Effectiveness of Parent-Child Interaction Therapy(PCIT) for Children with Problem Behavior: Meta-Analysis (문제행동을 보이는 아동에 대한부모-자녀 상호작용치료(PCIT)의 효과성: 메타분석)

Jeongok Lee (이정옥); LEE SANG HEE (이상희)

Effectiveness of Parent-Child Interaction Therapy(PCIT) for Children with Problem Behavior: Meta-Analysis

Journal of Symbols & Sandplay Therapy
Abbr : JSST
2023, 14(2), pp.47-89
Publisher : Korean Society for Sandplay Therapy
Research Area : Social Science > Psychological Science > Counseling Psychology / Psychotherapy
Received : May 30, 2023
Accepted : July 10, 2023
Published : August 31, 2023

Jeongok Lee ¹, LEE SANG HEE ¹

¹동국대학교대학원 상담코칭학과

Accredited

ABSTRACT

Parent-Child Interaction Therapy (PCIT) is an evidence-based short-term treatment program designed for preschool children(2 to 7 years old) and parents with behavior or emotional problems, and is an effective intervention method to improve parent-child relationships and reduce children’s problem behavior. The purpose of this study is to estimate the effect of PCIT studied in Korea and to prepare an integrated basis. From 1991 to February 2022, papers studied in Korea were selected as exploration and target studies. A total of 17 studies were selected, and 11 studies (212 children, 12 father, 212 mother, 436 total) were finally included in the meta-analysis study, excluding 3 studies that presented the ranking sum. As a result of this study, the effect of PCIT improved children’s problem behavior (1.32), reduced parenting stress (1.06) and mother’s depression (0.99), and increased parenting efficacy (1.06) and spouse’s parenting cooperation (0.86), which showed a significant effect (d>.8). This study is the first to conduct a meta-analysis on the effects of PCIT based on domestic literature and is expected to be widely used as a child counseling and parent education program.

KEYWORDS

parent-child interaction therapy (PCIT), problem behavior, parenting stress, parenting efficacy, parenting cooperation, meta-analysis

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

[journal] 안현정 / 2012 / A Study on the Relationship between the Child's Perceived Mother's Overprotection and the Child's Problematic Behaviors by the Child's Enneagram Personality Type / 한국가족복지학 / 한국아동가족복지학회 17(3) : 125~148

[journal] 백지은 / 2012 / The effectiveness of Group Parent Child Interaction Therapy of Children with Behavior Problems / 한국놀이치료학회지 / 한국놀이치료학회 15(1) : 93~110

[thesis] Baek, J-H. / 2022 / A study on the preventive effect of non-face-to-face group Parent-Child Interaction Therapy for toddlers / Master / Graduate School of Hanyang University

[journal] Bagner, D. M. / 2007 / Parent-Child Interaction Therapy for disruptive behavior in children with mental retardation : A randomized controlled trial / Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology 36(3) : 418~429

[book] Berk, L. E / 2014 / Child Development / Sigmapress

[book] Borenstein, M. / 2009 / The Handbook of Research Synthesis and Meta-Analysis : 221~235

[thesis] Choi, M-S. / 2005 / Therapeutic relationship and therapeutic outcomes of play therapy / Doctor / Graduate School of Sookmyung Women's University

[book] Cohen, J. / 1988 / Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences / Lawrence Erlbaum Associates

[book] Cooper, H. / 2015 / Research synthesis and meta-analysis: A step-by-step approach (Vol. 2) / Sage publications

[thesis] Doo, J-I. / 2010 / Verification of the effectiveness of a group Parent-Child Interaction Therapy program for children and parents with disruptive behavioral problems / Doctor / Graduate School of Hanyang University

[journal] 두정일 / 2014 / The Effects of Parent-Child Interaction Therapy on ADHD Traits Children’s Behavior Problems, Their Mother’s Psychological Status and Interaction / 정서·행동장애연구 / 한국정서행동장애학회 30(2) : 307~335

[journal] 두정일 / 2018 / The effectiveness of parent-child interaction therapy for children with autism spectrum disorder and their parents / 한국아동심리치료학회지 / 한국아동심리치료학회 13(2) : 51~71

[journal] 두정일 / 2012 / The Effectiveness of Group Parent-Child Interaction Therapy for Children with Disruptive Behavioral Problems and their Mothers / 한국심리학회지: 상담 및 심리치료 / 한국상담심리학회 24(2) : 339~363

[journal] Duval, S. J. / 2000 / A non-parametric ‘trim and fill’ method of accounting for publication bias in meta-analysis / Journal of the American Statistical Association 95 : 89~98

[journal] Eyberg, S. / 1988 / Parent-Child Interaction Therapy : Integration of traditional and behavioral concerns / Child & Family Behavior Therapy 10(1) : 33~46

[confproc] Eyberg, S. M. / 1979 / Parent-child interaction model for the treatment of psychological disorders in young children / [Paper presentation] Western Psychological Association

[journal] Eyberg, S. M. / 1992 / Assessing therapy outcome with preschool children : Progress and problems / Journal of Clinical Child and Adolescent Psychology 21(3) : 306~311

[journal] Foley, K. / 2016 / Effectiveness of group format Parent-Child Interaction Therapy compared to treatment as usual in a community outreach organization / Child & Family Behavior Therapy 38(4) : 279~298

[journal] Foote, R. / 1998 / Parent-child interaction approaches to the treatment of child behavior problems / Advances in clinical child psychology 20 : 125~151

[thesis] Gat, T. / 2007 / Effectiveness of Parent-Child Interaction Therapy administered in spanish to spanish-speaking latino clients / Master / California State University

[journal] Ghanizadeh, A. / 2009 / Helping families for caring children with autistic spectrum disorders / Archives of Iranian Medicine(AIM) 12(5) : 478~482

[journal] Ginn, N. C. / 2017 / Child-directed interaction training for young children with autism spectrum disorders : Parent and child outcomes / Journal of Clinical Child & Adolescent Psychology 46(1) : 101~109

[thesis] Gong, J-Y. / 2021 / A study on the interaction change of children with overall developmental delay in the PCIT process / Doctor / Graduate School of Myongji University

[book] Hedges, L. V. / 1985 / Statistical methods for meta-analysis / Academic Press

[book] Hembree-Kigin, T. L. / 2013 / Parent—Child Interaction Therapy / Springer Science & Business Media

[journal] Herschell, A. D. / 2002 / Clinical issues in parent-child interaction therapy / Cognitive and Behavioral Practice 9(1) : 16~27

[web] Higgins, J. P. T / 2008 / Cochrane hadbook for systematic reviews of interventions version 5.0.0 [updated Febuary 2008] / The Cochrane Collaboration / www.cochrane-handbook.org

[book] Higgins, J. P. / 2019 / Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions / John Wiley &Sons

[journal] Hildyard, K. L. / 2002 / Child neglect: developmental issues and outcomes / Child abuse & neglect 26(6-7) : 679~695

[book] Hwang, S-D. / 2020 / Meta-Analysis Using R / Hakjisa

[thesis] Jang, M-A. / 2019 / A study on the effectiveness of Parent-Child Interaction Therapy (PCIT)for children with language delay / Master / Graduate School of Hanyang University

[journal] Jin, H-D. / 2015 / Validation of the effectiveness of a parent-child interaction therapy(PCIT)program for infants / Early Childhood Mental Health Research 8(1) : 29~51

[journal] 김종한 / 2011 / The Analysis of Theses Content Related to Parents' Needs for Their Education / 한국산학기술학회논문지 / 한국산학기술학회 12(5) : 2115~2123

[journal] 김정미 / 2012 / The Moderating and Mediating Effects of Maternal Psychological variances and Responsive style on Pivotal developmental behaviors of Young children with disabilities / 유아특수교육연구 / 한국유아특수교육학회 12(2) : 55~77

[journal] 김재엽 / 2003 / Analysis of the Problems of Children Exposed to Family Violence and Clinical Intervention Program for the Children / 한국사회복지학 / 한국사회복지학회 55 : 27~54

[report] Kim, S-Y. / 2020 / Medical Technology Evaluation Methodology: A Systematic Literature Review / Korea Health and Medical Research Institute

[other] Kim, S-Y. / 2011 / NECA Systematic Review Manual / Korea Health and Medical Research Institute

[thesis] Kim, Y-J. / 2019 / Evaluating the effectiveness of single-parent-child complex therapy (PCIT)for behavioral children and their parents / Doctor / Graduate School of Hanyang University

[journal] 고은숙 / 2020 / A Case Study of Parent-Child Interaction Therapy in Anxious Preschool Children and Parents / 한국기독교상담학회지 / 한국기독교상담심리학회 31(4) : 39~68

[journal] Kohlhoff, J. / 2014 / Parent-Child Interaction Therapy for toddlers : A pilot study / Child & Family Behavior Therapy 36(2) : 121~139

[journal] Leung, C. / 2009 / Effectiveness of Parent-Child Interaction Therapy(PCIT)among Chinese families / Research on Social Work Practice 19(3) : 304~313

[journal] Leung, C. / 2017 / Efficacy of Parent–Child Interaction Therapy with Chinese ADHD children : Randomized controlled trial / Research on Social Work Practice 27(1) : 36~47

[journal] Matos, M. / 2006 / Adaptation of Parent-Child Interaction Therapy for puetro rican famlilies : A preliminary study / Family Process 45(2) : 205~222

[book] McMahon, R. J. / 1997 / Assessment of childhood disorders / Guildford Press : 130~193

[journal] Mcrae, R. E. / 2003 / The treatment of child neglect through a comprehensive service strategy including home-based therapy, play therapy, parent education, and parent-child interaction therapy / Dissertation Abstracts International : Section B : The Sciences & Engineering 63 : 3930~

[journal] Moher, D. / 2015 / Preferred reporting items for systematic review and meta-analysis protocols(PRISMA-P)2015 statement / Systematic reviews 4(1) : 1~9

[journal] Morris, S. B. / 2002 / Combining effect size estimates in meta-analysis with repeated measures and independent-groups designs / Psychological methods 7(1) : 105~

[journal] 나종혜 / 2005 / A survey on parental education in kindergartens of Daejeon / 한국생활과학회지 / 한국생활과학회 14(4) : 506~519

[journal] Olson, S. L. / 1990 / Early antecedents childhood impulsivity the role of parent child interaction, cognitive competence, and temperament / Journal of Abnormal Child Psychology 8(3) : 317~334

[thesis] Park, J-H. / 2014 / Determinants of mother's parenting behavior, mother's parenting behavior and path of problem behavior of adolescent children: based on Abidin's theory / Doctor / Graduate School of Konkuk University

[journal] 박민경 / 2018 / Effects of Parent-Child Interaction Therapy on Parenting Skill and Children's Problem Behaviors: Meta-analysis / 대한감각통합치료학회지 / 대한감각통합치료학회 16(2) : 50~63

[journal] 박나래 / 2012 / The Influence of Parental Neglect and Overprotection on Youth’s Psychosocial Adjustment －Focusing on Moderating Effect of Private Tutoring－ / 한국아동복지학 / 한국아동복지학회 (37) : 139~164

[journal] Park, Y-N. / 2016 / A pilot study of the effectiveness of parent-child interaction therapy(PCIT) / Early Childhood Mental Health Study 9(1) : 33~54

[journal] Phillips, J. / 2008 / Pilot evaluation of Parent-Child Interaction Therapy delivered in an Australian community early childhood clinic setting / Australian & New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 42(8) : 712~719

[journal] Phillips, S. T. / 2023 / Parent-Child Interaction Therapy for preschool aged youth : A meta-analysis of developmental specificity / Child & Youth Care Forum 52(2) : 267~284

[journal] Sourander, A. / 2005 / Childhood predictors of adolescence / European child &adolescent psychiatry 14(8) : 415~423

[web] Statistical Office / 2022 / 2021 birth statistics [press release] / https://www.kostat.go.kr/board.es?mid=a10301020300&bid=204&act=view&list_no=419974

[journal] Urquiza, A. J. / 1996 / Parent-Child Interaction Therapy : An intensive dyadic intervention for physically abusive families / Child Maltreatment 1(2) : 134~144

[journal] Ward, M. A. / 2016 / Parent-child interaction therapy for child disruptive behaviour disorders : A meta-analysis / Child & Youth Care Forum 45(5) : 675~690

[thesis] Yeom, H-J. / 2021 / Examination of the effectiveness of Parent-Child Interaction Therapy (PCIT): Comparison of father-mother effects in the parental co-participation condition / Master / Graduate School of Hanyang University

KJCKorea
Journal Central

Journal of Symbols & Sandplay Therapy 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.44