The Journal Of Korean Medical Classics 2023 KCI Impact Factor : 0.29
-
pISSN : 1229-8328 / eISSN : 2713-850X
- https://journal.kci.go.kr/jkmc
pISSN : 1229-8328 / eISSN : 2713-850X
[including in Instruction for Authors]
Review Regulation
7 (Role of Editing Committee)
① Editing committee manages all guidelines to scope and style of publication, number per issue, order in issue, appointment of examiner, etc.
8 (Hold of Editorial Committee)
① Chief editor holds editorial committee meeting(On-line meeting included) 4 times(or more) a year according to issue of journal.
9 (Consist of Editorial Committee)
① The editorial committee consist of 8 persons(or over) ; chief editor, executive editor, regional editing staffs, etc and 1 managing editor.
10 (The term of Editorial Membership)
① The chief and staff editors are elected to 2-year term and cloud be reappointed.
11 (Reviewers)
① 3 reviewers examine submitted manuscript.
② Reviewers are appointed by chief editor anonymously.
③ Reviewers are those ; present and former faculty at university, senior researcher at institute, experts corresponding professional field and so on.
④ Those of the same affiliation with the author cannot be appointed as reviewers.
⑤ In the case of submission by those in the editorial committee, the author-editor will be excluded from the entire reviewing process including reviewer recommendation, appointment and evaluation, with additional measures for anonymity, fairness, and security maintenance of reviewer appointment.
⑥ The author(s) may notify the committee of reviewers they wish to avoid due to personal or academic reasons at the time of submission. The editor-in-chief will appoint reviewers with consideration to the request.
12 (Principles of Review)
① The editorial board reviews the suitability of article, review of former research, references, logicality, originality and so on.
② Reviewer’s criteria are Publication(A), Publication with Correction(B), Review after Revision(C) and Reject(D). The editors should describe the detail reasons for B, C and D decision.
③ The editorial committee summarizes the editors’ decisions and makes final decision according to the following principal.
AAA, AAB : Publication
AAC, ABB, ABC, BBB, BBC : Publication with Correction
AAD, ABD, ACD, ACC, BBD, BCC, CCC : Review after Revision
ADD, BCD, BDD, CCD, CDD, DDD : Reject
④ If the revised version of a manuscript that has been initially been evaluated as 'Review after Revision(C)' is not submitted by the due date, the committee may reject the manuscript.
13 (Correction Request)
① Author should faithfully comply with the correction request. If request rejected, editorial committee can withdrawal publication.
14 (Formal Objection)
① The author of the article can make the formal objection only once. On the article objected by author, editorial committee can hold review again through the editorial committee meeting. Review fee 40,000KRW will be charged additionally.