Korean Journal of Medical Ethics 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 1.21
-
pISSN : 2005-8284 / eISSN : 2234-3598
- https://journal.kci.go.kr/medethics
KJCKorea
Journal Central
Trends in Japanese Research Ethics in the 21st Century: Research Misconduct and Related Policies
- Korean Journal of Medical Ethics
- Abbr : 의료윤리
- 2021, 24(4), pp.461-481
- DOI : 10.35301/ksme.2021.24.4.461
- Publisher : The Korean Society For Medical Ethics
- Research Area : Medicine and Pharmacy > General Medicine
- Received : November 11, 2021
- Accepted : December 24, 2021
- Published : December 31, 2021
Kyu Won Lee
1,
Kim, Ock Joo
1
1서울대학교 의과대학 인문의학교실
Accredited
ABSTRACT
Japan and South Korea both have relatively high rates of research misconduct in the biomedical sciences. These two countries also share other relevant characteristics, including being latecomers to research ethics and having hierarchical cultures and competitive research environments. Given these similarities, Korea can learn from Japan’s efforts to eradicate research misconduct. In the 2010s, after experiencing several high-profile cases of misconduct, Japanese authorities implemented measures to combat research misconduct at the national level. However, these measures have so far been outweighed by other policies that aggravate excessive competition and a negative research culture in science and technology. This article argues that the key lesson for Korea from Japan’s experiences fighting research misconduct is that instead of focusing only on research ethics education and punishment, it is necessary to (a) establish a system of manpower training with secure employment in science and technology, (b) abolish the ‘winner takes all’ strategy in research funding, and (c) promote bottom-up policy-making.
Statistics
-
368 Viewed
-
153 Downloaded
Tools
Issue List
Citation status
* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.
[journal]
Dollfuß H
/ 2015
/ Analyse zurückgezogener Publikationen in der bibliografischen Datenbank Web of Science von 2004 bis 2014
/ GMS Med Bibl Inf
15(1)
: 1~6
[journal]
Michael L. Grieneisen
/ 2012
/ A Comprehensive Survey of Retracted Articles from the Scholarly Literature
/ PLoS ONE
/ Public Library of Science (PLoS)
7(10)
: e44118~
[web]
Brainard J
/ What a massive database of retracted papers reveals about science publishing’s ‘death penalty’
/ https://www.sciencemag.org/news/2018/10/what-massive-database-retracted-papers-reveals-about-science-publishing-s-death-penalty
[journal]
Matsuzawa T
/ 2014
/ National research integrity system (NRIS) of foreign countries (1): Basic structural model and its typology
/ Joho kanri : gekkan JICST
56(10)
: 697~711
[web]
/ The Retraction Watch Leaderboard
/ https://retractionwatch.com/the-retraction-watch-leaderboard/
[journal]
Kupferschmidt K
/ 2018
/ Tide of Lies
/ Science
361
: 636~641
[journal]
Else H
/ 2019
/ What universities can learn from epic case of research fraud
/ Nature
570
: 287~288
[journal]
미야가와 타쿠야
/ 2008
/
Research Ethics in Japan: Institutions' responses to cases of noncompliance with research ethics guidelines
/ 생명윤리
/ 한국생명윤리학회
9(2)
: 35~47
[confproc]
Council for Science and Technology
/ 2006
/ Material #5: Representative cases of research misconduct
/ First meeting of Special Committee for Research Misconduct
[report]
Investigative Committee of Graduate School of Engineering, the University of Tokyo
/ 2006
/ Investigative report on re-experiments of RNA-related research papers by Prof. Kazunari Taira et al. 2006 Jan 25
[report]
Investigative Committee of Graduate School of Engineering, the University of Tokyo
/ 2006
/ Final investigative report on research papers whose reproducibility was questioned by the RNA Society of Japan. 2006 Mar 29
[journal]
Komazawa N
/ 2004
/ Enhanced insulin sensitivity, energy expenditure and thermogenesis in adipose-specific Pten suppression in mice
/ Nature Medicine
10(11)
: 1208~1215
[journal]
Slingsby BT
/ 2006
/ Scientific Misconduct in Japan : The Present Paucity of Oversight Policy
/ Cambridge Quarterly of Healthcare Ethics
15
: 294~297
[web]
/ Japan Society for the Promotion of Science, 21st Century COE Program
/ https://www.jsps.go.jp/j-21coe/
[web]
Science Council of Japan
/ About Science Council of Japan
/ http://www.scj.go.jp/ja/scj/index.html
[other]
Committee for Science and Society, Science Council of Japan
/ 2003
/ Regarding scientific misconduct and its prevention. 2003 Jun 24
[other]
Committee for Science and Society, Science Council of Japan
/ 2005
/ Current status and countermeasures for scientific misconduct. 2005 Jul 21
[other]
Science Council of Japan
/ 2006
/ Statement: Code of conduct for scientists. 2006 Oct 3
[other]
Council for Science and Technology’s Special Committee on Misconduct in Research Activities
/ 2006
/ Guidelines for responding to misconduct in research. 2006 Aug 8
[journal]
Kranke P
/ 2000
/ Reported Data on Granisetron and Postoperative Nausea and Vomiting by Fujii et al
/ Are Incredibly Nice!Anesthesia & Analgesia
90
: 1004~1006
[other]
Special Investigation Committee on Dr. Yoshitaka Fujii’s Papers
/ 2012
/ The results of the investigation into Dr. Yoshitaka Fujii’s papers. 2012 Jun 28
[journal]
Cyranoski D
/ 2012
/ Retraction record rocks community : Anaesthesiology tries to move on after fraud investigation
/ Nature
489
: 346~347
[report]
Committee for the Code of Conduct in Scientific Research
/ 2013
/ Interim investigation report of suspected publication misconduct in the former Kato Laboratory, Institute of Molecular and Cellular Biosciences. 2013 Dec 25
[report]
Committee for the Code of Conduct in Scientific Research
/ 2014
/ Final investigation report of publication misconduct in the former Kato Laboratory, Institute of Molecular and Cellular Biosciences. 2014 Dec 26
[book]
Kuroki T
/ 2016
/ Research misconduct: Fabrication, falsification, and plagiarism by scientists
/ Chuokoron-Shinsha
: 102~103
[book]
Japan Science and Technology Agency
/ 2010
/ Ex-post evaluation report of Kato Intranuclear Complex Project
/ ERATO
[report]
Kyoto Prefectural University of Medicine
/ 2013
/ Investigation report of the clinical research “Kyoto Heart Study.” 2013 Aug 9
[book]
Kuroki T
/ 2016
/ Research misconduct: Fabrication, falsification, and plagiarism by scientists
/ Chuokoron-Shinsha
: 87~93
[book]
Kuroki T
/ 2016
/ Research misconduct: Fabrication, falsification, and plagiarism by scientists
/ Chuokoron-Shinsha
: 90~
[other]
Japanese Association of Medical Sciences
/ 2013
/ Opinions on “Kyoto Heart Study.” 2013 Jul 12
[other]
RIKEN Committee on Suspected Research Papers
/ 2014
/ Investigation report of suspected research papers. 2014 Mar 31
[other]
RIKEN Committee on Research Papers
/ 2014
/ Investigation report of research papers. 2014 Dec 25
[other]
Reform Committee for the Prevention of Recurrence of Research Misconduct
/ 2014
/ A proposal for the prevention of recurrence of research misconduct. 2014 Jun 12
[book]
Sakamoto R
/ 2016
/ Analysis on research integrity policy in Japan: Transition of guidelines and its Implication
/ The University of Tokyo
[other]
Science Council of Japan
/ 2013
/ Statement: Code of conduct for scientists, a revised version. 2013Jan 25
[other]
Review Board for the Improvement of the Scientific Soundness, Science Council of Japan
/ 2013
/ Proposal: Prevention of research misconduct and its post management for the improvement of the scientific soundness. 2013 Dec 26
[other]
Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology
/ 2014
/ Guidelines for responding to misconduct in research. 2014 Aug 26
[web]
Otake T
/ 2014
/ ‘STAPgate’ shows Japan must get back to basics in science
/ https://www.japantimes.co.jp/news/2014/04/20/national/stapgate-showsjapan-must-get-back-to-basics-in-science/
[book]
Hickling Arthurs Low
/ 2009
/ The state of research integrity and misconduct policies in Canada
/ Hickling Arthurs Low
: 39~
[other]
Office for Research Integrity Promotion, Ministry of Education, Culture, Sports, Science and Technology, Japan
/ 2021
/ Initiatives for Promotion of Research Integrity. 2021 Apr
[other]
Editing Committee “For the Sound Development of Science”
/ 2015
/ For the sound development of science: The attitude of a conscientious scientist. 2015 Feb
[web]
Japan Society for the Promotion of Science
/ e-Learning course on research ethics
/ https://elcore.jsps.go.jp/top.aspx
[web]
Office of Research Integrity
/ The lab: To prevent research misconduct
/ https://lab.jst.go.jp/
[other]
Japan Agency for Medical Research and Development
/ 2018
/ Responsible research practices to learn from cases: A casebook to instill awareness and learning. 2018 Mar
[other]
Japan Agency for Medical Research and Development
/ 2020
/ Near miss cases on research integrity. 2020 Mar
[web]
Association for the Promotion of Research Integrity
/ About APRIN
/ https://www.aprin.or.jp/aprin
[web]
Association for the Promotion of Research Integrity
/ APRIN e-learning program (eAPRIN)
/ https://edu.aprin.or.jp/
[web]
Japan Agency for Medical Research and Development
/ RIO network
/ https://www.amed.go.jp/kenkyu_kousei/rionetwork.html
[web]
House of Representatives
/ Outline of the legislative bill to partially revise the Act on Strengthening R&D Capabilities and Promoting Efficient R&D by Reforming the R&D Systems
/ https://www.shugiin.go.jp/internet/itdb_gian.nsf/html/gian/honbun/youkou/g19705006.htm
[web]
Digital Agency
/ Act #63, 2008: Act on Revitalization of Science, Technology, and Innovation
/ https://elaws.e-gov.go.jp/document?lawid=420AC1000000063
[web]
The University of Tokyo
/ Regarding the investigation report of research papers
/ http://www.iam.u-tokyo.ac.jp/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2017/09/report_20170906_j.pdf
[web]
Osaka University
/ Regarding the investigation results of specific research misconduct
/ https://www.osaka-u.ac.jp/ja/news/topics/2020/08/20200818001
[web]
National Cerebral and Cardiovascular Center
/ Regarding specific research misconduct by former center staff
/ http://www.ncvc.go.jp/topics/20210130.html
[web]
Goto K
/ 2021
/ What is the impact of clinical research misconduct on patients in Osaka University Hospital?
/ https://www.asahi.com/articles/ASP1Z-7S9YP1ZPLBJ00C.html
[web]
/ 2019
/ Publication misconduct at Kyoto University:Pressure to win research grants behind persistent misconduct?
/ https://mainichi.jp/articles/20190326/k00/00m/040/329000c
[journal]
Matsuzawa T
/ 2013
/ Research misconduct in Japan:Macro-analysis based on open information (1)
/ Journal of Information Processing and Management
56(3)
: 156~165
[other]
Subdivision on Graduate Schools in the Subdivision on Universities
/ 2017
/ Material #5 for the 81st meeting: Basic current status data on graduate school education. 2017 May 30
[book]
Miyagawa T
/ 2018
/ An Empirical Study for Strengthening Research Integrity in Korea
/ Science and Technology Policy Institute
: 161~162
[journal]
Asai A
/ 2016
/ Conflicting messages concerning current strategies against research misconduct in Japan : a call for ethical spontaneity
/ Journal of Medical Ethics
42
: 524~527
[book]
National Institute of Science and Technology Policy
/ 2021
/ Japanese Science and Technology Indicators 2021
/ National Institute of Science and Technology Policy
: 6~
[web]
Coping with research misconduct
/ 2015
/ The Japan Times. 2015 Mar 26
/ https://www.japantimes.co.jp/opinion/2015/03/26/editorials/coping-with-research-misconduct/
[confproc]
Fudano J
/ 2018
/ Aspirational ethics and engineering ethics education: The construction of engineering ethics education program which fosters engineers who aspire to contribute to the well-being of the society
/ Proceedings of Annual Conference of Japanese Society for Engineering Education
66
: 130~131
This paper was written with support from the National Research Foundation of Korea.