Journal of Regulation Studies 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.78
-
pISSN : 1738-7132
- https://journal.kci.go.kr/ksrs2002
KJCKorea
Journal Central
A Study on the Behavior of Private in the Process of Introducing Regulatory Policy : Focusing on conflicts between taxicab and platform industries in introducing innovative platform taxicab
- Journal of Regulation Studies
- 2020, 29(2), pp.155-195
- DOI : 10.22954/ksrs.2020.29.2.006
- Publisher : 한국규제학회
- Research Area : Social Science > Public Administration
- Received : November 2, 2020
- Accepted : December 14, 2020
- Published : December 31, 2020
1연세대학교
Accredited
ABSTRACT
This study analyzes articles of the press, the minutes of meetings of the National Assembly, reports of the research institute, etc. on the conflicts between smart platform mobility and taxicab industries in the process of introducing a regulatory innovation platform taxicab. it is analyzed for the process based on Quirk's policy conflict model and Wilson's politics of regulation theory.
As a result of applying Quirk's policy conflict model, the smart platform mobility and taxicab industries were involved in the process of regulatory policy, and it was shown behaviors in conflicts and taken strategic conflictual actions. This was a phenomenon caused by the entanglement of interests in benefits, for this reason, this conflict case could be determined as a type of interest group politics based on an analysis using Wilson's politics of regulation model.
Therefore, it would be that the smart platform mobility and taxicab industries had severe conflicts for benefits and costs at the time when the introduction of the regulatory innovation platform taxicab. as a result of this study, it could argue that public managers should perform a role in reducing conflicts between interest groups and also providing conditions for negotiation in the balance of benefits.
Statistics
-
689 Viewed
-
337 Downloaded
Tools
Issue List
Citation status
* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.
[journal]
김근혜
/ 2017
/
An Exploratory Study on the Transition of the Regulation System for the Introduction of the Fourth Industrial Revolution Technology
/ 한국지역정보화학회지
/ 한국지역정보화학회
20(3)
: 59~88
[journal]
김동현
/ 2011
/
Regulatory Policy Design and Policy Change: Case Study of Internet Regulatory Policy Target Groups’ Social Construction
/ 규제연구
/ 한국규제학회
20(2)
: 119~149
[journal]
김이수
/ 2019
/
An Exploratory Study on the Effect of Social Innovation Policy on Social Value as New Policy Types and Policy Mixes: Focusing on the Moderating Effects of Public-Private Collaboration and Government-Supported Management
/ 지방정부연구
/ 한국지방정부학회
23(1)
: 135~160
[journal]
김지현
/ 2019
/
A study on User Experience of Mobility Platform Service -Focused on kakao Taxi and Tada-
/ 디지털융복합연구
/ 한국디지털정책학회
17(7)
: 351~357
[book]
남궁근
/ 2012
/ 정책학: 이론과 경험적 연구
/ 법문사
[journal]
노광호
/ 2018
/
A Comparative Analysis of Conflict Management Cases of the Navy Military Facility: Focusing on the Relocation and Construction of the Naval Base
/ 국방정책연구
/ 한국국방연구원
33(4)
: 105~141
[journal]
박선주
/ 2019
/
Using the Delphi Method to Develop a Regulatory Reform Evaluation Model: Application of a Participatory Evaluation Approach
/ 정책분석평가학회보
/ 한국정책분석평가학회
29(3)
: 55~84
[journal]
손화정
/ 2011
/
Policy Change Analysis on Alternatives for Financial Inequality among Districts in Seoul City: the Application & Usefulness of An Integrated Model
/ 한국정책학회보
/ 한국정책학회
20(4)
: 309~338
[journal]
손화정
/ 2011
/
Analysis of the Failure of Policy Change for the National Security Law under Participatory Government: Application of ACF & PCF
/ 한국행정학보
/ 한국행정학회
45(3)
: 25~50
[journal]
양건모
/ 2007
/
Effect of the Participation of Doctors and Pharmacists in the Policy Process on the Trust in the Ministry of Health & Welfare in Korea
/ 한국행정학보
/ 한국행정학회
41(4)
: 357~385
[journal]
양승일
/ 2006
/
An Analysis on the Regulatory Politics of the Greenbelt Policy
/ 도시행정학보
/ 한국도시행정학회
19(1)
: 75~90
[journal]
양승일
/ 2011
/
An Analysis on the Regulatory Politics regarding Real Estate Policy : Application on Expanded Model of Wilson's Regulatory Politics Theory regarding General Real Estate Tax Policy
/ 정부학연구
/ 정부학연구소
17(1)
: 109~143
[journal]
양승일
/ 2016
/
A Comparative Analysis on the Regulatory Politics using Modified Wilson's Regulatory Politics Theory : Focused on the Capital Area Regulatory Policy of Korea and Japan
/ 지방행정연구
/ (재) 한국지방행정연구원
30(1)
: 251~279
[journal]
양천수
/ 2019
/
The 4th Industrial Revolution and the Evolution of Regulatory Forms
/ 경제규제와 법
/ 법학연구소
12(2)
: 154~172
[journal]
왕재선
/ 2019
/
Policy Participations, Government Trust and Policy Acceptance: The Case of Nuclear Policy
/ 한국행정연구
/ 한국행정연구원
28(1)
: 33~60
[journal]
윤준석
/ 2017
/ 우버와 관련된 법적 쟁점-택시 관계 법령을 중심으로
/ LAW & TECHNOLOGY
13(4)
: 3~16
[journal]
임서현
/ 2019
/ [특집 5] 플랫폼 운송사업 제도화를 통한 모빌리티 서비스 발전방향
/ 월간교통
: 24~32
[journal]
이옥교
/ 2019
/
A Study on the Policy Formation of Jeju Naval Base : Suggested Policy References for Construction of Korea Coast Guard Base
/ 한국해양경찰학회보
/ 한국해양경찰학회
9(4)
: 81~102
[journal]
정석호
/ 2019
/
How Could the City of Seoul Launch the Late-Night Bus Services?:A Political Management Perspective
/ 지방정부연구
/ 한국지방정부학회
23(3)
: 261~283
[journal]
장현주
/ 2015
/
A Policy Change Through Advocacy Coalition Framework and Conflict Phase Theory: Focused on a Case of Bangudae Petroglyphs Conservation
/ 한국행정논집
/ 한국정부학회
27(4)
: 901~924
[journal]
정용찬
/ 2019
/
Dynamic of managing citizen-led collaborative governance: Focusing on the governance of Seoul Youth Policy Network
/ 한국행정학보
/ 한국행정학회
53(1)
: 31~63
[book]
최종원
/ 2003
/ 정책학원론
/ 대명출판사 [서울]
[book]
최병선
/ 1992
/ 정부규제론
/ 법문사
[journal]
최예나
/ 2019
/
A Study on the Effect of Citizen Participation on Problem Stream and Policy Stream in Policy Agenda Setting: Focusing on the Moderating Effects of Government Trust
/ 한국자치행정학보
/ 한국자치행정학회
33(2)
: 277~297
[journal]
현승현
/ 2012
/ 부정당업자 제재에 대한 행정관리방향
/ 지방계약연구
3(2)
: 3~25
[journal]
Ansell, Chris
/ 2008
/ Collaborative governance in theory and practice
/ Journal of public administration research and theory
18(4)
: 543~571
[book]
Davidson, E. Jane
/ 2005
/ Evaluation methodology basics: The nuts and bolts of sound evaluation
/ Sage
[other]
Easton, David
/ 1953
/ The political system
: 341~364
[book]
Easton, David
/ 1965
/ A systems analysis of political life
/ John Wiley & Sons
[journal]
Emerson, Kirk
/ 2012
/ An integrative framework for collaborative governance
/ Journal of public administration research and theory
22(1)
: 1~29
[journal]
Ingram, Helen
/ 2007
/ Social construction and policy design
/ Theories of the policy process
2
: 93~126
[journal]
Irvin, Renee A.
/ 2004
/ Citizen participation in decision making: is it worth the effort?
/ Public administration review
64(1)
: 55~65
[book]
Kingdon, John W
/ 1995
/ Agendas, alternatives, and public policies
/ HaperCollins College Publisher
[report]
Lasswell, Harold Dwight
/ 1956
/ The decision process: Seven categories of functional analysis
/ Bureau of Governmental Research, College of Business and Public Administration, University of Maryland
[book]
Lindblom, Charles Edward
/ 1965
/ The intelligence of democracy: Decision making through mutual adjustment
/ Free pr
[journal]
Lindblom, Charles Edward
/ 1959
/ The science of "muddling through
/ Public administration review
: 79~88
[journal]
Mintrom, Michael
/ 2009
/ Competitive federalism and the governance of controversial science
/ Publius: The Journal of Federalism
39(4)
: 606~631
[book]
Moore, Mark Harrison
/ 1995
/ Creating public value: Strategic management in government
/ Harvard university press
[book]
OECD
/ 2001
/ Citizens as Partners： Information, consultation and public participation in policy-making
[other]
OECD
/ 2001
/ Citizens as Partners： OECD handbook on information, consultation and public participation in policy-making
[journal]
Quirk, Paul J.
/ 1989
/ The cooperative resolution of policy conflict
/ The American Political Science Review
: 905~921
[journal]
Rhodes, Rod AW
/ 1990
/ Policy networks: a British perspective
/ Journal of theoretical politics
2(3)
: 293~317
[journal]
Rhodes, Rod AW
/ 2002
/ Putting people back into networks
/ Australian Journal of Political Science
37(3)
: 399~416
[book]
Rose, Richard
/ 1984
/ Understanding big government: the programme approach
/ Sage Públications Ltd
[journal]
Rothstein, Bo
/ 2001
/ Social capital in the social democratic welfare state
/ Politics &Society
29(2)
: 207~241
[book]
Sabatier, Paul A.
/ 1993
/ Policy change and learning: An advocacy coalition approach
/ Westview Pr
[journal]
Sabatier, Paul A.
/ 2007
/ The advocacy coalition framework
/ Theories of the policy process
2
: 189~220
[book]
Weimer, David L.
/ 2017
/ Policy analysis: Concepts and practice
/ Taylor & Francis
[journal]
Weimer, David L
/ 2005
/ Institutionalizing neutrally competent policy analysis:Resources for promoting objectivity and balance in consolidating democracies
/ Policy Studies Journal
33(2)
: 131~146
[journal]
Walters, Lawrence C.
/ 2000
/ Putting more public in policy analysis
/ Public Administration Review
60(4)
: 349~359
[book]
Wilson, James Q
/ 1980
/ The politics of regulation
/ Basic Books (AZ)
[journal]
Vining, A. R.
/ 2008
/ Public—private partnerships: Eight rules for governments
/ Public Works Management & Policy
13(2)
: 149~161
This paper was written with support from the National Research Foundation of Korea.