Government Trust and Policy Response - Application of Hirschman’s Exit - Voice - Loyalty (EVL) Concept -  (정부신뢰와 정책반응 - Hirschman의 EVL(Exit, Voice &amp; Loyalty) 개념의 적용 - )

KIM, CHONG HO (김종호); Jaesun Wang (왕재선)

Government Trust and Policy Response - Application of Hirschman’s Exit - Voice - Loyalty (EVL) Concept -

Crisisonomy
Abbr : KRCEM
2016, 12(10), pp.15-37
Publisher : Crisis and Emergency Management: Theory and Praxis
Research Area : Social Science > Public Policy > Public Policy in general

KIM, CHONG HO ¹, Jaesun Wang ²

¹고려대학교
²호남대학교

Accredited

ABSTRACT

This study analyzed public trust in government and public response to nuclear energy policy in Korea, applying Hirschman’s exit-voice-loyalty (EVL) model. Especially, in order to complement the limitation of the existing studies, we considered trust in central government and local government separately. The results are as follows. First, various demographic variables affect positive perception on the degree of ‘Voice’, while the degrees of ‘Exit’ and ‘Loyalty’ are influenced by simple factors. Second, the possibility of ‘Exit’ was highest in the group of high-risk perception, while the highest possibility of ‘Voice’ was found in the group of low-risk perception. Lastly, the higher level of public trust in government, the lower possibility of ‘Exit’ and the higher possibility of ‘Loyalty’. In particular, we found that trust in local government is the core determinant of both ‘Exit’ and ‘Loyalty’ behaviors.

KEYWORDS

policy response behavior, EVL(Exit, Voice, Loyalty), trust, risk perception of nuclear power

Citation status

* References for papers published after 2023 are currently being built.

[journal] Barry, B. / 1974 / Review Article: Exit, Voice and Loyalty / British Journal of Political Science 4 : 79~107

[journal] Bella, D. A. / 1988 / Technocracy and Trust: Nuclear Waste Controversy / Journal of Professional Issues in Engineering 114 : 27~39

[journal] Chung, Ji Bum / 2009 / Competition, Economic Benefits, Trust, and Risk Perception in Siting a Potentially Hazardous Facility / Landscape and Urban Planning 19 : 8~16

[book] Cummings, L. L. / 1995 / Trust in Organizations / Oxford University Press

[journal] Dowding, K. / 2008 / The Three Exit, Three Voice and Loyalty Framework: A Test with Survey Data on Local Service / Political Studies 58 : 288~311

[journal] Dowding, K. / 2000 / Exit, Voice and Loyalty: Analytic and Empirical Developments / European Journal of Political Research 37 : 469~495

[journal] Evans, P. / 1996 / Government Action, Social Capital and Development:Reviewing the Evidence on Synergy / World Development 24 : 1119~1132

[journal] Fischhoff, B. / 1978 / How Safe Is Safe Enough? Apsychometric Study of Attitudes towards Technological Risks and Benefits / Policy Sciences 9 : 127~152

[journal] Flynn, J. / 1992 / Trust as a Determinant of Opposition to a High-level Radioactive Waste Repository: Analysis of a Structural Model / Risk Analysis 12(3) : 417~429

[journal] Frewer, L. J. / 1998 / Understanding Public Attitudes to Technology / Journal of Risk Research 1(3) : 221~235

[book] Hirschman, A. / 1970 / Exit, Voice and Loyalty: Responses to Decline in Firms, Organization and States / Harvard University Press

[journal] 정주용 / 2014 / Exploring multidimensionality of trust and social acceptance toward nuclear power energy / 한국행정학보 / 한국행정학회 48(4) : 51~78

[book] Kang, Myung Goo / 2005 / Exit, Voice and Loyalty: Respolses to Decline in Firms Organizations and States / Nanam Publishing House

[journal] 김서용 / 2005 / A Study of the Cultural Base of EVLN(Exit, Voice, Loyalty and Neglect) / 한국행정연구 / 한국행정연구원 14(3) : 73~102

[journal] 김서용 / 2009 / Exit or Voice: Empirical Studies of Tiebout's Hypothesis and Hirschman's Exit, Voice, Loyalty, and Neglect Model in Korea / 한국행정학보 / 한국행정학회 43(1) : 145~169

[journal] 김서용 / 2006 / Between Risk and Benefit: Analysis of Determinants of Acceptance About Radioactive Waste Facilities / 한국행정연구 / 한국행정연구원 15(3) : 297~330

[journal] Kim, Seo Yong / 2014 / Individual Perception vs. Structural Context: Searching for Multilevel Determinants of Social Acceptance of New Science and Technology Across 34 Countries / Science & Public Policy 44(1) : 44~57

[journal] 김서용 / 2007 / Beyond Risk and Benefit: Heuristic Effect of Experienced Affect on Acceptance of Nuclear Power Stations / 한국행정학보 / 한국행정학회 41(3) : 373~398

[journal] 이현국 / 2014 / A study of the relationship between perceived performance and trust in government / 한국행정학보 / 한국행정학회 48(4) : 1~22

[book] Luhmann, N. / 1980 / Trust and Power / Hohn Wiley & Sons

[journal] Lyons, W. E. / 1989 / Citizen Response to Dissatisfaction in Urban Communities: A Partial Test of a General Model / Journal of Politics 51(4) : 841~868

[journal] Orbell, J. M. / 1972 / Theory of Neighborhood Problem Solving: Political Action vs. Residential Mobility / American Political Science Review 66 : 471~489

[journal] 박정훈 / 2008 / Government Trust and Policy Support: The Case of National Electronic ID Policy / 행정논총 / 한국행정연구소 46(1) : 93~122

[report] Poortinga, W. / 2005 / Public Perceptions of Nuclear Power, Climate Change and Energy Options in Britain: Summary Findings of a Survey Conducted during October and November 2005 / School of Environmental Sciences University of East Anglia

[journal] Rahn, W. M. / 2005 / A Tale of Political Trust in American Cities / Public Opinion Quarterly 69(4) : 530~560

[journal] Rousseau, D. M. / 1998 / Introduction to Special Topic Forum: Not so Different after All: A Cross-Discipline View of Trust / The Academy of Management Review 23(3) : 393~404

[journal] Rusbult, C. E. / 1988 / Impact of Exchange Variables on Exit, Voice, Loyalty, and Neglect: an Integrative Model of Responses to Declining Job Satisfaction / Academy of Management Journal 31 : 599~627

[journal] Sharp, E. B. / 1984 / Exit, Voice and Loyalty in the Context of Local Government Problem / Western Political Quarterly 37 : 67~83

[journal] Siegrist, M. / 1999 / A Causal Model Explaining the Perception and Acceptance of Gene Technology / Journal of Applied Social Psychology 29 : 2093~2106

[journal] Sjöerg, L. / 2009 / Precautionary Attitudes and the Acceptance of a Local Nuclear Waste Repository / Safety Science 47 : 542~546

[journal] Slovic, P. / 1987 / Perception of Risk / Science 236(17) : 180~285

[journal] Slovic, P. / 1993 / Perceived Risk, Trust, and Democracy / Risk Analysis 13(6) : 675~682

[journal] Tiebout, C. / 1956 / A Pure Theory of Local Expenditures / Journal of Political Economy 64 : 416~424

[journal] 왕재선 / 2013 / Trust and Acceptance of Nuclear Energy / 한국정책학회보 / 한국정책학회 22(3) : 235~266

[journal] 왕재선 / 2011 / Multi-dimensionality of Perceptions on Science Technology and Its Determinants: The Case of Public Perceptions on Genetically Modified Food(GM Food) / 정부학연구 / 정부학연구소 17(1) : 145~185

[journal] Young, D. R. / 1974 / Exit and Voice in the Organization of Public Services / Social Science Information 13(3) : 49~65

KJCKorea
Journal Central

Crisisonomy 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.64