing practice
/ Journal of Information Science
3(1)
: 27~34
[book]
Cronin, B.
/ 1984
/ The citation process: the role and significance of citations in scientific communication
/ Taylor Graham
[journal]
Cullars, J.
/ 1990
/ Citation characteristics of Italian and Spanish literary monographs
/ Library Quarterly
60(1)
: 337~356
[journal]
Frost, C. O.
/ 1989
/ The literature of online public access catalogs. 1980-85 : An analysis of citation patterns
/ Library Resources and Technical Services
33(4)
: 344~357
[book]
Garfield, E.
/ 1965
/ Statistical association methods for mechanized documentation
/ National Bureau of Standards
: 189~192
[journal]
Garfield, E.
/ 1996
/ When to cite
/ Library Quarterly
66(4)
: 449~458
[journal]
Gilbert, G. N.
/ 1977
/ Referencing as persuasion
/ Social Studies of Science
7(1)
: 113~122
[confproc]
Han, J.
/ 2008
/ Preliminary study on bibliometric citation analysis of the oceanographic journals
/ Proceedings of the 15th Conference of Korean Society for Information Management
: 229~234
[report]
Hanney, S.
/ 2005
/ From bench to bedside: Tracing the payback forwards from basic or early clinical research - a preliminary exercise and proposals for a future study
/ The Health Economics Research Group. Brunel University
[journal]
Harwood, N.
/ 2009
/ Citers’ use of citees’ names: Findings from a qualitative interview-based study
/ Journal of the American Society for Information Science and Technology
59(6)
: 1007~1011
[journal]
Haslam, N.
/ 2008
/ What makes an article influential? Predicting impact in social and personality psychology
/ Scientometrics
76(1)
: 169~185
[journal]
Hooten, P. A.
/ 1991
/ Frequency and functional use of cited documents in information science
/ Journal of the American Society for Information Science
42(6)
: 397~404
[journal]
Hurt, C. D.
/ 1985
/ Methodological citation differences in science, technology and social sciences literature
/ Library and Information Science Research
7(4)
: 345~355
[journal]
Kaplan, N.
/ 1965
/ The norms of citation behavior: Prolegomena to the footnote
/ American Documentation
16(3)
: 179~184
[confproc]
Kim, Byung-kyu
/ 2011
/ A study on adding index terms for improving the retrieval efficiency of the STI database
/ The Korea Contents Society
9(1)
: 293~294
[journal]
김병규
/ 2011
/
Citing Behavior of Korean Scientists on Foreign Journals in KSCD
/ 정보관리학회지
/ 한국정보관리학회
28(2)
: 117~133
[confproc]
Kim, S.
/ 2003
/ A study on citation analysis of design science literature
/ Proceedings of the 10th Conference of Korean Society for Information Management
: 233~244
[journal]
김완종
/ 2012
/
A Study on the Factors Influencing Citation Speed and Citation Frequency of Scientific Articles Using Bibliometric Analysis in South Korea
/ 한국문헌정보학회지
/ 한국문헌정보학회
46(4)
: 285~309
[journal]
Klamer, A.
/ 2002
/ Attention and the art of scientific publishing
/ Journal of Economic Methodology
9(3)
: 289~315
[book]
Latour, B.
/ 1979
/ Laboratory life: the social construction of scientific facts
/ Princeton University Press
[journal]
Lawani, S. M.
/ 1986
/ Some bibliometric correlates of quality in scientific research
/ Scientometrics
9(1)
: 13~25
[journal]
Leimu, R.
/ 2005
/ What determines the citation frequency of ecological papers?
/ Trends in Ecology and Evolution
20(1)
: 28~32
[journal]
Liu, M.
/ 1993
/ A study of citing motivation of Chinese scientists
/ Journal of Information Science
19(1)
: 13~23
[journal]
Liu, M.
/ 1993
/ Progress in documentation - the complexities of citation practice: A review of citation studies
/ Journal of Documentation
49(4)
: 370~408
[journal]
Macroberts, M. H.
/ 1986
/ Quantitative measures of communication in science: a study of the formal level
/ Social Studies of Science
16(1)
: 151~172
[book]
Merton, R. K.
/ 1973
/ The sociology of science: Theoretical and empirical investigations
/ University of Chicago Press
[journal]
Moed, H. F.
/ 2004
/ In basic science the percentage of ‘authoritative’ references decreases as bibliographies become shorter
/ Scientometrics
60(3)
: 295~303
[journal]
Moed, H. F.
/ 1989
/ Possible inaccuracies occurring in citation analysis
/ Journal of Information Science
15(2)
: 95~107
[journal]
Moravcsik, M. J.
/ 1975
/ Some results on the function and quality of citation
/ Social Studies of Science
5(1)
: 86~92
[journal]
남영준
/ 2011
/
Citing Behaviors of Researchers in Korea Civil Engineering
/ 정보관리학회지
/ 한국정보관리학회
28(4)
: 201~220
[journal]
Nicolaisen, J.
/ 2007
/ Citation analysis
/ Annual Review of Information Science and Technology
41(1)
: 609~641
[journal]
Peters, H. P. F.
/ 1994
/ On determinants of citation scores: A case study in chemical engineering
/ Journal of the American Society for Information Science
45(1)
: 39~49
[journal]
Prabha, C. G.
/ 1983
/ Some aspects of citation behavior: A pilot study in business administration
/ Journal of the American Society for Information Science
34(3)
: 202~206
[confproc]
Rabow, H.
/ 2005
/ The discovery of discoveries: Exploring the dissemination of major findings in the life sciences
/ Proceedings of the 10th International Conference of the International Society for Scientometrics and Informetrics
: 322~326
[confproc]
Rousseau, R.
/ 2000
/ Are multi-authored articles cited more than single-authored ones? Are collaborations with authors from other countries more cited than collaborations with in the country? A case study
/ Collaboration in Science and in Technology: Proceedings of the Second Berlin Workshop on Scientometrics and Informetrics
: 173~176
[journal]
Shadish, W. R.
/ 1995
/ Author judgments about works they cite -three studies from psychology journals
/ Social Studies of Science
25(3)
: 477~498
[journal]
Sievert, M. E.
/ 1989
/ An editor’s influence on citation patterns: A case study of Elementary School Journal
/ Journal of the American Society for Information Science
40(5)
: 334~341
[journal]
Snyder, H. W.
/ 1991
/ Motivations for citation: a comparison of self citation and citation to others
/ Scientometrics
21(2)
: 245~254
[journal]
Snyder, H.
/ 1998
/ Patterns of self-citation across disciplines (1980-1989)
/ Journal of Information Science
24(6)
: 431~435
[journal]
Soper, M. E.
/ 1976
/ Characteristics and use of personal collections
/ Library Quarterly
46(4)
: 397~415
[journal]
Stewart, J. A.
/ 1983
/ Achievement and ascriptive processes in the recognition of scientific articles
/ Social Forces
62(1)
: 166~189
[journal]
Sweetland, J. H.
/ 1989
/ Errors in bibliographic citations: A continuing problem
/ Library Quarterly
59(4)
: 291~304
[journal]
van Dalen, H. P.
/ 2005
/ Demographers and their journals: Who remains uncited after ten years?
/ Population and Development Review
30
: 489~506
[journal]
Vinkler, P.
/ 1987
/ A quasi-quantitative citation mode
/ Scientometrics
12(1-2)
: 47~72
[journal]
Wang, P.
/ 1996
/ A qualitative study of scholars’ citation behavior
/ Proceedings of the ASIS Annual Meeting
33
: 255~261
[journal]
Wang, P.
/ 1997
/ A qualitative study of citing behavior: contributions, criteria and metalevel documentation concerns
/ Library Quarterly
67(2)
: 122~154
[journal]
Wang, P.
/ 1999
/ A cognitive model of document use during a research project: Study II. Decisions at the reading and citing stages
/ Journal of the American Society for Information Science
50(2)
: 98~114
[journal]
White, H. D.
/ 2004
/ Citation analysis and discourse analysis revisited
/ Applied Linguistics
25(1)
: 89~116
[journal]
Wuchty, S.
/ 2007
/ The increasing dominance of teams in production of knowledge
/ Science
316(5827)
: 1036~1039
[journal]
윤석경
/ 2007
/
Characteristics of Public Administration Journals by Citation Analysis
/ 한국공공관리학보
/ 한국공공관리학회
21(3)
: 113~139
[journal]
Zuckerman, H.
/ 1987
/ Citation analysis and the complex problem of intellectual influence
/ Scientometrics
12(5-6)
: 329~338