본문 바로가기
  • Home

Is Korean Academia Unique? A Comparison of Knowledge Discourses between Korean and International Sociology

  • Korean Journal of Sociology
  • 2020, 54(4), pp.1-40
  • DOI : 10.21562/kjs.2020.11.54.4.1
  • Publisher : The Korean Sociological Association
  • Research Area : Social Science > Sociology
  • Received : September 16, 2020
  • Accepted : November 25, 2020
  • Published : November 30, 2020

LANU KIM 1 Sue-Yeon Song 2

1Stanford University
2한국방송통신대학교 원격교육연구소

Excellent Accredited

ABSTRACT

Korean academia has sought to secure its own uniqueness differentiating it from global academia. Despite the constant debate over the academic dependency of non-Western scholars on Western academia, there has been little substantive evidence showing whether Korean academia is subordinate to global academia or whether it has developed its own distinctive knowledge discourses. Analysis of this topic is particularly important because the current university evaluation system often provides strong incentives for scholars to publish in journals indexed in the SSCI. If Korean academia features distinctive knowledge structures compared to international academia, then the emphasis on producing SSCI publications may actually be undermining the uniqueness of Korean academia by incentivizing Korean scholars to follow international trends. By analyzing all published research articles in the field of sociology collected from both KCI and SSCI-indexed journals between 2011 and 2018, we compare the similarities and differences of the knowledge discourse structures of Korean and international sociology, focusing on three key points: shared terms, topic distribution, and networks of topics. Our results show that Korean and international academia share rather few academic terms, that there are distinct differences in the topics of interest between KCI and SSCI. Also, our results demonstrate that Korean sociology produces knowledge discourses in response to the changing needs of Korean society, and that Korean academia connects topics in different ways than international academia. In light of these findings, we discuss the role of scholars and scholarship with respect to the development of Korean academia.

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.