Journal of Regulation Studies 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.78
-
pISSN : 1738-7132
- https://journal.kci.go.kr/ksrs2002
KJCKorea
Journal Central
Influence of Regulation Characteristics and Collaborative Network Attributes on Decision Lag in Regulation Improvement
- Journal of Regulation Studies
- 2023, 32(1), pp.71-119
- DOI : 10.22954/ksrs.2023.32.1.003
- Publisher : 한국규제학회
- Research Area : Social Science > Public Administration
- Received : June 14, 2023
- Accepted : June 26, 2023
- Published : June 30, 2023
정지혜 1, Park, Sunjoo 2, SongJune Kim 2, Won Soh-Yeon 3
1고등기술연구원
2경북대학교
3한국행정연구원
Accredited
ABSTRACT
This study investigates the factors that influence decision lag in the regulatory improvement process using the policy lag theory as a framework. Social network analysis is utilized to measure the collaborative characteristics of regulatory agencies. 198 cases of regulations in the corporate field registered on the Regulatory Information Portal between 2017 and 2018 are analyzed using multi-level analysis. The study found that decision lag is more likely to extend when the benefits of regulatory improvement are concentrated on a specific policy target group. In regulatory work, the more inbound and outbound requests for collaboration, the higher the lag in regulatory improvement decisions. Additionally, betweenness and eigenvector centralities of regulatory agencies are found to significantly shorten decision lag. These results highlight the importance of these factors in improving the efficiency of regulatory improvement processes and contribute to regulatory policy and practice.
Statistics
-
211 Viewed
-
219 Downloaded
Tools
Issue List
Citation status
* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.
[book]
강상진
/ 2016
/ 다층모형
/ 학지사
[journal]
고영준
/ 2018
/
Theory and Practice of Regulatory Lag : Focusing on Conformity Assessment
/ 입법과 정책
/ 국회입법조사처
10(1)
: 171~191
[book]
곽기영
/ 2017
/ 소셜 네트워크분석
/ 청람
[other]
국무총리실
/ 2008
/ 규제절차 매뉴얼
/ 국무총리실
[journal]
권유진
/ 2021
/
A Study on the Factors Influencing the Life Satisfaction of Citizens in ODA Recipient Countries: Application of Multi-Level Analysis
/ 국가정책연구
/ 국가정책연구소
35(3)
: 135~176
[journal]
김상봉
/ 2008
/
A Study of the Policy lag approach of Policy Process: in the case of Seoul Public Traffic Reform Policy
/ 지방정부연구
/ 한국지방정부학회
12(1)
: 7~29
[book]
김성준
/ 2020
/ 공공선택론-정치·행정의 경제학적 분석
/ 박영사
[book]
김용학
/ 2007
/ 사회연결망 분석
/ 박영사
[report]
김윤권
/ 2014
/ 정부조직관리의 협업행정에 관한 연구
/ 한국행정연구원
[journal]
류병곤
/ 2016
/
The Multi-level Analysis on the Causal Relationship among Organizational Structure, Organizational Culture, and Organizational Effectiveness
/ 한국조직학회보
/ 한국조직학회
13(1)
: 33~62
[journal]
문경주
/ 2020
/
A Study of Determinants on the Settlement Consciousness of The Middle Aged in Busan Metropolitan City By Multi-level Analysis.
/ 항도부산
/ 부산광역시사편찬위원회
(39)
: 413~448
[journal]
민병익
/ 2010
/
The Analysis of taking time on enacting an ordinance in local council
/ 한국행정논집
/ 한국정부학회
22(4)
: 1165~1186
[journal]
박순종
/ 2016
/
Analysis of Ordinance Enactment Period and the Implication: Focusing on Korean Metropolitan Council
/ 한국정책학회보
/ 한국정책학회
25(2)
: 283~310
[journal]
서인석
/ 2013
/
Policy Target Group and Policy Decision Making Time: Focusing on Required Time to Pass a Bill Proposed by Congressperson
/ 한국행정학보
/ 한국행정학회
47(2)
: 55~83
[book]
손동원
/ 2002
/ 사회 네트워크 분석
/ 경문사
[report]
심우현
/ 2017
/ 디지털 헬스케어, 어떻게 대응할 것인가? 규제 대응 과제와 논의
/ 한국행정원구원
[report]
원소연
/ 2018
/ 다부처 규제 합리화 방안 : 안전규제 및 신산업 규제를 중심으로
/ 한국행정연구원
[journal]
원소연
/ 2019
/
Enhancing Multi-Agency Collaboration in the Shared Regulatory Space: Focused on the Regulatory Reform Systems in Korea
/ 국가정책연구
/ 국가정책연구소
33(4)
: 1~28
[journal]
이명석
/ 2017
/
Governance Change for Future Administrative Demands
/ 한국행정연구
/ 한국행정연구원
26(4)
: 1~32
[journal]
이민호
/ 2021
/
Relationship between cost-benefit analysis and stakeholder consultation as policy tools for regulatory quality management
/ 한국행정학보
/ 한국행정학회
55(3)
: 95~123
[journal]
이시원
/ 2013
/
The Current State of Research on Time Difference Perspective: Evaluating its Performance and Suggesting Tasks for Future Development
/ 한국사회와 행정연구
/ 서울행정학회
24(2)
: 405~435
[journal]
이시원
/ 2011
/
Policy Actor's Attitude and Duration of Policy-making: Focusing on a Case Study of Rho Mu-Hyun Government's Major Policies
/ 정책분석평가학회보
/ 한국정책분석평가학회
21(3)
: 179~206
[journal]
이영철
/ 2009
/
Implementation agency effect on Self-Sufficiency of Participants in Self-Support Program
/ 사회복지연구
/ 한국사회복지연구회
40(2)
: 227~252
[report]
이종한
/ 2020
/ 규제지체 해소를 위한 유연성 제고방안: 신산업 중심으로
/ 한국행정연구원
[report]
이종한
/ 2017
/ 수요자 중심 규제개혁 평가 및 개선 방안
/ 한국행정연구원
[report]
이주선
/ 2002
/ 특성별 규제분류와 규제개혁에의 시사점
/ 규제연구회
[report]
이혁우
/ 2018
/ 규제개혁의 평가와 새로운 추진체계의 모색
/ KDI
[book]
이혁우
/ 2021
/ 규제관리론
/ 윤성사
[book]
이희연
/ 2013
/ 고급통계분석론
/ 문우사
[journal]
이희철
/ 2016
/
Collaborative Administration Networks and Policy Implications: Based on Analyses of Collaboration Plans of Government Ministries
/ 정부학연구
/ 정부학연구소
22(1)
: 83~112
[journal]
임도빈
/ 2003
/
시간길이와 부처조직운영에 관한 연구: 정통부와 농림부의 비교
/ 한국행정학보
/ 한국행정학회
37(4)
: 79~101
[journal]
임도빈
/ 2008
/
Time and Policy Making Process; a case study of Rho Mu-Hyun Government’s major policies
/ 한국정치학회보
/ 한국정치학회
42(3)
: 191~217
[journal]
정정길
/ 2002
/
정책과 제도의 변화과정과 인과법칙의 동태적 성격- 시차적(時差的) 접근방법 (Time Lag Approach)을 위한 제언 -
/ 한국정책학회보
/ 한국정책학회
11(2)
: 255~272
[journal]
정정길
/ 2002
/
na
/ 한국행정학보
/ 한국행정학회
36(1)
: 1~19
[book]
정정길
/ 2005
/ 행정의 시차적 접근
/ 박영사
[journal]
정정길
/ 2003
/
Time Lag Elements of Policy and Institutional Change
/ 행정논총
/ 한국행정연구소
41(2)
: 178~202
[book]
최병선
/ 1992
/ 정부규제론
/ 법문사
[confproc]
최상욱
/ 2018
/ 네트워크 연구 비판에 대한 맥락과 기저 – 개념, 이론, 방법론 측면에서 -
/ 한국행정학회 동계학술대회 발표자료
[report]
최유성
/ 2014
/ 행정적 규제의 유형 분류 및 실태 분석에 관한 연구
/ 한국행정연구원
[journal]
최희성
/ 2020
/
The Analysis of Time Lag in Laws and Enforcement Ordinances of Successive Governments
/ 법학연구
/ 법학연구소
28(3)
: 259~291
[journal]
최희성
/ 2018
/
The Analysis of Time Lag in Policy Making and Policy Implementation: Based on Laws and Enforcement Ordinances of the 19th National Assembly
/ 한국정책학회보
/ 한국정책학회
27(3)
: 299~330
[book]
하병기
/ 2000
/ 규제개혁의 경제효과분석
/ 을유문화사
[journal]
하복동
/ 2006
/
Cross-Cutting Issues and Challenges to Public Policy Making: Case Study for Service Industry Fostering Policy
/ 정책분석평가학회보
/ 한국정책분석평가학회
16(2)
: 57~80
[journal]
홍성수
/ 2016
/ 시차이론과 시간의 개념
/ 한국정책연구
16(3)
: 1~18
[journal]
홍현미라
/ 2008
/
An Analysis on the Organizational Effect in Job Satisfaction of Participants in the Social Job: Centered on the Application of HLM Model
/ 사회복지정책
/ 한국사회복지정책학회
(35)
: 457~480
[book]
Agranoff, R.
/ 2003
/ Collaborative public management: New strategies for local governments
/ Georgetown University Press
[book]
Anderson, J. E.
/ 2002
/ Public Policy making
/ Houhton Mifflin
[book]
Bardach, E.
/ 1982
/ Going by the book: The problem of regulatory unreasonableness
/ Temple University Press
[book]
Barke, R.
/ 1984
/ Federal Administrative Agencies
/ Prentice Hall
: 144~156
[journal]
Bonacich, P.
/ 1987
/ Power and Centrality: A Family of Measures
/ American Journal of Sociology
92
: 1170~1182
[book]
Brunner, K.
/ 1964
/ An Alternative Approach to the A Monetary Mechanism
/ Government Printing Office
[journal]
Butts, C. T.
/ 2008
/ Social network analysis: A methodological introduction
/ Asian Journal of Social Psychology
11
: 13~41
[journal]
Freeman, L. C.
/ 1978
/ Centrality in social networks conceptual clarification
/ Social networks
1(3)
: 215~239
[journal]
Friedman, M.
/ 1961
/ The Lag in Effect of Monetary Policy
/ Journal of Political Economy
69(5)
: 447~466
[journal]
Hendershott, P. H.
/ 1966
/ The Inside Lag in Monetary Policy: A Comment
/ Journal of Political Economy
74(5)
: 519~523
[book]
Kareken, J.
/ 1963
/ Stabilization Policies
/ Prentice-Hall, Inc
[journal]
Kerwin, C.
/ 1992
/ Time and rulemaking: An empirical test of theory
/ Journal of Public Administration Research and Theory
2(2)
: 113~138
[book]
Klijn, E
/ 1997
/ Managing Complex Networks: Strategies for the Public Sector
/ Sage Publications
[book]
Knoke, D.
/ 1982
/ Network Analysis
/ Sage
[book]
Lasswell, H. D
/ 1971
/ A preview of policy sciences
/ American Elsevier
[journal]
Marsden, P. V.
/ 1990
/ Network data and measurement
/ Annual Review of Sociology
16
: 435~463
[report]
OECD
/ 1997
/ The OECD Report on Regulatory Reform: Synthesis
[report]
OECD
/ 2001
/ Citizens as Partners: OECD Handbook on Information, Consultation, and Public Participation in Policy-Making
/ OECD Publica tions Service
[journal]
Perryman, M.
/ 1980
/ Some Evidence regarding the Lag in the Initial Countercyclical Response of Monetary Policy
/ Nebraska Journal of Economics and Business
19(2)
: 65~71
[book]
Pierson. P.
/ 2004
/ Princeton
/ Princeton University Press
[journal]
Potter, R. A.
/ 2017
/ Slow-Rolling, Fast-Tracking, and the Pace of Bureaucratic Decisions in Rulemaking
/ The Journal of Politics
79(3)
: 841~855
[journal]
Provan, K. G.
/ 2001
/ Do Networks Really Work? A Framework for Evaluating Public-Sector Organizational Networks
/ Public Administration Review
61
: 414~423
[book]
Ripley, R. B.
/ 1986
/ Policy Implementation and Bureaucracy
/ The Dorsey Press
[journal]
Roberts, N.
/ 2000
/ Wicked Problems and Network Approaches to Resolution
/ International Public Management Review
1
: 1~16
[book]
Scott, J
/ 2000
/ A Handbook
/ Sage
[book]
Spangler, B. Decision-Making Delay
/ Conflict Information Consortium
/ University of Colorado
[journal]
Susskind, L.
/ 1985
/ The Theory and Practice of Negotiated Rulemaking
/ Yale Journal on Regulation
3(1)
: 133~165
[journal]
Waarden, F.
/ 1992
/ Dimensions and Types of Policy Networks
/ European Journal of Political Research
21
: 29~52
[book]
Wasserman. S.
/ 1994
/ Social Network Analysis: Methods and Applications
/ Cambridge University Press
[journal]
Willes, M. H.
/ 1967
/ The Inside Lags of Monetary Policy: 1952-1960
/ The Journal of Finance
22(4)
: 591~593
[book]
Wilson, J. Q
/ 1980
/ The Politics of Regulation
/ Basic Books
[web]
내일신문
/ 2021
/ [21대 국회 1년, 쏟아지는 법률│③ 너무 쉬운 입법] 의원입법, 11일만에 한 건씩 … 정부입법, 8단계·최소 154일
/ http://m.naeil.com/m_news_view.php?id_art=387723
[web]
뉴스토마토
/ 2022
/ '국가건축정책위 국토부 이관 반대'…건축단체, 공동설명서 발표
/ https://www.newstong.co.kr/view3.aspx?seq=11256307
[web]
뉴시스
/ 2022
/ '말많고 탈많던' 클라우드 인증 등급제 시행 잠정 보류
/ https://mobile.newsis.com/view.html?ar_id=NISX20221111_0002082706
[web]
한국경제
/ 2022
/ 복지부-산업부 디지털 헬스케어 밥그릇 싸움
/ https://www.hankyung.com/politics/article/2022100962531